Tag: law classes online

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Cyber Laws in UAE, Australia And China

By: Apoorva B N

ABSTRACT

In the modern swift- moving world, computers and internet are no more a privilege. Internet facilities have become a necessity as it is the par on course for any individual’s life today. Today, we have achieved so many advancements in the technological arena that it is next to impossible to even imagine our lives without computers or the internet. Now that internet has made its way to almost every aspect of human life, along with its blessings are its share of dangers and threats that haunt individuals today. In order to regulate the use of internet and everything that comes with it, ‘Cyber law’ emerged as a necessary facet of law. Cyber law deals with disputes arising in the internet domain, including matters like data protection, privacy concerns, identity left, electronic signatures, information technology and security. As information technology is looking at advancements taking place at a rapid rate, law regarding its regulation also needs to be updated at the same rate. In India, the main legislation that seeks to regulate information technology and related aspects is the Information Technology Act, 2000. Various amendments are being made to this legislation from time to time to be on par with the technological advancements that are taking place in the IT field. Similarly, this article aims to get an understanding and a brief analysis of the cyber laws of other jurisdictions like UAE, Australia and China.

INTRODUCTION TO INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (IT)

Technological advancement is one of the most important factors contributing to a country’s economy. It also brings about modern rapid changes to the social lives of the individuals. Advancement in technology and science brings about rapid growth in employment opportunities thereby increasing the GDP of the country that enriches the economy as a whole. Information Technology is the study and use of computer systems to store, retrieve and send information.[1] In order to regulate information technology, especially facets of it including internet law, information and digital security, IT law or cyber law has emerged as a necessary aspect of law.

Learn more about Cyber Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

CYBER LAWS IN UAE

UAE is said to be the most digitally advanced Arab country. It had also made its place in the top 20 digital economies in 2018[2]. In 2017, two breakthrough digital initiatives, the Dubai Internet of Things (IoT) Strategy and the Digital Wealth Initiative, were launched[3]. Securing an important position in the word for being digitally advanced, UAE has its own set of cyber security laws for the regulation of the cyber threats and like offences that form a part of any technological advancement. Therefore, the UAE has a comprehensive legislation on cyber laws called the ‘Cyber Crimes Law 2012’ (UAE-Law No. 5 of 2012)[4]. Few of the important offences and penalties that are covered under this legislation are—

  • Promoting or publishing pornographic material or indecent act and gambling activities.
  • Publishing of others information and photos on internet
  • Violating others privacy by eavesdropping and publishing the information using the social media
  • Human Trafficking
  • Data Forgery of prohibitive data
  • Unauthorized use and interception of computer services

Penalties for imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years and a fine up to 200,000 AED.

The National Electronic Security Authority (‘NESA’) implements the Cyber Law and regulates the protection of communications networks and information systems in the UAE.[5] The Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (‘TRA’) was established by the Telecommunications Law to supervise the telecommunications division in the UAE. The TRA set up the Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT) to advance the standards of information security and protect the IT set-up.

Information Security Regulation (ISR) standards from Dubai Smart Government mandates government entities in Dubai to implement requirements and controls stated in the standard to ensure appropriate level of confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information assets.[6]

These were the key features of the Cyber law infrastructure in the UAE.

Learn more about Cyber Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

CYBER LAWS IN AUSTRALIA

The legislations that deal with cyber and Information technology laws in Australia are as follows[7]—

  1. Australian Privacy Principles (APP): It is an amendment made to the Privacy Act, 1983 including various other amendments like—
  • The Privacy and data protection Acts, 2014-Victoria ;
  • Privacy and data protection Act, 1998– New south Wales;
  • Privacy and information Act, 2009– Queensland;
  • Personal information Privacy Act, 2004– Tasmania;
  • Information privacy Act, 2014– Australian capital territory;
  • Information Act, 2002– Northern territory.
  1. The Cybercrime Act, 1995: In August 2012, the Government passed the Cybercrime Legislation Amendment Act 2012(Cth) (CLAA). The purpose of the CLAA was to empower Australia to assent to the Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime (Cybercrime Convention), the only international treaty on cybercrime. The Cyber Crime Act, 1995 was very much based on the international convention on cybercrime and it contains various offences relating to the unauthorised access, modification, or impairment of data and restricted data (sections 477.1, 477.2 and 478.1 of the Criminal Code).
  2. TELECOMMUNICATION ACT, 1997—The main objective of this legislation is to protect the privacy of individuals who use Australian telecommunication systems related to real time communications.[8]

These were the key Cyber law legislations of Australia and their objectives.

When it comes to high tech crime or cybercrimes of national importance, the accountability of investigation and response is conferred to Australian Federal Police (AFP). They possess jurisdiction over cases of cybercrime concerning online frauds affecting any governmental institution. Their jurisdiction further ranges to the investigation of cases related to virtual child sex harassment and exploitation, child protection and tourist child sex offenders.[9]

The Director of Public Prosecutions prosecutes on violations relating to unauthorised admission to data, damage caused to electronic communication and use of carriage services to harass or cause a wrongdoing, within sections 478.1(1), 477.3(1) and 474.17 of the Criminal Code (Cth).[10]

The New South Wales Police are conferred with powers to investigate and prosecute online fraudsters in offences in areas like internet banking, mobile banking, phishing, mule recruitment, shopping and auction site fraud, scams, spam and identity theft, child sexual exploitation and cyber bullying offences.[11]

Learn more about Cyber Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

CYBER LAWS IN CHINA

The Chinese Government has always laid emphasis on the advancement in science and technology. Their innovation model includes huge projects in areas like Nano Technology, biotechnology, aircrafts, high-end generic microchips etc. Cybersecurity law of the People’s Republic of China was enacted by the e Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress on November 7, 2016 and was enforced on June 1, 2017. The key features of the cyber law of China are as under[12]—

  1. Security obligations of ISPs
  2. Rules for the transnational transmission of data at critical information infrastructure
  3. Rules for personal information protection
  4. Principle of cyberspace sovereignty

It also provides intricate rules and definitions on legal liability for various unlawful conducts, and sets a range of punishments like fines, suspension for modification, withdrawal of licenses and commercial licenses among others. The law therefore enforces cybersecurity and administrative authorities with powers and duties to implement the law against illegal activities.

Relevant cases in China[13]—

Sina Weibo v. Maimai (2016) was the first unfair competition case concerning big data analytics in China. The central issue for the court to decide was whether the alleged “unauthorized collection and use of data” and its related activities constitute unfair competition under the Anti- Unfair Competition Law. The case is a landmark decision to address one of the important questions on competition for data resources in the internet industry: to what extent data scraping (both personal data and other data) targeting a competitor could be potentially caught by the rules of unfair competition.

Tencent v. Douyin (2019) – case concerning the ownership of users’ ID, nicknames and profile pictures.

Facts: Douyin had entered into a Developer Agreement with WeChat and QQ platforms, and had access to users’ WeChat and QQ IDs, nicknames and profile pictures. Douyin had shared those data with Duoshan, a social networking product run by its affiliate. WeChat and QQ platforms claimed that the unauthorized use of IDs, nicknames and profile pictures of their users constitute unfair competition. The court granted a temporary injunction restraining Douyin from using those user data until the date of final judgment. It remains to be seen whether the court would consider the case following the same logic of the Maimai case.

Learn more about Cyber Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

CONCLUSION

We can therefore conclude on being able to have understood the meaning and importance of information technology and how it has become an inevitable and a significant aspect of human life today. We also understood the IT laws or cyber laws that are codified in various jurisdiction across the world, like UAE, Australia and China. By the above stated information, it is safe for us to conclude that among the countries whose cyber laws have been discussed in this article, China appears to be the most technologically advanced country thereby making it better equipped in IT or cyber laws to regulate the threats that will be posed with technological advancements. Secondly, UAE is also seen to have been making efforts and taking efficient steps to get their IT or Cyber law infrastructure well- equipped. Australia appears to be relatively backward in terms of technological advancements in comparison with China and UAE. But Australia’s latest technological advancements have given rise to good legal backing by way of the cyber law legislation of the country.

Learn more about Cyber Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

[1] ‘WHAT EXACTLY IS INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (IT)’, workforce.com, https://www.workforce.com/news/what-exactly-is-information-technology-it

[2] CLEOFE MACEDA, ‘UAE MOST DIGITALLY ADVANCED IN ARAB WORLD’, GULFNEWS, https://gulfnews.com/technology/uae-most-digitally-advanced-in-arab-world-1.2239034

[3] Ibid.

[4] BASSAM ZA’ZA’, ‘UNDERSTANDING UAE’S CYBERCRIME LAW AND PENALTIES’, GOING OUT, SEPTEMBER 12, 2015 07:00, https://gulfnews.com/going-out/society/understanding-uaes-cybercrime-law-and-penalties-1.1564565#:~:text=the%20uae%20cybercrime%20law%20no,and%20seriousness%20of%20the%20cybercrime.

[5] IBID.

[6] COMPLIANCE AND DATA PROTECTION SERVICE, RNS TECHNOLOGY SERVICES, https://www.rnstechnology.com/compliance-data-protection/#:~:text=information%20security%20regulation%20(isr)%20standards,compliance%20with%20local%20regulations

[7] KING & WOOD MALLESONS, ‘AUSTRALIA’S CYBERCRIME LEGISLATION’, LEXOLOGY, https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=4ab62fdd-f177-47eb-b02d-e327cf9833a9

[8] “Cybercrime Laws in Australia.” lawteacher.net. 11 2018. All Answers Ltd. 12 2020 https://www.lawteacher.net/free-law-essays/australian-law/cybercrime-laws-in-australia-8255.php?vref=1

[9] PAVUL LEGAL, ‘CYBERCRIME LAW IN AUSTRALIA’, PAVUK, 2 June 2018, https://www.pavuklegal.com/cybercrime-law-in-australia/

[10] PAVUL LEGAL, ‘CYBERCRIME LAW IN AUSTRALIA’, PAVUK, 2 June 2018, https://www.pavuklegal.com/cybercrime-law-in-australia/

[11] Ibid.

[12] LAUREN MARANTO, ‘WHO BENEFITS FROM CHINA’S CYBERSECURITY LAWS?’, CSIS, https://www.csis.org/blogs/new-perspectives-asia/who-benefits-chinas-cybersecurity-laws#:~:text=In%20June%202017%2C%20the%20China,for%20China’s%20present%20day%20guidelines.&text=The%20law%20requires%20that%20data,to%20government%2Dconducted%20security%20checks.

[13] Recent privacy case law update in China, Dentons, file:///C:/Users/Apoorva%20Narendranath/Downloads/8b0990bc-f987-428d-b3c1-4eea30fbce82.pdf

Categories
Blog

Copyright Licensing Agreement and the Clauses Covered Under It- An Analysis

By: Darshi Sanghvi

What is copyright licensing?

In India, copyright is known by and large as an ownership right offered by law to creators, for instance, of artistic work, cinematography, literature and sound recordings. In other words, it is a protection provided to creators of work in the form of an acknowledgement for their intellectual contribution. The primary objective of any copyright is to protect the interest of the creator, besides the dissemination of knowledge that is carried out. An often undiscovered fact is amidst other benefits; economic rights also enable a creator to reap economic benefits from his intellectual creations. As per the Copyright Act of 1957, there are different rights in place, pertaining to the nature of the work undertaken. It is further pertinent to note that it is the exclusive right of the owner to do or authorise doing any of the acts covered thereon.[1]

Learn more about Intellectual Property Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

The copyright framework permits not only the communication of work, but also its reproduction, translation and adaption. Thus, the owner of the copyright work is given the opportunity of generating wealth not just by exploiting it himself, but also by sharing it with the public at large for mutual benefits. This is where copyright assignment and licensing come into play.  A distinction may be drawn between licensing and assignment, in terms of the fact that through licensing, the licensee is granted rights on the basis of certain conditions, however their ownership is not vested in the licensee. On the other hand, in an assignment, the assignee is regarded as the owner of the interest assigned to him.

Through copyright licensing, the licensor grants a license to the licensee, thereby authorising the use of the said copyright by such a licensee. The licensee is thus provided with the adequate protection and spared from the claim of infringement unauthorised use that may be made by the licensor otherwise.

Furthermore, the term ‘Exclusive License’ is elaborated in the Copyright Act to comprise of licenses that confer, on the licensee or any other person duly authorised by him, any right pertaining to the copyright of the work, excluding all the other persons.[2]

In exchange of a consideration, a copyright owner may choose to transfer some or all of his rights to others for the purpose of seeking monetary benefits. A license may either be said to be exclusive, or non-exclusive.[3]

Learn more about Intellectual Property Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

What is a copyright licensing agreement?

In order to initiate licensing, a copyright owner enters into a contract, widely known as the Copyright Licensing Agreement. Through such a contract, the copyright owners permit another individual or organization to use their work in several ways, for instance:

  • For reprinting
  • For distribution
  • For using it over a specified period of time[4]

In a nutshell, it is an agreement that throws light on how, why, when and where a copyrighted work can be capable of being used.

Types of copyright licensing agreements

  • Voluntary License – The author, also known as the Copyright owner, is said to have exclusive rights with regard to his creative work and has the sole right to grant license in that respect. The Copyright Act 1957[5] provides that the owner of the copyright may grant the interest in his copyright through a license in writing, which must be signed by him or an agent duly authorised by him to do so. Such a license can be granted with respect to existing as well as future work. A voluntary license may be exclusive, non-exclusive, sole or implied.
  • Compulsory License[6]– As a part of the Berne Convention[7], India has taken a step towards the incorporation of a compulsory license under the Copyright Act 1957. The term “compulsory license” is used to mean a statutory license that provides an exclusive right to do an act without the prior permission of the copyright owner/ author. Section 31 covers the compulsory licensing of copyrighted work that is withheld from the public.

