Tag: study law degree online australia

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Banking and Investment Laws in USA, UK and UAE

By: Manas Maheshwari 

Introduction

Banks are the most important element of the Financial System of any country. The Economic Development Indicator depends on the efficacy and efficiency of the banking system prevailing in that particular country. The core function of Bank is to accept deposits and lend money thereby acting as an intermediary between depositors and borrowers. The income of  Bank is difference between rate of interest charged to the borrowers and the rate of interest paid to the depositors. This is the traditional function of Banks. In modern times like now, Banks including Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) perform various other value added services to its customers like foreign exchange transactions, providing distinct types of loans other than business loans such as car loans, home loans, education loans etc. , advisory and consultancy services, hire purchase financing, insurance services and many more. The Banking is not limited to the Commercial Banking operations alone. It has widened its limits and has reached the stage where the Investment Bank’s role in the economic development has come into play. The Investment Bank performs dual functions like acting as an underwriter, book manager to the issue, merchant banker, registrar in primary securities market from side of the corporate issuer. The Investment Bank also advises the clients mainly, Institutional Investors about the Buy and Sell side functions. The role of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) also comes into play when the commercial operations has been globalized and particularly when the capital is not at abundance.

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

Analysis of Banking and Investment Laws in UAE

As per the Doing Business Report 2020[1] published by the World Bank, the United Arab Emirates is ranked 16th out of 190 countries. This shows that UAE is gradually becoming  business and financial centric attracting a host of global banks corporate to set up their operations.

Currently, there are three types of Banks operating within UAE. These are:

  1. Commercial Banks;
  2. Islamic Banks and
  3. Foreign Banks.

The Islamic Banks are regulated by the Shariah principles as opposed to the commercial banks leading to many operational differences between the two. The popular banks currently operating in UAE are Emirates NBD, National Bank of Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank, First Gulf Bank and Dubai Islamic Bank.

The UAE Central Bank is the primary regulator for Banking and Financial Services in UAE. Apart from Central Bank, there are various other regulatory bodies namely:

  1. The Insurance Authority (“IA”);
  2. The Securities and Commodities Authority (“SCA”);
  3. Dubai Financial Services Authority (“DFSA”) and
  4. Abu Dhabi Global Market (“ADGM”).

The Regulatory authorities functioning within the federal level are the Central Bank, IA and SCA and those functioning within the emirate level are DFSA (operates within the Dubai International Financial Centre) and ADGM (operating within Abu Dhabi).

The Federal Law No. 10 of 1980[2] governs the Central Bank, the Monetary System and Organization of Banking. The Islamic Banks, Financial Institutions and Investment Companies are governed by Federal Law No. 6 of 1985[3]. The Decretal Federal Law No. 14 of 2018[4] covers the subject of Central Banks and Organization of Financial Institution and their activities. The SCA is governed by Federal Law No. 4 of 2000[5] and issues regulations from time to time which the companies operating in the securities market has to comply with. The IA regulates the Insurance sector in UAE in accordance with Federal Law No. 6 of 2007[6].

The DIFC, being an international Financial hub offers very vibrant environment w.r.t Commercial Banking and Investment Banking services. The laws related to this area of business are:

  1. Companies Law[7];
  2. Electronic Transactions Law[8];
  3. Insolvency Law[9] and
  4. Law of Security[10].

The Financial Collateral Regulations[11], Insolvency Insurers Regulations[12], Security Regulations[13] and Investment Companies Regulations[14] has been amended from time to time by DIFC.

The Central Bank of UAE issues licenses to foreign banks for operating in UAE as per the law that governs the domestic bank licensing. The Investment Banks cannot accept deposits whose maturity period is less than two years with some exceptions and these banks are licensed as per the relevant law[15]. The Islamic Banks can carry all types of Banking, Financial and Investment services and operations as per the relevant federal law.

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

Only authorized Institutions and Companies incorporated as per the Commercial Companies Law are licensed to act as moneychangers[16]. In respect of Financial Intermediaries involved in sale and purchase of stocks and bonds and in money market transactions, only UAE citizen in respect of natural person can act as an intermediary[17]. The responsibility for licensing brokers and intermediaries fall upon SCA in respect of shares and Central Bank in case of currency and commodities.

The Investment Companies as per the resolution[18] adopted by Board of Directors of Central Bank is involved in following businesses:

  1. Managing Portfolios;
  2. Preparing Allotment;
  3. Managing Investment Trust funds and
  4. Acting as a Trustee for managing funds on behalf of Beneficiary.