Important clauses to be included in Copyright Licensing Agreements

An agreement begins by stating the date and place of its execution and further proceeds towards identifying the contracting parties. This lays the foundation for the following clauses that are particular to the property or rights that are granted.

  • Recitals: This clause is considered essential for any form of agreement as it is used to provide a gist about the contracting parties. This clause sets forth the relationship of the parties up to the stage before which the agreement came into being. A well-drafted recital plays its part in clearly expounding the context of the agreement to any reader, thus enabling a person unknown to the agreement to comprehend it better. Nevertheless, it also clarifies the fact that the binding clauses of the agreement are to be included in the coming clauses and not the recital itself.
  • Definition: This clause is equivalent to a dictionary for the purpose of the agreement. It elucidates all the terms of immense importance to the agreement, which play an important role in determining the rights and obligations of the parties. Definitions can additionally be used for the purpose of restricting the scope of the agreement. A precise description of the terms like “licensed patents”, “use”, “royalty”, “revenue” etc. can be found within this clause.
  • Rights Grant/ Grant of license: This clause plays a significant role in enabling the parties to understand the extent to which the license extends. The Rights Grant clause irons out the significance of the rights granted by the Licensor to the Licensee. The said clause states several points like the “Exclusivity of the license”, “right to use”, “restrictions on use” and “limitations- geographical and political”. Most importantly, it acts as a guide by specifying “who gets what”. The clause clarifies that the Artist retains his right to reproduce his work and that the license remains with the artist and does not affect the ownership of the copyrighted work.
  • Indemnification: In the event of any litigation risk or loss arising on one party as a result of the act of another or due to the existence of any defect in the license granted or the ownership of the copyright, it is essential to discuss the specifics of who will be indemnified and who will be the indemnifier if such a risk comes true. In other words, this clause provides the right to the party suffering due to the act of another party to call upon him to indemnify the suffering party for any loss that may have incurred.
  • Consideration: Consideration forms an essential part of any contract, unless it is expressly mentioned otherwise. The consideration clause of a license agreement cites the amount of consideration that a licensee is required to pay to the licensor, in the form of royalties. The clause further sets out the method by which such royalties are to be calculated. According to most of the agreements, the royalties paid are based on the profit made by the licensee by exploiting the license. Besides such a royalty, the licensor is also entitled to demand a fixed license fee to be paid, which can be taken separately from the royalty. Both, the fee and the royalty depend on a number of factors, for instance, the use of work, the Artist’s reputation, the scope of the license, so on and so forth. The licensor also possesses the right to formulate a condition obligating the licensee to keep track of the sales made by him and to show the licensor such audit reports that shall be prepared by him.
  • Obligations of the Parties: Every party contracting under a license agreement has certain obligations towards each other which differ and are over and above the aforementioned clauses. These obligations involve making disclosures with respect to the information which is required to be known by both the licensor and licensee; in case the grant is of an exclusive license then the licensor agrees not to exploit the exclusivity granted to him thereunder; and may also contain a clause that obligates the licensee to exploit the copyrighted property in a manner that enables him to make the most of the license granted to him, much more so in case of exclusive license which exclusively grants him the license to exploit particular copyrighted work.

Learn more about Intellectual Property Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

  • Alterations and modifications: Alterations or modifications of any sort that may be made by the licensee must first be granted under the rights grant clause. If, upon granting any such right, modifications are made in the work, then the licensor might demand to be the owner of such property post the requisite improvement and shall then assign such improved property under another license with identical conditions as the previous agreement. Under certain circumstances, the licensee might seek to retain the ownership of the improved property, and then the licensor might obtain a license from the licensee for the purpose of including the modified part in his original work.
  • Term and termination: This clause lays down the period for which a license is granted to the licensee, the focus being on the date when it comes into force and the date on which it ceases to exist. Such a license possesses the scope of being renewed from time to time, subject to the conditions as specified under the agreement or at the will of parties. Term of the license is finalised by the concerned parties bearing in mind their respective benefits. Termination of an agreement is by and large based on two factors: at convenience and for cause. More often than not, parties don’t prefer granting the opposite party a right to terminate the contract at convenience as it may lead to a loss to the other party who might have invested a huge amount of money with a view of exploiting the licensee or the granted rights. One party is entitled to immediately terminate the agreement, if the other party does an act that is considered as a breach of any term of the agreement. This clause also puts out the consequences of termination of the license for any reason whatsoever. Nevertheless, in case of termination of the agreement at convenience, the party bringing about the termination of the agreement can, under obligation, be compelled to give a prior notice of certain period before such termination is implemented.
  • Dispute Resolution: In case of any dispute arising between the parties with regard to any breach of the agreement or any other reason pertaining to the license. Majority of the agreements elucidate the process to be followed in case of a conflict. The form of dispute resolution that must be opted for, can be decided at the discretion of the parties, which can be chosen from normal litigation, arbitration, mediation, and conciliation. The parties are at their will to decide the manner of dispute resolution and the law governing them.[8]

This is a non-exhaustive list of clauses essential to the agreement entered into between a copyright owner and the person seeking rights to reproduce or perform that copyrighted work. Copyright license agreement should be drafted, bearing in mind the protection of the rights of the Licensor as well as the Licensee. Furthermore, each clause must stipulate the rights, obligations, and limitations expressly, such that any future misunderstandings and misconceptions can be avoided on the part of the parties.

Learn more about Intellectual Property Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified Diploma course by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

 

[1] Section 14 of Copyright Act 1957

[2] Section 2(j) of Copyright Act 1957

[3] https://ssrana.in/ip-laws/copyright-law-india/copyright-licensing-in-india/

[4] https://vakilsearch.com/advice/copyrights-in-india-how-to-assign-and-license-a-copyright/

[5] Section 30 of Copyright Act 1957

[6] Section 31 of Copyright Act 1957

[7] Article 9(2) of Berne Convention

[8] https://www.gspkendra.com/2018/12/27/most-important-clauses-in-a-copyright-licensing-agreement

Categories
Blog

E- Sports Player Contracts and the Clauses Covered Under It

By: Manohar Samal

  1. Introduction 

Electronic sports (e- sports) involves playing computer or other games for profit where fans view the gaming and place wagers depending upon the skills of the players indulged in such games.[1] Not only wagers but, e- sports generate revenues through live streaming of players as well.[2] Reportedly, 380 million people worldwide were indulged in watching some or other form of e- sports making it a billion dollar industry.[3] The growth and evolution of e- sports into a money- making industry has resulted in exploration of new possibilities in the legal field such as its operation with legal endorsements, intellectual property and contracts.[4]

Contract law plays an extremely central role in e- sports and contracts for teams, players, tournament leaders and leagues should be well- drafted in place. This is mainly because during the initial years of e- sports turning into a profitable industry, exploitation and late payment of consideration were common occurrences.[5] One of the most vital contracts in e- sports is the endorsement contract as many players have faced difficulties in such forms of contracts in the past.[6]

Albeit the fact that the e- sports sector has colossally grown within the past decade worldwide and in India, the regulatory system seems to be lackadaisical in this field.[7] India does not have any law on regulating e- sports and only a Private Member Bill titled Sports (Online Gaming and Prevention of Fraud) Bill has been introduced before the Lok Sabha till date.[8]

Learn more about International Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Krida Legal!

  1. E- Sports Player Contracts and the Clauses Covered Under It 

Traditional sports have well- regulated systems with contractual stability.[9] However, the same thing cannot be said about e- sports. Since there is no principal legislation or effective regulation, contract based relationships govern the entire e- sports industry.[10] Therefore, it would not be wrong to infer that contract law plays a pivotal and colossal role in the e- sports industry. Due to the various difficulties faced by players in the past, it is important that certain contract clauses work in their favor and towards the interest of the e- sports game at large. This would naturally mean that e- sports player contracts will have to contain some indispensable content and clauses and these clauses have been enlisted below:[11]

  1. Definitions Clause- The definitions clause is an indispensable clause in any contract. This would also include e- sports player contracts since a definition clause helps in explaining the exact meaning of the terminology or nomenclature used in the contract which can result in reduced risk of future litigation in interpretation related matters as all ambiguities are eliminated after looking at the definitions clause.
  2. Player Services Clause- All the services which are going to be provided by the player have to be clearly specified in the e- sports player contract. This would include all services provided by the player in addition to participating and playing in competitions, leagues or tournaments such as social media promotion and creation and promotion of video content (vlogging). This clause would also have to cover the hours of engagement which is agreed upon by the player and the respective contractor.
  3. Player Obligations Clause- E- sports player contract needs to contain an exhaustive list of obligations which the player is expected to carry out. This would include details in respect of tournaments which the player will participate in, the teams which will accompany and instruct the player, the amount of promotion required to be done by the player in sponsor events, the apparel and accessories to be worn by the player and the hours of training in which the player is expected to indulge. The player obligations clause is pivotal because it results in clear indication of the players obligations preventing any form of exploitation.
  4. Player Restrictions Clause- The player restrictions clause is responsible for explicating the restrictions and limitations which the player has to adhere to. This clause includes factors and concomitants such as restriction from playing in tournaments without the team or the contractor’s permission, restriction to promote competitors’ or their sponsors and for specifying a code of conduct for players to observe during the tenure of the contract.
  5. Non- Disparagement Clause- A non- disparagement clause offers protection to teams and sponsors from defamatory remarks made by a player and is an indispensable part of an e- sports player contract.
  6. Remuneration and Allowances Clause- Details of the remuneration paid or going to be paid to the player has to be specified under this clause. Moreover, all benefits, allowances and bonuses arising in the course of the contract will also have to be specified under this clause.

Learn more about International Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Krida Legal!

  1. Image Rights Clause- This clause covers a unique aspect known as image rights. An image right is the right associated with the player due to his or her skills which a team or the contractor can use during the course of contract.[12] Such image rights include name, appearance, voice, in- game avatar or gamer tag. This clause is paramount since it could lead to the player being additionally compensated or paid for allowing exploitation and utilisation of his or her image rights.
  2. Equipment Clause- The equipment going to be supplied, types and forms, restrictions and permissions to use and similar connected matters have to be covered under the equipment clause. This is mainly because the equipment has a great role to play in the player’s success while participating in a tournament or league or competition.
  3. Revenue Sharing Clause- The revenue sharing clauses contains facts about the amount of extra revenue which will be shared with the players from the sale of merchandise, sale of in- game items, revenue generated out of streaming and prize money earned. Since revenue sharing from additional sources has been a controversy leading to litigation and conflict amongst the team and the players, it is vital that this clause is drafted properly where clear specifications about percentage of revenue sharing is stipulated.
  4. Roster Management Clause- Roster management clause is a key clause in an e- sports player contract. This is mainly because roster management strategy of the team can directly affect a player’s career. Roster management is a process which involves strategising the use of player resources by the team.[13] Therefore, it would contain information such as players going to initiate playing during the tournament, league or competition and the number of substitute players. The time duration after which each substitute will be allowed to play is also covered under the roster management clause of an e- sports player contract.

Learn more about International Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Krida Legal!

  1. Termination and Renewal Clause– The termination and renewal clause is an indispensable clause in an e- sports player contract. This clause contains aspects of compensation in case pre- termination of contract takes place and quantification of value of the remaining contract period of a player in proportion to the investments made by the contractor in such player. Post- termination obligations and duties are also covered under this clause such as deletion of data, return of equipment and non- disparagement. Non- compete and non- acceptance of any other team or contractor’s offer is also covered under this clause. Renewal related aspects are also covered under this clause. This is an important clause to keep the player’s conduct in check and also helps the player in understanding his or her restrictions. Such clauses are also known as buyout clauses.[14]
  2. Loans Clause- Unlike the common meaning assigned to the term “loan”, in an e- sports contract, loans are not even remotely related to bank loans and instead refer to loaning of members to other teams. It may arise that teams may enter into arrangements for exchange and loaning of players. This is why it is important that the loans clause is drafted properly so that any form of legal dispute between teams does not arise. The loans clause contains information such as the duration of loans, functions to be performed by the loaned player, restrictions and permissions to the loanee team and other assignment details.
  3. Governing Law and Disputes Resolution Clause- The governing law and disputes resolution clause affirms the jurisdiction whose law will govern the contract[15] and the court, tribunal or forum which will be preferred in case any sort of dispute arises between the team, sponsors or players. The location of such preferred court, tribunal or forum is also specified under the governing law and disputes resolution clause.
  1. Confidentiality Clause- The confidentiality clause is a pivotal clause in any contract. Similarly, confidentiality clauses have significance in e- sports player contracts as well. This is because aspects such as team plans, resources and strategy are delicate information which could lead to the success or loss of teams in e- sports. Therefore, it is important to protect it through a confidentiality or non- disclosure clause. The scope of confidentiality, permissible disclosure and related aspects are covered under the confidentiality clause of an e- sports player contract.

Learn more about International Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Krida Legal!

  1. Conclusion

 Hence, the above discussions pristinely explicate the role of an e- sports player contract in the smooth conduct and success of e- sports games along with showcasing the clauses which are covered under such forms of contract.

[1] USC Gould School of Law. “eSPorts Law Growth”. USC Gould Online Blog. (2020). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://onlinellm.usc.edu/blog/esports-law-growth/>.

[2] Willingham, AJ. “What is eSports? A Look at an Expensive Billion Dollar Industry”. CNN Edition. (27 August 2018). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://edition.cnn.com/2018/08/27/us/esports-what-is-video-game-professional-league-madden-trnd/index.html>.

[3] Ibid.

[4] Ibid 1.

[5] Ibid 1.

[6] Ibid 1.

[7] Verma, Bhumesh and Srivastava Stuti. “Regulating E- Sports- An Opportunity and a Challenge”. RGNUL Student Research Review. (05 July 2019). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <http://rsrr.in/2019/07/05/regulating-e-sports-an-opportunity-and-a-challenge/>.

[8] Ibid.

[9] Rastogi, Anirudh and Ranjit, Vishakh. “E- Sports Player Contracts: Common Clauses and Potential Legal Issues in India”. Mondaq. (18 June 2020). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://www.mondaq.com/india/gaming/955392/e-sports-player-contracts-common-clauses-and-potential-legal-issues-in-india>.

[10] Ibid.

[11] Ibid.

[12] Vrey, Rogier and Wilms, Tim. “eSports and Image Rights”. CMS Law. (17 August 2017). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://cms.law/en/nld/publication/esports-and-image-rights>.

[13] Roundhill Investments. “E- Sports Glossary”. Roundhill Investments. (2020). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://www.roundhillinvestments.com/esports-glossary>.

[14] Lewin, Pete. “Why Every Esports PLayer Needs a Contract”. The ESports Observer. (21 November 2016). [online] [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://esportsobserver.com/every-esports-player-needs-contract/>.  

[15] Contractbook. “Electronic Sports (eSports) Player Contract (EU)”. Contractbook. (2020). [online]. [last accessed on 15 August 2020]. Available from: <https://contractbook.com/templates/electronic-sports-esports-player-information-eu>.

Learn more about International Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Krida Legal!

Categories
Blog

Digital Forensics and Law Enforcement

By: Prabha Devi Ganesan

INTRODUCTION

Digital Forensics is also defined as the science of identifying, preserving, analyzing and reporting of any evidence stored in the digital media like computer, network, server and mobile device. The documents of the evidence which are collected from the storage media computer system or any digital device can be used as evidence in the court. Before performing a forensic investigation a digital forensic examiner must understand various concepts in forensic.

People who can involve at the time of investigation are

  1. First responder
  2. Forensic investigators
  3. Court expert witness
  4. Law enforcement personnel

Process of Digital Forensics

  1. Identification -The first process of digital forensic is that what kind of evidence is present and also identifying the format and finding out where it is stored in the computer or mobile device.
  2. Preservation – It means that all the data is isolated, preserved and secured from using the digital device.
  3. Analysis – Based on the evidence found the fragments of data are reconstructed and the conclusion is being drawn as a conclusion. It also tells that how was it taken place.
  4. Reporting – It is like reconstructing all the crime scene and reviewing it with proper photograph, sketching and mapping the crime scene
  5. Presentation – This is the last process and all the above process are being summarized in this process and explained and put to a conclusion. The terms should be written in a abstracted terminologies

Learn more about Digital Forensics with Enhelion’s Online  certified course certified by Obsidian!

Principles of digital evidence can be gathered digitally from the messages that are sent via phone, email internal history, computer files, images and instant messages. It can also be from the sources like desktop computers, laptops, mobile devices and cloud.

Main objectives

It helps to find the identity of the suspect or the culprit. Reconstructing the procedures at the crime scene may help to ensure that digital evidence which is obtained is not being altered or corrupted. It also helps to identify the evidence at short period of time and also gives overview of any malicious activity involved. It also helps to find the motive behind the crime scene. Process of computer forensic report gives a complete documentation on the investigation process. All the evidence is preserved by following chain of custody.

In case of confiscating a computer, expert forensic examiner must be called. The expert is called to ensure that any criminal actions doesn’t get lost or damaged if the computer is switched off. Pictures of the data that is currently being displayed on the screen and when the computer system is taken into custody when the server system is off because when the server system is off, the data saved can be damaged or disrupted from the services provided to the customers. As soon as the mobile is being confiscated it must be switched off and battery must be removed it is to make sure that the recent call information and cell tower remains unchanged. Once if it is off we shouldn’t turn it on because it may change the information on the device. A remote command can be sent without the knowledge of the investigator if the attacker gets to know about the mobile device is on. The mobile must be kept off because there are many other chances where it can be switch on easily. All the evidence which is collected is kept in FARADAY BAGS or other materials used when isolating a mobile device.  We should turn on flight mode. Turn off WIFI. Turn off Bluetooth. NFC or other communications system must be off. To prevent static electricity it can be kept in a material where there is no passage of electric current like paper bag, paper made out if cardboard and any envelope made up of paper.

Learn more about Digital Forensics with Enhelion’s Online  certified course certified by Obsidian!

LAW ENFORCEMENT

Computer based evidence have common in court proceedings and also it consists of many important information for computer for intelligence than the law enforcement. There is much enforcement of techniques that law enforcement is not being known. Digital forensics is involved in the commercial organizations   in case of any disputes regarding the employment, wrong or fraud investigation and intellectual property theft bankruptcy etc.

CASE LAW 1:  (CREDIT CARD FRAUD)

STATE OF TAMILNADU VS THE MANAGER OF BPO ORGANIZATIONS (BUSINESS PROCESS OUTSOURCING)

FACTS OF CASE: The manager with the fraud control unit of BPO filed a complaint stating that two of his employees has conspired with the credit card holder and manipulated the credit card limit and as a result they cheated the company of INR 0.72 million. After the investigation they have seized six mobile phones, imported wrist watches, jewelers, credit cards and leather accessories all worth of INR0.3 million and cash INR 25000. They also informed the company of the security lapses in their software so that cases like this could not be repeated in the future. This case has won the second runner-up position for India Cyber Cop Award for its investigating. It was also stated that the case was remarkable by the investigating team of the business process and its use in collecting digital evidence.

CASE LAW 2: (BLACKMAILING)

STATE OF MAHARASTRA VS THE NRI (NON-RESIDENT INDIAN)

FACTS OF THE CASE: the accused was a NRI was working in Dubai she posed to a young girl living in Kolkata to enter into Han email correspondence. The accused started corresponding with the complainant using different email IDs with different female names which made the complainant believe that he was corresponding with different girls. Later on the accused asked for money and gifts and also sexual favors from the girls whom he was corresponding with. The accused started blackmailing the complainant referring to the email exchanges and she was made to believe that one of the girl committed suicide and sent fake copies of high court of Calcutta he also paid the bribe for the officials who supposedly investigating and compensate the family. This case won the first runner-up position India Cyber Cop Award for its investigating

Coming to the network forensics it involves HEX CODES AND ASCII CODES

ASCII CODES – AMERICAN STANDARD CODE FOR INFORMATION INETRCHANGE

When we take forensics it is also important to know about the number system fundamental. It is for the understanding the machine. There are 4 types they are binary, octal, decimal and hexadecimal

Binary number

Base -2

Symbols- (1-0)

Octal number

Base – 8

Digits – (0-7)

Decimal number

Base -10

Standard number is always 10

Hexadecimal number

Base – 16

Digits – (0-9)

Characters – A to f

OFFSET – It indicates the distance between the starting or beginning of the object and a given element or point with the same object.

FILE SYSTEM FORENSICS

The Identification, collection and analysis of digital evidence from different types of storage media is known as FILE SYSTEM FORENSICS. There are many concepts that relates to the file system

 

Firstly,

Hard disk – data can be hidden on the maintenance track or it can be protected or preserved in a protected area on the hard disk which is also known as evidence collection tool

File allocation table (FAT) and Master File table (MFT) in New Technology File System (NTFS) are to keep a track of files present in the storage media

Deleted files are removed from the file system table even though it looks like it has been deleted from the hard disk and looks like it doesn’t appear in the hard disk anymore and the clusters which are being deleted allows the other files to save or store data. There are different ways to recover the data using certain techniques we can use hex format   when we are using hex format we should start from the starting or beginning and end of the file. We should copy it in a text file. After saving it in a text file it has to be saved in an appropriate file extension.

PARTITION TABLE

It is the Master boot record. It enables a computer system to know how the hard drive is being organized particular partition are being erased but still it is being stored in the hard drive.

 

SLACK SPACE

The data is hidden in a random data is called ram slack found left over at the end of the volume. If the data are being deleted and if the clusters are not being stored it can be used in to store the data, and also the data which is deleted can be restored. It is mainly to hide the data in the storage media in a computer.

Learn more about Digital Forensics with Enhelion’s Online  certified course certified by Obsidian!

FREE SPACE

The space which is being created are being obtained after the deletion of the file which is been deleted from the original partition is called free space

FAKED BAD CLUSTERS

The data can also be stored in cluster that are named as bad and master file table which is names as badclus contains the information about the bad clusters present in NTFS file system. Size of file system is equivalent to the size of the volume. It is used to hide the size of the data stored on volume by a suspect

FAT 32 – 1996

It is mainly used in DOS and windows operating system before windows XP. 32 in the FAT32 represent the 32 bit number to depict cluster value. It accommodates 2^32. Newer hard drive don’t use FAT32

It gives a idea about where a particular file is stored it is also considered to be very simple when compared to NTFS file system.

NTFS

It’s a newer file system than FAT32

It is being used in Window NT & 2006

It has 512 byte record called boot record

It is used to read the information regarding the partition present on the file system and other relevant information that is used by the operating system to load properly

CONCLUSION

Digital forensic examination of electronic system has end up in a great success in the analysis of cyber and computer assisted crime and also it has equivalent importance on the appropriate incident management capabilities to handle misuse of systems.

Learn more about Digital Forensics with Enhelion’s Online  certified course certified by Obsidian!

Categories
Blog

Role of Consumer Protection Law in Medical Negligence cases

By: Sreyasi Sarma

Abstract

Medical profession is a noble profession. The connection between the patient and the specialist depends on shared trust and confidence. It is a helpful weapon of shopper to guarantee responsibility of specialist organizations. The patients have begun utilizing this Act, when they are abused by clinical carelessness of the medical services. Each specialist independent of the spot of his administration has an expert commitment to broaden his administration for ensuring life. Inadequacy might be consequence of powerlessness and absence of competency while carelessness would be brought about via lack of regard. In all instances of carelessness, there will be lack yet in all instances of inadequacy, carelessness won’t be available. The Indian legal executive has excellent help in securing and protecting the privileges of the customers just as sharpening the general public concerning the privileges of the customers. The analyst through some case laws endeavour to zero in upon the legal activism on clinical carelessness risk under the Consumer Protection Act.

Introduction:

Recently, Indian culture is encountering a developing mindfulness with respect to patient’s privileges. This pattern is unmistakably detectable from the ongoing spray in suit concerning clinical expert or foundation obligation, guaranteeing redressal for the enduring caused because of clinical carelessness, vitiated assent, and penetrate of privacy emerging out of the specialist persistent relationship. The patient-focused activity of rights assurance is needed to be acknowledged in the monetary setting of the fast decay of State spending and gigantic private interest in the circle of the medical services framework and the Indian Supreme Court’s meticulous endeavours to Constitutionalize a privilege to wellbeing as a principal right. Starting at now, the arbitrating cycle concerning clinical expert obligation, be it in a purchaser discussion or a normal common or criminal court, considers precedent-based law standards identifying with carelessness, vitiated assent, and penetrate of classification. In any case, it is similarly basic to take note of that the assurance of patient’s privilege will not be at the expense of expert honesty and self-rule. There is certainly a requirement for finding some kind of harmony. Something else, the outcomes would be illogical.

With regards to acquiring measures, there is a meriting need for a two dimensional methodology. On one hand, the attractive heading focuses towards recognizable proof of least sensible principles considering the social, conservative, and social setting that would encourage the adjudicators to choose issues of expert risk on a goal premise. Then again, such distinguishing proof empowers the clinical experts to disguise such norms in their everyday release of expert obligations, which would ideally forestall to an enormous degree the situation of assurance of patient’s privileges in a litigative atmosphere. Over the long haul, the present antagonistic arrangement of specialist and the patient would go through a change to the benefit of the patient, specialist, and society on the loose.

In the law of carelessness, experts, for example, attorneys, specialists, engineers and others are remembered for the classification of people purporting some extraordinary ability or gifted people by and large. Any errand which is needed to be performed with an extraordinary ability would commonly be conceded or attempted to be performed just if the individual has the essential expertise for playing out that task. Any sensible man going into a calling which requires a specific degree of figuring out how to be known as an expert of that branch, impliedly guarantees the individual managing him that the aptitude which he purports will be practised with a sensible level of care and alert. On a similar relationship, this guarantees the patients that a specialist has the imperative expertise in the clinical calling which he is rehearsing and keeping in mind that endeavour the presentation of the errand depended to him he would practice his ability with sensible skill. Decided by this norm, a proficient including clinical expert might be held obligated for carelessness on one of two discoveries: possibly he was not had of the essential expertise which he proclaimed to have had, or, he didn’t work out, with sensible ability in the given case, the aptitude which he had.