The Finance Companies undertake the following activities according to the resolution[19] adopted:

  1. Loans and Advances;
  2. Issuing credit guarantee and
  3. Issue of securities such as stocks, bonds, debt etc.

The Laws and Regulations governing Foreign Exchange are:

  1. Anti-Money laundering legislation[20] by Central Bank (To Register Hawala Providers);
  2. Anti-Money Laundering/Anti-Terrorist Financing Regulations[21] by DIFC and
  3. Anti-Money Laundering and Combating the Financing of Terrorism[22] by DMCC.

In the midst of Covid-19 pandemic, the Central Bank of UAE have taken various measures relating to rescheduling loan payments, reducing charges for customers, deferring loan installments, encouraging customers to adopt digital banking services, to boost lending capacity of banks and to provide temporary relief to private sector and retail customers affected by Covid-19 pandemic and directed all banks to carry out sanitization of ATMs on regular basis[23].

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

Analysis of Banking and Investment Laws of UK

As per the Doing Business Report 2020[24] published by World Bank, United Kingdom is ranked 8th out of 190 countries. This establishes the fact that UK Laws and Regulations are business friendly.

Most of the UK laws partakes its character from European laws and regulations. The Primary framework for regulating Banking, Financial Services and Insurance sector in UK is Financial Services and Markets Act 2000[25] (“FSMA”). Apart from this, there are various domestic rules and regulations derived from secondary sources.

The principal regulators for Banks are:

  1. Bank of England (“BOE”);
  2. Prudential Regulation Authority (“PRA”), a division of BOE and
  3. Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”).

The BOE performs a statutory duty exercising its powers in the matter of resolution of Banks if a Bank is declared insolvent. The Financial Policy Committee (“FPC”) of BOE performs macro-supervision over Banking and Financial Sector. The Payments System is regulated by a Payment Systems Regulator and the issuance of Electronic Money is regulated by FCA.

The Primary function of PRA is to supervise the Banking and Insurance Companies[26]. The PRA also ensures proper mechanism of infrastructure in place for performing Banking related functions. It develops strategies in cooperation with the Companies to counter the crisis like situations. The PRA helps in ensuring a sound financial system is in place.

Till 2013, the Financial Services Authority (“FSA”) was the principal regulator for Banking and Financial Services industry. After 2013, the responsibility was divided between PRA and FCA.

The PRA and FCA are different entities working together and having a common aim. The FCA is responsible for ensuring fairness in the Financial Markets. It helps in ensuring a fair outcome for the consumers. The primary objectives[27] of FCA are:

  1. To protect the consumers;
  2. To protect the Financial Markets;
  3. To promote competition and
  4. To work in coordination with consumer groups, trade associations, professional bodies and other stakeholders.

The FCA is an independent public body and the main source of its income is the fees which it charges from its customers. The FCA is accountable to the Parliament and Treasury.

The activities that are regulated under the Banking and Financial sector are incorporated in the Financial and Markets Act (Regulated Activities) Order 2001[28] (“RAO”). Regulated Activities covers the following aspects:

  1. Accepting Deposits;
  2. Securities and Derivatives Business;
  3. Transactions in Investments;
  4. Insurance Activities;
  5. Mortgage Contracts and
  6. Consumer Credit.

In the wake of the global financial crisis in 2008, the UK economy went into a sharp recession. This was the time when the concept of Bank Ring-Fencing was developed. Under this concept, the retail banking services of the Bank were separated from the other services that the Bank offered and were prioritized. The Bank Ring Fencing helps in protecting the consumer banking services from the unexpected events which leads to global financial crisis like situations.

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (“FSCS”) is a deposit insurance scheme which protects the consumers of the firms in financial sector that have failed.

The Consumer credit in UK is mainly regulated by Consumer Credit Act, 1974[29]. The Act regulates the following aspects:

  1. Credit card purchases;
  2. Credit agreements and
  3. Credit advertising.

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

The Banking Resolution aspect is incorporated in the Banking Act 2009[30]. The Bank of England is the UK’s Banking Resolution Authority. The Resolution regime is governed by the Bank of England’s approach to Resolution. This Resolution regime does not apply to the credit unions. The depositors of credit unions are paid out by FSCS up to a maximum limit of 85,000 pounds per credit union[31].

Due to Covid-19 pandemic, the FCA has also reviewed the disaster recovery plans in order to ensure that all the regulations have been complied with[32]. The UK’s exit from the European Union will also have a substantial impact on the Banking and Financial Sector.

Analysis of Banking and Investment Laws in USA

USA has a dual banking system put in place. Both the Federal Banks and State-Chartered Banks are operating in USA. The following categories of Banks are operating in USA:

  1. National Banks;
  2. State-Member Banks;
  3. State non-member Banks;
  4. Foreign Banks;
  5. Private banks;
  6. Industrial Banks and
  7. Trust Companies.

The Banks are required to obtain a charter before accepting deposits and continuing business[33].