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

The norm to be applied for judging, if the individual charged has been careless, would be that of a customary equipped individual practising common ability in that calling. It isn’t vital for each expert to have the most elevated level of aptitude in that branch which he rehearses. Where a calling grasps a scope of perspectives with respect to what is an adequate norm of direct, the ability of the expert is to be decided by the most minimal standard that would be viewed as worthy. The test is the norm of the customary gifted man practising and maintaining to have that extraordinary ability. A man need not have the most noteworthy master ability; it is entrenched law that it is adequate in the event that he practices the normal expertise of a common skilled man practicing that specific workmanship.

Hence, an expert man should order the corpus of information which structures part of the expert hardware of the common individual from his calling. He ought not linger behind other common steady and clever individuals from his calling in the information on new advances, disclosures and improvements in his field. He ought to have such mindfulness as a normally able professional would have of the insufficiencies in his insight and the impediments on his ability. He should be aware of the dangers and dangers in any expert assignment, he attempts to the degree that other conventionally skillful individuals from the calling would be ready. He should bring to any expert undertaking he attempts no less mastery, ability and care than other usually skilled individuals from his calling would bring yet require bring no more.

To build up risk on that premise it must be appeared

(1) that there is a typical and ordinary practice;

(2) that the respondent has not embraced it; and

(3) that the course indeed embraced is one no expert man of conventional aptitude would have taken had he been acting with normal consideration.

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

A clinical specialist can’t be held at risk essentially on the grounds that things turned out badly from incident or misfortune or through a blunder of judgment in picking one sensible course of treatment in the inclination of another. A clinical expert would be obligated just where his lead fell beneath that of the norms of a sensibly equipped.

Legal INTERPRETATION OF MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE LIABILITY

Overall, the accompanying lawful issues have been tended to and reacted to by various discussions and Courts in India.

Charge of Medical Negligence against Professional Doctors

From the hour of Lord Denning up to this point it has been held in a few decisions that a charge of expert carelessness against the clinical expert remained on an alternate balance from a charge of carelessness against the driver of an engine vehicle. The weight of verification is correspondingly more prominent on the individual who charges carelessness against a specialist. With the best ability on the planet, things here and there turned out badly in clinical treatment or careful activity. A specialist was not to be held careless essentially on the grounds that something turned out badly. The National Commission, just as the Apex Court in a catena of choices, has held that the specialist isn’t subject for carelessness in view of another person of better aptitude or information would have endorsed an alternate treatment or worked in an alternate manner. He isn’t liable of carelessness on the off chance that he has acted as per the training acknowledged as legitimate by a sensible group of clinical experts. The Hon’ble Supreme Court on account of Dr Laxman Balkrishna versus Dr Trimbak, AIR 1969 SC 128, has held the above view that is as yet viewed as a milestone judgment for choosing an instance of carelessness. On account of Indian Medical Association versus Santha, the Apex Court has concluded that the expertise of a clinical professional varies from specialist to specialist and it is officeholder upon the Complainant to demonstrate that a specialist was careless in the line of treatment that brought about the life of the patient. Along these lines, a Judge can see a specialist as blameworthy just when it is demonstrated that he has missed the mark concerning the norm of sensible clinical consideration. The standard of Res-Ipsa-Loquitur has not been commonly trailed by the Consumer Courts in India including the National Commission or even by the Apex Court in choosing the case under this Act. In a catena of choices, it has been held that it is for the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness or insufficiency in assistance by illustrating master proof or sentiment and this reality is to be demonstrated past all sensible questions. The simple charge of carelessness will be of no assistance to the Complainant.[1]

What Constitutes Medical Negligence?

Disappointment of an activity and results are not carelessness. The term carelessness is characterized as the nonattendance or absence of care that a sensible individual ought to have taken in the conditions of the case. In the claim of carelessness for a situation of wrist drop, the accompanying perceptions were made. Nothing has been referenced in the protest or in the grounds of allure about the sort of care wanted from the specialist wherein he fizzled. It isn’t said anyplace what kind of carelessness was finished over the span of the activity. Nerves might be chopped down at the hour of activity and simple cutting of a nerve doesn’t add up to carelessness. It isn’t said that it has been intentionally done. Actually, it is additionally not said that the nerves were cut in the activity and it was not cut at the hour of the mishap. No master proof at all has been created. Just the report of the Chief Medical Officer of Haridwar has been delivered wherein it said that the patient is an instance of post-horrible wrist drop. It isn’t said that it is because of any activity or the carelessness of the specialist. The simple claim won’t present out a defence of carelessness except if it is demonstrated by solid proof and is upheld by master proof. The facts demonstrate that the activity has been performed. It is likewise evident that the Complainant has numerous costs yet except if the carelessness of the specialist is demonstrated, she isn’t qualified for any compensation.[2]

What is the Standard of Care?

It is currently a settled standard of law that a clinical expert will bring to his assignment a sensible level of expertise and information and must exercise a sensible level of care. Neither the most noteworthy nor the least level of care and fitness decided in the light of conditions for each situation is the thing that the law requires. Decided from this measuring stick, post-employable contamination or shortening of the leg was not because of any carelessness or insufficiency in help with respect to the contrary party Appellant. Inadequacy in help subsequently can’t be attached on the inverse party.[3]

For a situation that prompted visual impedance as a result, the accompanying perceptions were made. The writing concerning largo unmistakably referenced that the symptom of this medication whenever taken for a more extended length can influence visual perception however this isn’t a reality for this situation. Plus, there is no master proof on record to show that the utilization of this medication made harm the patient’s visual perception. In any event, for the wellbeing of argument, on the off chance that it is acknowledged that this medication made harm the patient’s vision, if the Respondent-specialist is one who has encouraged his patient to utilize this medication after an assessment in which he discovered the patient to be experiencing jungle fever, all things considered too the specialist Respondent can’t be held liable of carelessness or insufficient in his administration. In any case, as expressed above, for this situation, the medication has been utilized by the patient in low portions for a couple of days and there is no master proof to show that the utilization of medication has influenced his vision. Thusly, the Complainant-Appellant has neglected to demonstrate that the Respondent was careless and insufficient in his obligation as a doctor.[4]

Verification of Medical Negligence

It has been held in various decisions by the National Commission and by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that a charge of expert carelessness against a specialist remained on an alternate balance from a charge of carelessness against a driver of a vehicle. The weight of evidence is correspondingly more noteworthy on the individual who affirms carelessness against a specialist. Even with a specialist with the best aptitudes, things now and then turn out badly during clinical treatment or in a medical procedure. A specialist isn’t to be held careless essentially in light of the fact that something turned out badly. The Complainant’s vision was not re-established after the activity was led by the Appellant yet on this ground alone a specialist cannot be held careless in light of the fact that even in the wake of receiving every vital insurance and care the aftereffect of the activity may not be agreeable since it relies upon different variables. The dispute of the Appellant was that the patient was experiencing diabetes and circulatory strain and in numerous such cases, visual perception isn’t re-established after the activity anyway cautiously it is finished. For this situation, there isn’t anything on record to show that something turned out badly because of a demonstration of the Appellant-specialist. There is no proof to arrive at the resolution that the Appellant fell beneath the norm of a sensibly equipped expert in their field, to such an extent that their leaders may be meriting reproach. The Appellant can’t be subject for carelessness since another person of better ability or information would have endorsed an alternate technique for activity in an alternate manner. The proof proposes that the Appellant has played out the activity and acted as per the training routinely acknowledged and received by him in this clinic and a few patients are consistently treated for their eye issues. The Hon’ble Supreme Court on account of Dr Laxman Balkrishna versus Dr Triambak, AIR 1969 Supreme Court page 128 has held the above view and this view has been additionally affirmed on account of the Indian Medical Association versus Santha. The Apex Court and the National Commission has held that the aptitude of a clinical expert contrasts from specialist to specialist and it is an occupant upon the Complainant to demonstrate that the Appellant was careless in the line of treatment that brought about the deficiency of visual perception. A Judge can see a specialist as blameworthy just when it is demonstrated that he has missed the mark regarding a norm of sensible clinical consideration. The reality and conditions of the case before us show that the Appellant has taken care of the patient with due consideration, expertise, and determination. Basically, in light of the fact that the patient’s vision was not re-established acceptably, this record alone isn’t just for holding the specialist blameworthy of carelessness and inadequate in his obligation. It is settled law that it is for the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness or inadequacy in help by illustrating master proof or sentiment and this reality is to be demonstrated past all sensible uncertainty. A simple claim of carelessness will be of no assistance to the Complainant. [5]

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

The accompanying instances of supposed clinical carelessness give an understanding into how a ultimate choice is reached by the legal bodies. “All clinical carelessness cases concern different inquiries of reality, when we state the weight of demonstrating carelessness lies on the Complainant, it implies he has the undertaking of persuading the court that his adaptation of the realities is the right one”. No master feeling has been delivered by the Complainant to repudiate the report of the Board of Doctors. The allure of the Complainant was excused with costs as “No master feeling has been created by him.”[8] For a situation of an inappropriate association of the patella, no master has been delivered by the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness of the contrary party. Accordingly, it can’t be said with a precision that therapy of the Complainant by the contrary party was against the standards recommended under the clinical statute or that the contrary party in any capacity was careless or inadequate in the presentation of his duties. [6]

“Charge of clinical carelessness is a major issue and it is for the individual who sets up the case to demonstrate carelessness dependent on the material on a record or via proof”. The objection of clinical carelessness was excused in light of the fact that the candidate neglected to build up and demonstrate any case of clinical negligence.[7] “Just on the grounds that the activity didn’t succeed, the specialist can’t be supposed to be careless” and the allure of the specialist was allowed.[8] “A simple claim won’t present a defence of carelessness except if it is demonstrated by solid proof and is upheld by master proof” and the allure was dismissed. “The commission can’t establish itself into a specialist body and repudiate the assertion of the specialist except if there is something opposite on the record via a specialist assessment or there is any clinical composition on which dependence could be based” and the Revision appeal of the specialist was allowed. For another situation, an X-beam report showed a little mistiness that like a hazy shadow that gets obvious for some causes other than math. It couldn’t be accepted that actually, stone existed in the correct kidney that had not been worked upon. Considering the present situation, we don’t feel that any instance of carelessness has been made by the Complainant. This request is, subsequently, allowed.[9]

RECENT SUPREME COURT DECISION AND CONCLUSION

Before the instance of Jacob Mathew versus the State of Punjab, the Supreme Court of India conveyed two distinct assessments on specialists’ obligation. In Mohanan versus Prabha G Nair and another, it decided that a specialist’s carelessness could be found out simply by filtering the material and master proof that may be introduced during a preliminary. In Suresh Gupta’s case in August 2004 the norm of carelessness that must be demonstrated to fix a specialist’s or specialist’s criminal risk was set at “net carelessness” or “wildness.”

In Suresh Gupta’s case, the Supreme Court recognized a mistake of judgment and at fault carelessness. It held that criminal indictment of specialists without sufficient clinical sentiment highlighting their blame would do an extraordinary damage to the network. A specialist can’t be gone after for at fault or criminal carelessness in all instances of clinical setbacks or incidents.

A specialist might be at risk in a common case for carelessness however simple remissness or need of due consideration and aptitude can’t be portrayed as so wild or terribly careless as to make her/him criminally obligated. The courts held that this qualification was important so the perils of clinical experts being presented to common risk may not absurdly stretch out to criminal obligation and open them to the danger of detainment for supposed criminal carelessness. Consequently, the grievance against the specialist must show carelessness or imprudence of such an extent as to demonstrate a psychological express that can be portrayed as absolutely indifferent towards the patient. Such gross carelessness alone is culpable.

On September 9, 2004, Justices Arijit Pasayat and CK Thakker alluded the subject of clinical carelessness to a bigger Bench of the Supreme Court. They saw that words, for example, “net”, “wild”, “capability”, and “apathy” didn’t happen anyplace in the meaning of “carelessness” under Section 304A of the Indian Penal Code and subsequently they couldn’t concur with the judgment conveyed on account of Dr Suresh Gupta.

The issue was chosen in the Supreme Court on account of Jacob Mathew versus the State of Punjab. The court guided the focal government to outline rules to spare specialists from pointless provocation and unjustifiable weight in playing out their obligations. It decided that until the public authority outlined such rules, the accompanying rules would win:

A private grievance of carelessness or carelessness against a specialist may not be engaged without by all appearances proof as a sound assessment of another skilled specialist supporting the charge. What’s more, the exploring official should offer a free input, ideally of an administration specialist. At long last, a specialist might be captured just if the examining official accepts that she/he would not be accessible for indictment except if captured.

[1] Smt. Savitri Singh v. Dr. Ranbir PD. Singh and others. 2004;(1) CPJ 25 (Bihar)

[2] Smt. Vimlesh Dixit v. Dr. R.K. Singhal. 2004;(I) CPJ 123

[3] Dr. Kamta Prasad Singh v. Nagina Prasad. 2000;(III) CPJ 283 (WB)

[4] Ajay Kumar v. Dr. Devendra Nath. 2004;(II) CPJ 482.

[5] Dr. Akhil Kumar Jain v. Lallan Prasad. 2004;(II) CPJ 504.

[6] Amar Singh v. Frances Newton Hospital and Anr. 2001;(I) CPJ 8.

[7] Mam Chand v. Dr. GS Mangat of Mangat Hospital. 2004;(I) CPJ 79

[8] Dr. (Smt) Kumud Garg v. Raja Bhatia. 2004;(I) CPJ 369.

[9] Dr. Harkanwaljit Singh Saini v. Gurbax Singh and Anr. 2003;(I) CPJ 153

 

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

Categories
Blog

Role Of Intellectual Property Law In The Sports Industry

By: Pallavi Tiwari

  1. INTRODUCTION

Sports are said to form 1-5 percent of the GDP and thus are very important for economy and various related companies. As far as the recent trend is concerned Indian Premier League (IPL) is going on and this is the most appropriate example to understand the connection between sports, marketing and business. Here, every team has its brand value, their advertisements, their theme songs, logos, brand name, tag-lines, marketing strategy and players’ performance strategy and all of this forms a part of IPR.  All these assets need to be protected as part of IPR from being taken away by third parties.  IP in sports came up first as recommended by Kunstadt but only with respect to copyright and trademark as the players who invest labor to develop a new move should be given economic benefit for the same.[1]

Copyright subsists in the photos clicked in the IPL events and the theme song of the themes or the title track of IPL itself.[2] Design rights can be established in the bats used by players which are specially designed and aim to facilitate their game. Trademark relates to the logo of the teams or their merchandise used in the games. All this helps in the branding of the team and also create some value in the eyes of the viewers. Unless and until something is appealable it holds no value in the market, so for investment it is important that it has created some value in the market. These logos and other IP rights have to be protected so that no one else could copy them or use them in their business and gain advantage of the established image of the players or the team, according to trademark dilution under Section 29(4) of the Trademark Act. [3]

Any third party could come up with these marks or designs and thus cause great loss to the owners and can also tarnish their image by selling bad products in the name of the players or teams by creating confusion in the minds of the consumers, which happened in the famous PayPal or Paytm case. Thus sports and IP laws work in intersection with each other and IP is essential for the commercialization of sports.[4]

Learn more about Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

  1. PATENT LAW AND SPORTS INDUSTRY

Patent law can be used in the sports industry with respect to the techniques used in the game or in the making of sports equipment to enhance the efficacy. Some examples of such patents are “D.S. Miller’s Dominant Hand Putting Method” or the “Nolan Ryan’s baseball pitch” and both are either to evade the impediments caused due to some handicap or improve the technique involved in a game. Patent can only be granted if something is novel, non-obvious and has industrial use as per Article 27(1) of the TRIPS[5] and also imbibed into the Indian Patent Law. As far as sports patents are concerned and the first requirement of novelty is to be addressed, it is important to note that even if a player has developed a technique or a move to play or designed an equipment to enhance the game it is important that he gets a patent first on it and then use it in front of other players. If he fails to do so, the patent is said to be already in the public and thus not novel or non-obvious. To determine novelty it is important that the technique or anything to be patented should not be in the mind of the public already expert in the field but the moves or techniques used by the players are just movements of limbs  and thus very commonly discussed and seen amongst the players. Thus generally players fail to get patent due to non-fulfillment of the novelty criteria. Another condition is of industrial application and there is no proof that sport related patent can be used commercially or in an industry. It depends on patent to patent and thus this condition may or may not be fulfilled.[6]

Sports is about learning new moves and mostly players learn from one another but if these moves are patented it would cause an unfair advantage on the other competitors. Sometimes another player in between of a match can use a patented move which would cause the game to come to a halt and thus destroy the basic essence of sports. Thus, this would make the players first think and then make a move or use a technique which would not be spontaneous anymore and going against the principles of sports.[7]

As far as India’s position with respect to patenting moves of a game are concerned section 3(m)[8] of the Indian Patent Act clearly debars “a mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing a game” from being granted a patent. Thus India is still not open to patenting of sports or the moves involved as compared to US which observes as laid down in Diamond v. Chakraborty[9] case that anything can be patented.[10]

Thus, the position of patent grant with respect to sports move is still not clear and uniform across the globe so no decision can be called upon the same.

  1. COPYRIGHT AND SPORTS INDUSTRY

As far as sports are concerned copyright exists in a lot of things like slogans for a team, pictures of players, or any other photography associated with the events. As copyright now involves broadcaster and performers’ rights under the Act, it gives a broadcaster a right to telecast a particular sporting event and to possess that right the companies pay huge amounts. So if any other person uses the broadcast for his own channel then it shall also be an infringement of copyright. These broadcasters make available to the public the sport events as each and every event cannot be attended by the viewers. Thus broadcasting is the major area where copyright subsists in case of sports and due to the revenue generated by licensing the broadcasting rights events can be organized and other related events can take place. Apart from the field events there are computer games also which use software which can be subjected to copyright protection and also patent protection when combined with hardware as computer programs or software are per se not patentable.[11] The characters or graphics used in video games are also subjected to copyright protection as now the craze for online games and events including video games are no less than field sports events.[12]

Learn more about Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

As far as copyright in sports is concerned, there are two categories of sports that can be discussed: purposive or non-aesthetic sports or aesthetic sports.[13] Section 13 mentions about works in which copyright subsists and sports is clearly not a part of it. The case of Institute for Inner Studies v.Charlotte Anderson,[14] was one landmark case which discussed why copyright protection is not offered to sports. The High Court observed that yoga asana cannot be granted copyright protection because they are neither included under literary or dramatic work under the Act. The Court also felt that sports lack the main criteria of fixation in tangible medium with respect to copyright. It is also considered anti-competitive in nature as it will thereby reduce the scope for future players to use similar moves.

This is not the case with aesthetic sports (dance, gymnastics, skating) as they involve some creativity and can come under choreographic works protected under copyright. Dancers, gymnasts can also avail the performers’ rights under Section 38 of the Act. They also fulfill the requirements of performance under 2(q) of the Act and performer under Section 2(qq) of the Act and thus are eligible for protection. As far as uncertainty or originality is concerned with respect to copyright protection, aesthetic sports fulfill this criterion. They are also fixated in nature as most of the copyrighted works are as they constitute of certain specific moves.

Further in the case of Star India Pvt. Ltd. v. Piyush Agarwal & Ors.[15] the Single Bench observed that cricket events are subject to performers’ rights protection under the copyright act. But later on, this decision was overruled and the Delhi High Court observed that performers’ rights are not under copyright as they are clearly mentioned to be “special rights” under Section 38 of the Act. But stand in India relating to copyright protection for sports is still unclear.

  1. TRADEMARK AND PROTECTION OF LOGOS AND BRAND NAMES IN SPORTS

Trademarks are used to distinguish goods and services from one another. These days’ sports events also involve a lot of brands and use them in logos and their marks to gain commercially. This is done essentially to create a brand value for products used in these sports or to catch the viewer attention. For example, champions rise is used for FIFA and like in IPL as well every team has their own logo and mark. It helps the viewers to establish a relation with the team or game and to choose their favorite side. There have been cases where players have trademarked their name like David Beckham. In the recent trend of online games it is important to have brand names for teams and events so the viewers can distinguish between them. If some revenue has to be generated through a sports event or by a team it is important that it should have some recognition in the market and this can be established through trademark.[16]

In a famous case STJUE Arsenal v. Reed,[17] the defendant used the branded goods outside the stadium in a commercial manner unofficially thus causing an infringement. Getting trademark on a team or a player’s name which in turn become very popular helps the sports apparel manufacture to establish goodwill on the brand value of the team or the player. According to Forbes ranking it is established that “the portion of [a sports team’s] enterprise value attributable to local revenue streams like television, advertising, merchandise and tickets, that exceeds what a typical team in the same sports generates.”[18]

There are some associated rights to trademarks which are known as personality rights where a player can control how much his personality in the public can be exploited to create a brand value or use it as recognition for a product. When someone uses a player’s name on their goods and does not do well on the goodwill of the player it is a clear case of trademark dilution under Section 29(4) of the Indian Trademark Act. This brand value created by using team names or players’ names can also be used by broadcasters to attract the audience and thus IP law is all mixed up in the sports industry.

  1. TRADE SECRET IN SPORTS AND GAMES

Apart from these above-mentioned IP rights, there is one right which though not yet recognized under IP is important for the sports industry. It is trade secret which forms part of all the secret strategies of teams to win or secret compounds in their gears to make playing easy and winnable or any other dietary ingredient. It is not be disclosed to the public unlike patent rights. Generally other teams might try to steal these assets but they are to be necessarily protected so that no other team or player can gain undue advantage on the same.

Data analysis is another trade secret which needs to be protected from being used by fellow competitors. It may involve screening the way other team plays, their loopholes and the team’s strength and weakness in the past few matches. This then later on helps the team to decide how they will strategize their game and also observe patterns in the player’s physiological and psychological behavior. This data is also known as big-data and though India doesn’t recognize a specific trade secret law it still has been given special importance in US and UK with newly introduced legislations.

  1. DESIGN RIGHTS IN SPORT INDUSTRY

Design rights are generally an extension of trademark law and copyright law where the difference is only that design first of all is only to refer to aesthetic beauty of the product and cannot include anything technical or anything attributing to the functions of the products. Teams or sports events use beautiful designs for products to be used in the game like bats, balls and other goods to attract the viewer attention. It is highly creative in nature and it aims to enhance the appearance of the goods to be used so that if someone buys the product later they can associate it with the design of the team or the player.

One such example is development of clever bicycle by Lucio Tortola, a cyclist to reduce issues in the back and any chance of injury in bicycle rides. This was designed to be a shock absorber and help the cyclists in future. Now this design has become very famous and used by most of the cyclists across the globe. So design is just not for beauty but to also remove some issues involved in the game and help the future players. [19]

Learn more about Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

  1. CONCLUSION

The author has discussed various IP rights associated with sports and players and how India stands with respect to these rights. There is also another term called ambush marketing apart from these IP rights infringements which is a problem in the sports industry. Generally it is not within the scope of IP law but needs to be addressed whenever any sports issue is under consideration. It is a very prevalent practice these days when some company tries to commercially get advantage on the basis of already established goodwill of an event. They reap commercial gains in this process by unofficially associating themselves with famous sports events and gaining advantage of being a sponsor when they are not.

Relying on afore-mentioned propositions, it is important to recognize the importance of various IP rights in sports and how they can be protected. IP is always an essential ingredient of any commercial activity and since sports is now more of commercial nature it is important to protect it. In this write-up, the author shall discuss how patent, copyright, trademark, designs, trade secret and other IP rights are closely attached to sports and how can they be infringed so that businesses and companies related to sports can avoid such activities. To save a business it is important to save the IP related to it and similar is the stand for sport industry.

[1] F. F. Scott Kieff, Robert G. Kramer &  Robert M. Kunstad, “It’s Your Turn, But It’s My Move: Intellectual Property Protection for Sports Moves”, 25 Santa Clara High Tech. L.J. 765 (2012).

[2] Anita Roy, “Shield of IPR around IPL”,  http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/author-616-anita-roy.html.

[3] Vaishali Singh, “The Untapped Emergence of IP Rights and Sports: Faster, Stronger and Higher” (2019) PL (IPR) July 91.

[4] Zia Akhtar, “Sports development, legal infrastructure and protecting Intellectual Property rights” http://www.africansportslawjournal.com/Sports%20development%20legal%20infrastructure%20and%20protecting%20Intellectual%20Property%20rights_.pdf.

[5] Article 27TRIPS 1994, “Patentable Subject Matter”.

[6] “Leveraging Intellectual Property In The Global Sports Economy: Sports As A Tool For Progress And Development”, Global Innovation Policy Centre, https://www.theglobalipcenter.com/introducing-leveraging-intellectual-property-in-the-global-sports-economy/.

[7] Derek Bambauer, “ Legal Responses To The Challenges Of Sports Patents”, Harvard Journal of Law & Technology Volume 18, Number 2 (2005).

[8] Section 3(m), The Patent Act, 1970 “a mere scheme or rule or method of performing mental act or method of playing game”.

[9] 447 U.S. 303 (1980).

[10] Sharada Kalamadi, “Intellectual property and the business of sports management”, (2012), http://nopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/14768/1/JIPR%2017(5)%20437-442.pdf.

[11] S.K. Verma, “IP Protection of Software and Software Contracts In India”, Vol. 17 JIPR (2012).

[12] Molly Torsen, “Intellectual Property and Sporting Events: Effective

Protection of Event Symbols through Law and Practice”, International Intellectual Property Institute,  https://iipi.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/Sporting_Events_and_Intellectual_Property.pdf.

[13] Seemantani Sharma, “A Copyright Incentive for Promoting ‘Aesthetic Sports’ in India”, The Entertainment and Sports Law Journal, 17(1), 7, http://doi.org/10.16997/eslj.232.

[14] Case Number: CS(OS)–2252/2011.

[15] MIPR 2013 (1) 201; 2013 (54) PTC 222 (Del).

[16] Paras Sharma, “Intellectual Property Rights In Sports” Volume 8, Issue 3, IJCRT, (2020).

[17] [2003] EWCA Civ 696 (21 May 2003).

[18] M Ozanian “The Forbes Fab 40: The World’s Most Valuable Sports Brands 2017”, Forbes, Forbes Fab 40: Teams (2017).

[19] “Reiventing the Frame, Challenging the Status Quo”    https://www.wipo.int/ipadvantage/en/articles/article_0159.html.

Learn more about Sports Law with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants!

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Transportation Laws in India, UAE & USA

By: Subham Agarwal

Humankind has always found ways to transport themselves for business, survival, or food. Transportation has always played a significant role socially, economically, culturally, and commercially. Humankind has also always invented new ways to increase the speed of transportation.

The first-ever steam-powered automobile was built in 1769, and the steam-powered railway was built in 1804. In 1885 the first petrol-powered automobile was developed by Karl Benz, and this year is known as the “Birth year of modern car.” This changed the entire landscape of the transporting system, but change comes at a cost. This started causing various traffic deaths and injuries that resulted in many to express concern. In early 1903, New York City introduced the world’s first traffic law regulating speed limit in the city and countryside. With this, many countries started implementing rules to minimize traffic violations. In later years, the government started imposing stricter rules and regulations to reduce traffic violations, deaths, and injuries.

Learn more about Transportation Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Jurist & Jurist International Advocates!

United Arab Emirates (UAE)

The United Arab Emirates is a country predominated by Muslims. However, in the last few decades, people worldwide have settled there. UAE is famous for various things, one of them being strict laws. UAE has stringent rules for Motor Vehicle. In UAE, transportation law is of recent origin. The first law was “Federal Law No. (21) of 1995 Concerning Traffic”. The transportation system is also of recent origin. The first Bus service in UAE was introduced in Abu Dhabi by the Emirate in 2008 in only four routes.

In addition to it, the first passenger rail was started in 2009, i.e., Dubai Metro, while the Abu Dhabi metro and Sharjah metro are still under construction. Also, the construction work for the goods carrier train network commenced in 2009. The fact that transportation is of very recent origin in UAE, so the transportation law relating to Railways and others still need to be developed.

However, when it comes to Air Transport, Dubai airport is the world’s busiest airport for the last six years. All the airport in UAE is controlled by the General Civil Aviation Authority (GCAA), and they make all the necessary guidelines for the airport and air carriers.

UAE has one of the most strict laws relating to road transport. As we all know, UAE’s laws are mostly based on the Deterrent theory, but it helps UAE reduce its traffic death and injury. In 2006, 190 people died per million in traffic collisions linked to high speed and low safety culture. In 2010 it reduced to 100 per million, and in 2014-2018 it dropped by 34%.

Road and Transport Authority (RTA) regulates and issues licenses in UAE. It also operates jointly with the traffic department to ensure more efficiency in implementing rules. The road transportation in the UAE comprises driving rules, road rules, road types, land, and marine transportation. In Dubai, penalty points system are followed for each violation, and the authority adds black points for every violation. It leads to the seizure of the driving license if it reaches 24 black points within 24 months, the penalty charges are as follows:

  • On the first violation, the driving license is seized for three months
  • On the second violation, the driving license is seized for six months
  • On the third violation, the driving license is seized for a year and is given when the driver passes the driving course signed by the traffic authorities.

Various rules under Transportation Law of UAE are:

  • The minimum legal age for driving is eighteen, and the person has to renew every year up to the age of 21 and then in every ten years.
  • Wearing of seat belts for all the passengers is compulsory. A child seat is mandatory for up to 4 years of age, and no child below the age of ten can sit in the front seat. Violation of any of it is punishable with a fine of AED 400 and 4 black points.
  • Drinking and driving is considered as one of the most severe crimes, and if caught, imprisonment and/or fine of minimum AED 20,000 (4lakhs INR approx.). An additional charge under Narcotics law is filed.
  • Using a mobile phone while driving is strictly prohibited, and if caught, a fine of minimum AED 800 and 4 black points is charged.
  • Driver must also follow the “3-second rule,” i.e., there must be a 3-second distance between two cars, and tailgating is considered an offense.

Learn more about Transportation Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Jurist & Jurist International Advocates!

These are some traffic rules of the UAE, and the list goes on. Therefore, after looking at these few rules, we can conclude that UAE traffic rules are stringent but needful to avoid accidents and traffic violations. The deterrent model is beneficial, and various country’s legislators should give thought to it.

United States of America (USA)

In the United States of America, transportation consists of road, rail, air, and waterways transport. Travel through roads consist of 40% share, followed by airways and others. In the USA, the highest contributor to Greenhouse gas emission is transportation. Now, looking at the history of transportation, in the 18th century, most of the travels were done by rail, horses, or horse wagons. In this century, most of the population was situated in coastal areas, so traveling from one city to another was very difficult. Then in the 19th century, the automobile revolution took place. People started using motor vehicles, and due to the invention of better air travel, there was a significant shift from rail transport to air transport. In the 20th century, the national highway system came, and the road became the most preferred mode of transportation. Rail transport declined drastically.

In the present situation, all the states have their own traffic rules and guidelines regulated, supervised, and funded by the U.S. Department of Transportation. Although there are different rules for all the states, they are unified by the Uniform Vehicle Code (UVC). It is a model act by the National Committee on Uniform Traffic Law and Ordinances, a private non-profit group. Most of the members of these groups are state governments.

Compared to the various countries, the USA prefers motorized transit than any other form of transportation. 91% of the population owns 4 wheel vehicle, and 86% of workers have private vehicles for commuting to work.

In addition to it, individuals can also have their own private airport in the USA, and all the airlines are private. The airport safety, pilot training, and investigations are done by the Federal Aviation Administration and Transportation Safety Board. The USA has the world’s most developed air transportation system. There is a minimal passenger train or rail network present in the USA, but rail is heavily used to carry goods.

In many U.S. states, traffic offenses are distinguished into two, i.e., traffic misdemeanors and traffic felonies. Traffic misdemeanors are those minor offenses that do not require any hefty long trial. Punishment for these are fines or going to driving school. Traffic felonies are those offenses that endanger the lives of others while driving. For instance, driving a vehicle to hit and kill someone. Punishment for those offenses, which are a year or more imprisonment, comes under the category of traffic felonies.

In most states, the Points System is followed. This is similar to the UAE Black points system. For each offense, points are added in the U.S., and one can reduce it by paying fines or attending driving school. Too many points lead to temporary seizure of license.

Every state has a Department of Motor Vehicle or Bureau of Motor Vehicles, which keep records of the license holders, including tickets issued against such license holders. After being ticketed, a person can inform the local court about the alleged violation, either plea guilty, not guilty, or nolo contender (not to contest) for a specific time period (usually 10-15 days are given). On pleading guilty, the violator can ask the judge to reduce the fine. On pleasing not guilty, a hearing is done before a magistrate or judge, and if acquitted, then all the ticket will be waived off.

Therefore, we can conclude that every state has different rules and regulations in the USA, making it difficult for people who are traveling to various states. We can also see that ticketing and getting justice for that is a very lengthy process and is a significant burden on people. On the positive side, this clumsy process somewhere creates a deterrent in people’s minds before violating any rule.

India

In India, transportation consists of air, land, water, and rail. Air transport comes under the Ministry of Aviation, and the regulatory authority is the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA). Land transportation comes under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highway. Waterways come under the Ministry of Shipping, and the regulatory authority is the Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI). Lastly, railways come under the Ministry of Railways.

India’s first legislative law on transportation was the “Indian Motor Vehicle Act, 1914” central legislation passed by British India. The act had 18 Sections and gave local government the responsibility of registration and providing licenses to vehicle and drivers, and some regulations.

In India, the maximum number of people are dependent on public transportation. For example, Indian Railways came to India in 1853, running from Bombay to Thane, which is now the world’s 4th largest rail network with the most extensive workforce globally, i.e., 14 lakhs employees.

The potential of air transport in India was first realized in 1911 when an aircraft carried mail from Allahabad to Naini across river Ganga. The first civil aviation company in India was set up by TATA sons in 1932. Then, the Air Corporation Act, 1953, came into force to nationalize the entire industry. Today, the Indian aviation industry is one of the fastest-growing industries, with less nationalize control and more safety regulations work by the government.

In the present day, we are under the provision of the Motor Vehicle (Amendment) Act, 2019. This act amended the 1989 act and imposed more hefty fines on traffic violators. Some of the provisions are:-

  • Driving a vehicle without insurance is punishable with imprisonment up to three months or a fine of Rs 2000 or both for the first offense. Earlier it was Rs 1000.
  • Using a vehicle without registration is punishable with a fine of Rs 2000 to Rs 5000 in case of the first offense and for second and subsequent offense imprisonment up to 1 year or fine of Rs 10,000 or both.
  • In 2016, Good Samaritan Law was passed as Bill on the Supreme Court of India’s judgment. Ministry of Road Transport and Highway later issued guidelines. This law protects citizens who help accident victims from any delay or harassment.

Therefore, we can conclude that the 2019 amendment is going in tune with the UAE deterrent model by imposing hefty fines on violators and also creating awareness among people.

Learn more about Transportation Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Jurist & Jurist International Advocates!

 

 

 

Categories
Blog

Role of Intellectual Property in Mergers and Acquisition

By: Nidhi Poddar

Introduction 

Intellectual Property has not always horse around Merger and Acquisition deals. Intellectual Property plays a disguised role in 2 major aspects:

  1. By making certain Intellectual Property intensive industries, for example, life sciences, where the value of pharmaceuticals can often be viewed with the scope of patent protection.
  2. By making certain deal structures, for example, spin-outs and joint ventures where the rational allocation of Intellectual Property Rights is an unavoidable necessity.

Whether directly or indirectly, consciously or unconsciously, Intellectual Property plays a significant role in any Merger and Acquisition activity. However, it was not unusual that the acquirer decides and proceeds with the typical Acquisition, without involving Intellectual Property experts. In most Merger and Acquisition deals, the acquirer determines the valuation, negotiates principal deal terms, and even finalized the structure of transactions whether internal or external. In certain aspects, Intellectual Property is a rattler to the Merger and Acquisition train i.e. delighted to affix along but not driving with equal importance. This is evidently accurate for valuation in Merger and Acquisition deals. While valuing a business, the bankers or any other person involved will not endeavor to value Intellectual Property separately. As the valuation of Intellectual Property separately is a burdensome task. If in any case, the acquirer measures the value of Intellectual Property separately from the business, then it would not be in the acquirer’s interest as the acquirer has to pay the higher value of the business.[1]

Merger & Acquisition

Waves of Merger and Acquisition is a key feature of corporate history and has evolved significantly in India in past decades. Merger and Acquisition has become the most important aspect of growth strategy in the corporate industry. Merger and Acquisition has shown an effective result in businesses like information technology, telecommunication, business process outsourcing and pharmaceuticals. The strategy of Merger and Acquisition has proven to be a surest way to acquire competencies and funds, opening new market avenues, expanding customer base, snuffing out competition. The strategy helped the corporate industry in maintaining and improving profitability.[2] Merger and Acquisition is a tool for reconstruction of the company in order to maximize the wealth of the company and create goodwill in the global market. Merger refers to consolidation of two companies into one company. This Merger of two companies will help in maximizing profit and enhance the work and ensure that the company achieves the desired goals. Whereas Acquisition refers to a takeover of one company by another company by purchasing its ownership stake. Generally, such a stake is above 50%, which provides the acquiring company the control of management.[3]

Intellectual Property

Intellectual Property is an incorporeal Property which is invented or created by human intellect. Intellectual Properties are intangible in nature and possess a right i.e. ” Right in Rem” which means that the inventor has the right towards the property wholly. The different forms of Intellectual Property are- Copyright, Trademark, Patent, Design etc. Intellectual Property Rights refers to the legal rights possessed by the inventor or creator in order to protect the invention or the creation for a certain period of time. Intellectual Property Rights is an exclusive right to the inventor or the creator or assignee, to use, sell or dispose the invention. Intellectual Property Rights promote the economic development of the country by creating healthy competition and encouraging industrial development and economic growth within the country.[4]

Learn more about Mergers and Acquisitions with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Corp Comm Legal!

Intellectual Property is referred to as a corporation’s biggest asset. In the New Economy- Brand names i.e. (Trademarks, Service marks and Trade names), Product value, Brand value, Innovation portfolio of the company plays a pivotal role in the management of assets of the company and are equally important as the goods and services. Sounds, smells, colour and product shape comes under the trademark protection. There should be no surprise that Intellectual Property plays a crucial role in the sale or purchase of a business.[5] Intellectual Property plays a vital role in the strategic development of the corporation. Intellectual Property is one of the various reasons for which different corporations merge or acquire any company, because such Merger and Acquisition strengthens their market share and improves and makes their management system efficient.[6] With the technology advancement, the importance and the value of intellectual property of a company has enhanced. The intellectual property possessed by a company is a cornerstone, thus has increased focus on intellectual property while any commercial transaction. In the present era, it has become the most task to identify and adequately analyze the value of intellectual property of the company as it will directly impact the value of the transaction.[7]

IP due diligence

This article intends to highlight and provide a quick overview on how Intellectual Property due diligence is important in Merger and Acquisition transactions. There is great  significance of Intellectual Property due diligence in Merger and Acquisition transactions in relation to the acquisition or investment in technology and biotech companies because the main purpose of acquiring such company is to target the Intellectual Property Assets (IPA) of the company. Intellectual Property Assets mainly refers to Patents, Trademarks, Copyright. Intellectual Property due diligence refers to a deep investigation which is conducted to understand the value of the Intellectual Property of the target company before any Merger or Acquisition.[8]

Role of Intellectual Property in Merger and Acquisition:-

  1. Value addition to the company portfolio:–

Merger and Acquisition of a company helps in adding value to the portfolio of a company. It is very necessary that companies evaluate the portfolio of the company and check whether the current portfolio meets the requirement of the company objective. In the present dynamic and inconstant market environment, it is not possible to invent something new, thus the companies must search for new opportunities and the ways of acquiring existing innovations of the other companies.

  1. Acquiring unique capabilities:-

Every company wishes to have a stronghold and be in a dominating position against their competitors. One of the major tools to achieve this is Merger and Acquisition. By Merger and Acquisition, a company may acquire the unique innovation or capabilities of their competitors. This will help the companies to have an edge over others. This result in changing the whole outlook of the company and creating a unique and efficient business model. 

  1. Transfer of Technology: –

A fruitful benefit of acquiring an Intellectual Property is that it allows the transfer of technology from one company to another. This helps in proper exploitation and utilization of the Intellectual Property to its full extent.

  1. Diversification: –

The Acquisition or Merger of a company helps in exploring and enhancing different sectors of a business. Merger and Acquisition open new doors of deals and growth within the market. It is very convenient to start a business through pre-existing or pre-established resources, and even this reduces the cost of operation and helps in creating a diversified asset portfolio for the company.

  1. Growth: –

The main objective to implement the corporate strategy is to promote growth and development and to maximize the profit, resulting in achieving the desired goals. The company must ensure that the product portfolio of the company is updated and is efficient to meet the current demand in the market.[9]

Learn more about Mergers and Acquisitions with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Corp Comm Legal!

Some classic example of Merger and Acquisition

  1. In 1988, Nestle acquired Rowntree business. It was the largest foreign takeover of a United Kingdom Company. In this deal, Nestle agreed to pay around US $ 4.5 Billion for Rowntree PLC. The main objective of this deal was to acquire famous brands i.e. Kit Kat, Yorkie, and Rolo.
  2. Another Classic example is Acquisition of Luxury Italian fashion house Versace by Michael Kors. The main objective of this deal is to access new product lines and markets through an established brand and IP portfolio.[10]
  3. Motorola Mobility was acquired by Google Inc. which gave the acquirer complete control of Motorola’s patents. Later Google Inc. sold Motorola Mobility to Lenovo, but retained ownership of Motorola Mobility’s Patent Portfolio. The main objective of Google Inc. was to purchase the patents of Motorola mobility.[11]
  4. Another interesting case study is the Acquisition of Rolls Royce by Volkswagen. Volkswagen has acquired all the assets required for the production of cars but was restricted to use the Logo of Rolls Royce. Volkswagen overlooked the fact that prior to the Acquisition, BMW has already acquired the access to use Rolls Royce Logo for its car.[12] BMW was a direct competitor to Volkswagen. Volkswagen purchased all rights to manufacture Rolls Royce cars but did not have engines for their car as BMW was producing engines for Rolls Royce. Rolls Royce factory was manufacturing both Rolls Royce and Bentley cars. After a lot of twists and turns, in 2003 BMW became the owner of Rolls Royce and Volkswagen is sole manufacturer of Bentley cars. This case study reiterates the importance of intellectual property due diligence before any Merger and Acquisition.

By the above stated classic examples what we get to learn from it.

In any Merger and Acquisition proper due diligence of Intellectual Property asset is a must. The nature of Merger and Acquisition is stated as risky and with the technology advancement in the present era has become riskier. Due diligence of Intellectual Property Assets must be the pertinent question before initiating a formal contact with the target company. Before contacting, the company must do some homework and must collect certain information regarding patents, trademark, copyright, goodwill etc. Needless the same amount of importance must be given to the tangible and intangible assets to get a fair valuation.[13]

Conclusion

Intellectual Property are the intangible assets of the company and plays a vital role in the expansion of the company and even add a great value to the portfolio of the company. Merger and Acquisition help in creating asset portfolio, acquire new capabilities, enhance the growth rate which ultimately help the company achieve their goals. To avoid any uncertainties or defects, a company should ensure a proper due diligence and valuation of Intellectual Property asset before acquisition of the Intellectual Property asset.

A company survival, goodwill and the profit depend on the possession of IP assets. It must be ensured that the deal benefits both the parties. Government is bringing out various policies to encourage Merger & Acquisition in India. The Land Acquisition bill, Labor Law and Good & Sale Tax (GST) will have a great impact on the corporate field.

Any company at any level or a startup company must emphasize on the importance of protecting their Intellectual Property rights. The acquiring company must conduct due diligence to improve their marketability and be able to identify weaknesses.

Due diligence is an integral part of any Merger and Acquisition transaction. Any act of negligence while performing due diligence can lead to over valuation of the company and even lead to an exposure to a unknown risk and liabilities.

[1] https://www.sullcrom.com/siteFiles/Publications/Mousavi-IAM-July-Aug-2011.pdf

 

[2] https://pdfslide.net/documents/Intellectual-Property-the-dominant-force.html

 

[3] http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-2693-role-of-Intellectual-Property-in-an-acquisition-or-Merger.html#:~:text=Intellectual%20Property%20assets%20are%20the,such%20as%20Merger%20and%20acquisition.

 

[4]  https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3217699/

 

[5] https://norrismclaughlin.com/articles/Intellectual-Property-aspects-of-Mergers-a-Acquisitions-part-i-of-ii-conducting-due-diligence/

 

[6]  https://www.udl.co.uk/insights/the-importance-of-ip-in-Mergers-and-Acquisitions

 

[7] http://www.buildingipvalue.com/05_NA/124_127.htm

 

[8] https://www.corporatelivewire.com/top-story.html?id=ip-due-diligence-in-ma-transactions

 

[9] Supra note (3)

[10]  https://www.udl.co.uk/insights/the-importance-of-ip-in-mergers-and-acquisitions

[11] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20150407005604/en/Research-Markets-Strategic-Importance-Intellectual-Property-IP

[12] https://medium.com/@ramkumar1984.rajachidambaram/how-ip-acquisition-unlocks-huge-value-in-technology-m-a-23e2739cf091

 

[13] https://www.origiin.com/2019/01/10/mergers-and-acquisitions-intellectual-property-due-diligence/

Learn more about Mergers and Acquisitions with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Corp Comm Legal!

Categories
Blog

Impact of Covid-19 on the Aviation Industry

By: Mayank Singh

Aviation is one of the most influenced industry during Coronavirus emergency which has happened because of magnitude of pandemic. This Pandemic has resulted large scale emergency which tends to suspension of flights and limitations on venture out universally to hinder the spread of infection. It is conceivable to watch the effect of COVID-19 on the flight business in every region including Europe, North America, Asia-Pacific and the remaining part of the world. In the country like United States, for instance, after the public Wellness crisis occurred due to COVID-19 episode, practically the entirety of the region is on outright lockdown, which Consequently, limits homegrown travel inside the nation. Nations like Spain, Italy, France, and India are under full lockdown and a wide scope of flights are ended until further notice.

A report of International Air Transport Association says that Aviation industry may endure misfortune on income as much as 113 billion dollar in this emergency. Around 4.2 billion explorers were carried around the globe in 2018, according to the World Bank Organisation. Fragments that were driving the flying business before the COVID-19 pandemic join expanding extra cash the whole course over the globe, the presentation of low-passage planes, developing by and large budgetary exercises, new travel plans, and some more. Besides, substitution of creating business plane has likewise contributed far and away to the market headway.

The primary elements affecting the aeronautics business since the pandemic remember the drop for visits and travel as an enormous number of global and homegrown flights are being dropped worldwide to check the infection’s transmission. Governments over the globe deny outsiders’ visas and lock up affected regions which is also one of the noteworthy purpose behind the log jam of the flying business. The International Aviation division has different portions of Air lines, from which, alongside cooking and other assistance giving firms, traveller aircraft section is required to get generally influenced.

Carrier organizations affecting the airplane producing businesses may likewise be seeing the crossing out of an airplane request in the short term. Driving flying organizations which are in effect universally affected incorporate Airbus, Qatar Airways, Lufthansa, China Eastern Airlines, Emirates, Boeing, American Airlines Group Inc. what’s more, Delta Air Lines. For evident reasons, Qatar Airways has suspended all of its trips to and from Italy it was one of the most noticeably terrible hit nations by the COVID-19 pandemic. The organization has consented to downsize its activity which incorporates diminishing flights and dispensing with less savvy airplane. As a prudent step of COVID-19 episode, Qatar Airways had grounded all its ten A380 airplane until 31 May 2020.

Learn more about Aviation Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified course! 

Furthermore, owing to the pandemic, Emirates likewise finished much of its traveller traffic. By and by, the company looks for rescue classes by aircraft and air terminal guiding partnerships. In Europe , for example, air terminal supervisory organisations are reliant on the procurement of $15.4 billion missing due to a pandemic. It is researched that air terminals in Europe are expected to receive 700 million fewer passengers, 28 percent less than previously expected.

Turning to economical aspect, the phenomenal decrease in avionics and business activity has incapacitated air terminal income sources. In the subsequent quarter, the normal reduction in by and large air terminal incomes on a worldwide scale is figure at $39.2 billion (USD) and over $97 billion for 2020. Air terminals must continue meeting their capital costs responsibilities as they stay depicted by fantastically high repaired costs essential for keeping and working the system sections of the air terminal, including runways, runways, covers, halting stands and terminal structures. The impact of COVID-19 has hence achieved an existential peril to air terminals and to the flying industry unhindered.

The International Air Transport Association ( IATA) has resurrected its study of the financial effect of the general growth emergency of the novel (COVID-19) on the overall air transport market. IATA is also watching cumulative compensation events for the explorer company in 2020 of between $63 billion (in a situation where COVID-19 is contained in new business divisions and over 100 instances in current business divisions beginning at 2 March) And $113 billion (with the broader distribution of COVID-19 in this situation). No estimates of the effect on payload exercises are yet available.

The past IATA analysis (given on 20 February 2020) placed a $29.3 billion decline in income based on a condition that would see the benefit of COVID-19 largely limited to business sectors linked to China. The virus has spread to more than 80 nations since that time, and forward appointments on courses beyond China have been badly affected.

Budgetary sectors of the economy reacted positively. After the start of the flare-up, aircraft share prices have dropped by approximately 25 percent, with about 21 values concentrating more noteworthily than the drop that occurred at a similar point during the 2003 SARS emergency. To a large degree, this decline as of now costs a lot more remarkable than our previous inquiry in a stun to business profits.

To consider the developing circumstance with COVID-19, IATA assessed the likely effect on traveller incomes dependent on possible situations.

The unexplained extension attributable to COVID-19 is almost unimaginable. The possibilities of the company in a large part of the world have gotten ug in minimally more than two months. How the infection can expand is muddled, but whether we see the effects on a few industry sectors and a $63 billion income misfortune, or a more pervasive influence that triggers a $113 billion, loss of income in this pandemic.

“Numerous carriers are cutting limit and taking crisis measures to diminish costs. Governments must observe. Aircrafts are giving a valiant effort to remain above water as they play out the imperative undertaking of connecting the world’s economies. As governments look to upgrade gauges, the carrier business will require thought for help on duties, charges and space portion. These are uncommon occasions,” said Alexandre de Juniac, IATA’s Director General and CEO.

Learn more about Aviation Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified course! 

Impact of Covid-19 on Indian Airlines.

In the budgetary year 2021, the Indian aeronautics division is probably going to lose up to $ 4 billion, warning firm CAPA India has stated, raising the misfortune gauge from the past $3.6 billion.

CAPA India likewise talked about a higher capitalization necessity for Indian carriers, up from $2.5 billion to $3.5 billion of every investigation delivered on July 3. Systematically, the organization said the Indian flight industry could be decreased from the greater part twelve, including Air India, IndiGo, Go Air and Spice Jet , to just a few players now.

“Restructuring seems more likely and would result in a very drastic shift in the industry ‘s structure. If timely recapitalization does not happen, India might be heading for a two-three airline market,” it added. Ongoing traffic has generally included fundamental repositioning traffic, with travellers that were stuck in an inappropriate spot when the lockdown was declared getting back to their headquarters. Optional travel has been restricted, as reflected in the way that in excess of 90 percent of appointments have been for single direction travel, contrasted with 40 percent earlier with COVID,” the report said.

Despite the fact that the administration has permitted carriers to work up to 45 percent of their mid year plan yet it has had little effect as traveller load drifts around the midway imprint. Passages, which have been topped inside a range, have would in general be nearer to the lower end of the band, CAPA India said.

Ahead of Covid-19, one of the fastest rising aviation markets in the world, India is bracing for rough days ahead. Market watchers fear that a complete lack of government support will trigger a shakedown of India’s airline industry, which could have a lasting impact on the once upbeat demand for jet fuel in the country. In seven of the last 10 years, having seen double-digit percentage rise, In the first half of 2020, Indian airlines saw passenger numbers collapse 50 percent year on year to 35.2 million, or the lowest since 2014.

Airfares have also been put under pressure due to a decline of almost 30 per cent in bookings to destinations hit by viruses. As a consequence, airfares to those destinations have declined by 20-30%. With domestic travellers postponing or cancelling their travel plans, domestic traffic growth is also steadily being impacted.

Many companies announced a decline in domestic travel this summer of more than 30 per cent compared to last year. Airfare has been reduced by 20-25% on common domestic routes and airfares are also expected to remain subdued for the summer season. Aircraft transporters’ money adjusts are coming up short and many are nearly insolvency. Likewise, the crisis could provoke loss of occupations and pay cuts. A couple of airplanes have requested various from their laborers to go on leave without pay. Air Deccan has suspended errands and sent laborers on unpaid leaves.

In the interim, the travel industry service has refered to Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) evaluations to recommend the loss of income to the travel industry can run between Rs 72,000 crore and Rs 1.58 lakh crores in 2020-21. As per the service, marked lodgings will endure the greatest shot in the travel industry area, trailed by visit administrators. In view of the fundamental gauges via airlines,the division might be set for a decrease of 50-60% in worldwide rush hour gridlock and up to a half drop in homegrown rush hour gridlock, the note said. It additionally included that “there may be a critical however brief loss of both immediate and circuitous positions in the division.”

Learn more about Aviation Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified course! 

While a few carriers have begun tolerating advance appointments fully expecting facilitating of the lockdown after April 14. In resuming domestic operations, Indian carriers are using a hawk-eyed approach; however, the pace of PLFs would be a main concern. For both 30-day/15-day ticketing periods, the brokerage said its airfare tracker indicates average yield across subway routes has decreased by ~30 percent year to date.

According to flight regulator Directorate General of Civil Aviation, local air explorer traffic hung 82.3% in July differentiated and the very month a year back. From January to July, airplanes passed on a whole of 37.28 million voyagers, a rot of 54.84% appeared differently in relation to the relating time period a year back.

It likewise assessed that because of such misfortunes, “all things considered, some airplane may must be grounded” and “a critical decrease is additionally expected noticeable all around payload took care of at air terminals across India.” 

  Conclusion

Aviation Industries are investing additional amounts of energy to guarantee appropriate sterilization and fumigation of air terminal terminals just as the purification of planes. Be that as it may, notwithstanding taking such prudent steps it is as yet hard to manage the dread ingrained in the psyches of travelers voyaging which consequently is influencing the general business of the flying business. On head of that, so as to control the spread of this deadliest infection government confined all worldwide trips to land in India. This will bring about loss of income and money related pressure.

Learn more about Aviation Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified course! 

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Competition Law Issues in the Facebook-Jio Deal

By: Abishek TK

Jio – Facebook Crossover: A Financial Entente:

Facebook is one of the only apps used by almost 2.5 Billion users, making the social media platform the world’s largest. While Facebook conquers the world, Whatsapp conquers India with approximately 200 million users, making it the country’s largest. On 21st April 2020, Facebook CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, told the world that the Facebook was teaming up with Reliance Industries. Facebook had purchased a total of 9.99% stake in the Reliance Industries. The 5.7-billion-dollar deal pushes Reliance Industries ahead in its plans of facilitating the launch of its new commerce business. In 2019, Reliance Industries Chairman Mukesh Ambani had other primary contributors to his debt reduction plan with approximately $15 billion deal with Saudi Aramco for a 20% stake in Reliance Industries’ refining and petrochemicals business and a ₹7000 crore for a 49% sale in its fuel retail joint venture to a British firm BP. Usually, any merger between companies or corporations is a tedious process. Out of some approvals, be it regulatory or otherwise, the most critical one is the approval of Competition Commission of India. In order to complete a deal that crosses the thresholds given under Sec. 5 of the Competition Act, 2002[1], the approval by Competition Commission of India is compulsory. Another rule is that, Section 6(2) of the Competition Act, 2002, examined with Regulation 5 of the Combination Regulation confirms a suspensory reign, i.e., the approval must be obtained before the deal is finalized within the United States. Though the deal sounds bold and strong, which it does, can still encounter anti-trust issues. Starting with the multi-billion-dollar investment into Jio will have to be appraised and authorized by means of India’s opposition regulator. For this to happen, the Competition Commission of India will have to go forward and look at the proposed deal and verify that it does not cause appreciable adverse effect on competition within the marketplace. The responsibility of the Competition Commission of India is to analyze now not only the capacity of destructive results on competition how much ever additionally the capability worries it may offer upward rush to. It would be more intriguing and interesting to see if the minority stake purchase in India’s major telecom empire would provide any regulations to Facebook.

Learn more about Competition Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified Diploma course! 

Section 4 of Competition Act, 2002 sets down arrangements identifying with maltreatment of predominance which obviously expresses that a prevailing element ought not utilize its situation of solidarity to make hurt the contenders and customers in the business sectors of the nation. The Competition Act, 2002 in segment 19(4) has set out specific variables which help in deciding if an element is predominant in an applicable market or not. Prior to deciding if the arrangement among Facebook and Jio Platforms can prompt the act of maltreatment of strength by the two substances, it is basic to realize whether Facebook’s WhatsApp pay and Jio Platform’s JioMart are prevailing in their pertinent market or not.

Establishing Dominance:

Jio and Facebook are both emperors in their respective fields. According to the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, 32% stake is owned by Jio in the 1.15 billion Indian mobile services industry. It possesses the highest number of customer base and revenue-sharing share in the telecom industry. This means, Jio has an overall customer base of 369.93 million, exceeding its rivals, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone- Idea. Regarding Facebook, it basically operated via three platforms- Facebook, Instagram and Whatsapp. As for Whatsapp, it currently has a solid 400 million users in India[2]. These 400 million users are among the 600 million people who get right of entry of internet. A fragment of effectiveness compared to Whatsapp can be seen in applications like Hike, WeChat and Telegram.

JioMart is an online staple help which gives conveyance administrations of basic food item and fundamental things from close by kirana stores of the nation. JioMart right now works in just three spots of the nation for example Navi Mumbai, Thane and Kalyan. The important market of JioMart is by all accounts an online staple conveyance administration. It is appropriate to take note of that JioMart in this market has under 5% piece of the pie and furthermore is another major part in this market. It can influence neither the opposition nor the rivals in the online basic food item administration market of the nation. Subsequently, in the wake of investigating the components referenced in segment 19(4) of the Competition Act, 2002, it tends to be reasoned that JioMart is certainly not a prevailing part in its important market.

Jio is looking forward to revolutionize ‘JioMart’ in order to merge small and medium sized ‘kirana’ businesses. This would firstly enhance mother-pop shops within the domestic and local markets by tying them to the digital platforms. Once this is over, it would try to penetrate another market by utilizing the dominance of Whatsapp. If all these are successful, Whatsapp might allow JioMart to function through the messaging platform itself. If this is carried out in the manner that Whatsapp comes with default JioMart platform, it could cause an abuse of dominance under Section 4(2)(d) as downloading Whatsapp would be the main agreement the JioMart will be kind of a given in itself. The disadvantage in that kind of a strategy is, customers will not be able to use any other embed e-commerce portal on Whatsapp. This will become unfair and cause disturbances in the market as it might leave the customers with no choice but to accept the given deal.

Learn more about Competition Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified Diploma course! 

The said deal may have an impact on payment apps due to the establishment of Whatsapp Pay project long-stalled by Facebook. The partnership with Jio will establish the payment service for itself. Once Whatsapp Pay enters the field, industry players like Google Pay, Paytm, and Pay will face a tough competition. People will easily be able to text and pay simultaneously without switching apps. To keep things in balance, the Competition Commission of India will have to consider whether Facebook and Jio would become dominant in the relevant markets, potentially abusing the dominant position in order to monopolize the field using Whatsapp Pay. Since the combined power of Jio and Facebook would make it difficult for any other platform to compete, the CCI should analyze whether it would be likely that any anti-competitive acts by Jio or Facebook would create new monopoly in the other relevant markets.

Appreciable Adverse Effect on Competition:

Determining the resources and market positions of the combines techno-heads is difficult, especially in the technology sector. Google LLC[3], CCI found that there is a need to now not only depict the standard applicable marketplace but also related to relevant markets which have been anguished by the behavior of the concerned parties. Section 20 (4) lists that factors that the Competition Commission of India should not forget to include if there is any substantial destructive effect on the competition arising from the said combination.

The quintessence of this combination is to check for horizontal or vertical overlaps. If there is no appearance of horizontal overlaps, there is a strong possibility of vertical integration. For example, Jio introduces internet access to smartphones, smartphones with internet can access Whatsapp, which can ultimately be combined with JioMart. Though this is not the ideal vertical integration, but the use of dominant function in a single market to move into a new marketplace would possibly be to have an adverse effect on the natural competition in the ‘physical’ trade market. Strategic investment, when seeks to impale a specific segment by making use of the leverage on their respective fields to arrive at a completely new product, criteria has to be comprehensive in order to check and verify the potential adverse effect on competition, if any. The United States court imposed 5 billion dollars fine on Facebook for violation of privacy is itself a warning on the Indian regulators to intervening in this a way achieving the deal specifically, to protect the Indian Start-Up movement, which is probably an important bulkhead of the Digital India ship.

Platform Neutrality:

Platform Neutrality, as the name proposes, comprises of impartiality toward any item showed on a market. This standard is abused in occurrences of combination, in which the stage holds a double job through acting each as a mediator and a commercial center contender. Since the stage is a pool of customer insights, it offers the owner business endeavor and side to improve its administrations through dominatingly dispensing bogus hunt rankings and serving one-sided pointers sooner than its customers. Courses of action like these outcomes in the special treatment being concurred to the office’s in-living arrangement cloud kitchen brands, building up an irregularity in the reasonable resistance in the pertinent zone.

It is appropriate to take note that the monstrous e-exchange associations, for example, Amazon and Flipkart have constantly been underneath the examination of the Courts for disregarding the stage impartiality strategies. All India Online Vendors Association had blamed each of those organizations for manhandling their strength inside the relevant commercial center by giving special solutions for there to some degree possessed producers. After due examinations concerning this depends, the CCI had unnoticed the cases of them disregarding any popular rivalry standards. Notwithstanding, rehashed charges by the method of equivalent organizations made the NCLAT award a test into this issue again.

Network Effect:

The Network Effect, additionally called network externality, is the increase picked up by method of the officeholder clients while an additional individual joins the gathering. Its utilization is particularly generally far reaching inside the time area in which the enormous network is a bit of leeway to the clients and the got data fills in as a little something extra for its proprietor. Henceforth, there lies no competition inside the truth that having an enormous base of records can bring about an endeavor achieving a prevailing situation inside the market. This predominance, in sure occasions, can go about as an essential for organizations in leading enemy of forceful conduct. The organizations with the guide of keeping up their matchless quality in a solitary pertinent market contribution to each other material market, in this manner mishandling its energy to develop predominant in both those business sectors. Such moves are named as utilizing and are denied underneath Section four(2)(e) of the Competition Act, 2002 (“the Act”).

Carefully predominant associations like Google have utilized their strength in the past, utilizing its got realities to sell its own administrations for example Google Flights, Google Maps, etc. The creators battle that the arrangement whenever did, might be each other case of this type of misuse. As each Facebook and Jio are at prevailing situations in their particular business sectors, they have an unbridled admittance to realities which can be utilized for their own one of a kind business advantage. For example, WhatsApp by means of its settlement with JioMart can assemble a tremendous heap of data at the admission styles of the customers in India, which later can be used for the ad of the JioMart stage through Facebook. Also, if WhatsApp goes to a choice to make Jio Payments Bank on the grounds that the on line UPI-principally based value elective, it’ll achieve Reliance Companies accessing its total client base, which incorporate the records of its adversary telecom partnerships. Each one of those points of interest blended have the capacity of making Jio and its auxiliaries predominant exclusively dependent on the realities that it recognizes associations own, subsequently which remember it for the ambit of utilizing underneath Indian Competition Act.

Deep Discounting:

Deep Discounting, normally named as ruthless evaluating, happens while a monetarily wealthy organization costs its item at a significantly decline charge contrasted with the contrary organizations inside the commercial center. While the partnerships secure such developments as a component of their expansion approach, the overwhelming development inside the reliance of its client’s outcomes in them achieving a place of intensity, unjustly. This can be mounted by method of depending on Section 19(4)(f) of the Act, which offers for ‘buyer reliance’ as one of the justification for evaluating the predominance of an organization. So as to downsize the burden of such enemy of forceful tendencies, such estimating has been described as maltreatment of strength under Section four(2)(a)(ii) of the Act, making it violative of the standards that ensure honest rivalry in the business sectors.

Jio, inside the past, has been blamed for savage valuing for its net administrations. In truth, following this system, it has developed to be one in everything about most significant telecom producers in India. Subsequently, the creators battle that the arrangement has the capacity of monetarily backing the stage to present profound limits for their items, building up a tremendous distinction in the expenses inside the market. This differential valuing by method of drawing in the clients by means of its uncommon decreases can pressure out the contrary e-staple brands inside the relevant commercial center. While these limits may prompt a fast time-frame advantage for its clients, the minimization in their decisions will achieve a drawn out misfortune. JioMart by utilizing sorting out its imposing business model will in the end be equipped for help its expenses unnecessarily, in this way constraining its customers to search for their items at some random charges.

Learn more about Competition Law with Enhelion’s Law Firm certified Diploma course! 

Conclusion:

The objective of Competition Act, 2002 is to guarantee the free progression of exchange and keep the elements from stopping rivalry on the lookout. In the 21st century, the idea of shopper government assistance can’t be deserted in any of the situations. The intensity of the CCI gave by the Competition Act, 2002 is restricted to a degree. Indian Competition Law doesn’t punish endeavor to turn into a prevailing element and this is the greatest downside.

In the current arrangement, Facebook and Jio Platforms through its administrations WhatsApp Pay and JioMart separately will endeavor to get prevailing in their pertinent market by utilizing unscrupulous strategic policies. Notwithstanding, CCI can’t stop such practices because of absence of arrangements in the Competition Act, 2002. The ideal opportunity for a change has shown up and the Indian Legislature should embed such arrangements in the demonstration so as to enable the CCI to manage such unreasonable practices in the nation.

[1] Section 5, Competition Act, 2002.

[2] Manish Singh, WhatsApp reaches 400 million users in India, Tech Crunch, (26.07.2020), https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/26/whatsapp-india-users-400-million/.

[3] Umar Javeed v. Google LLC, Case No. 39 of 2018, dated 16-4-2019.