The Primary Regulatory Authority for keeping a regulatory oversight over the Banking operation in US is the Federal Reserve System (“Fed”). The Federal Reserve System, being the Central Bank of USA is the primary supervisory authority over Bank Holding Companies, Financial Holding Companies, State Chartered Banks, Savings and Loan Holding Companies. The Federal Reserve is equipped with the following powers:

  1. Remove officers of Banking Companies;
  2. Imposing penalty and fines;
  3. Revoking Bank membership and
  4. Terminating activities of Banks.

The main functions[34] performed by Fed are:

  1. Formulate monetary policy;
  2. Stabilizing the financial system;
  3. Administering the payment and settlement system and
  4. Promoting the consumer awareness and community development.

Besides the Federal Reserve, other regulatory bodies operating in USA are:

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”): The OCC[35] is the primary supervisory authority having oversight over National Banks, Saving Banks and Foreign Banks having branches at federal level. The OCC is an independent unit of the Department of Treasury. It helps in ensuring that the Banks are accountable to customers and comply with the relevant laws and regulations.

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation[36] (“FDIC”): It is an independent agency created to instill the confidence among the general public in the financial system. It insures deposits and supervises the state-chartered Banks. The responsibility of FDIC also lies in administering the deposit insurance fund and managing receiverships.

State Banking Agencies: The State Banking Agencies are responsible for supervising the banks operating at state level. The functions of this agency varies from state to state. Some common functions performed by these agencies are:

  1. Issuing Bank charters;
  2. Conducting examinations at Bank and
  3. Enforcing regulations and levying fines.

Some other important regulators[37] for Banking and Financial oversight are:

  1. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network;
  2. Federal Trade Commission and
  3. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) is the primary regulator of Securities Market in USA. The primary objective of SEC is to protect the investors, develop efficiency in the securities market and to address investor grievances.

The derivative market in USA is regulated by Commodity Futures Trading Corporation (“CFTC”). The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (“NAIC”) is a regulatory organization governed by chief insurance regulators of the respective states. The Insurance Laws are enacted by the respective state legislature under which insurance regulators operate. The legislations related to Banking in USA are:

National Bank Act of 1864[38]: This act performs the functions relating to establishing national banks, creating uniform national currency and establishing OCC.

Federal Reserve Act of 1913[39]: This act established the Federal Reserve System as the Central Bank of USA. The act sets out the framework for the operation of Fed and ensuring stable monetary and financial system.

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

Federal Credit Union Act[40]: This act establishes the National Credit Union Administration for governing the credit unions.

Federal Deposit Insurance Act[41]: This act establishes the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation which will insure the deposits of all banks and saving associations. The FDIC is the primary regulator for state non-member banks.

Bank Holding Company Act of 1956[42]: This act gives enhanced powers to Federal Reserve by regulating the Bank Holding Companies.

International Banking Act of 1978[43]: This act brings foreign banks at par with the domestic Banks w.r.t regulations, capital requirements etc.

The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act[44] was adopted in 1999 for providing affiliation of Banks, securities firms and for safeguarding the personal sensitive data of the customers.

The Dodd-Frank act[45] of 2010 is a comprehensive set of regulations governing financial services borne out of great recession of 2008. The Act performs following functions[46]:

  1. Protecting consumers against any abusive lending and mortgages by Banks;
  2. Overseeing non-banking hedge funds;
  3. Establishing financial stability oversight council;
  4. Orderly shutdown of Banks if it becomes insolvent and
  5. Creating Volcker’s Rule which prohibits banks from owning hedge funds for their own purpose.

Besides these important acts some other important acts such as Bank Secrecy Act[47], Patriot Act[48] etc.

According to Doing Business Report 2020[49] published by World Bank Group, the United States of America is ranked 6th out of 190 countries. The Banking and Investment related laws in USA are quite business friendly and amended from time to time in response to the latest developments.

 

[1] The World Bank, Ease of Doing Business Rankings, Link.

[2] Union Law No. (10) of 1980.

[3] Federal Law No. (6) of 1985.

[4] Decretal Federal Law No. (14) of 2018.

[5] Federal Law No. (4) of 2000.

[6] Federal Law No. (6) of 2007.

[7] DIFC Law No. 5 of 2018.

[8] DIFC Law No. 2 of 2017.

[9] DIFC Law No. 1 of 2019.

[10] DIFC Law No. 8 of 2005.

[11] DIFC Financial Collateral Regulations, November 01, 2019.

[12] DIFC Insolvency (Insurers) Regulations, September 29, 2008.

[13] DIFC Securities Regulations, November 01, 2019.

[14] DIFC Investment Companies Regulations, November 12, 2018.

[15] UAE Central Bank, Banking, Link.

[16] UAE Central Bank, Banking, Link.

[17] UAE Central Bank, Banking, Link.

[18] Resolution No. 164/8/94 dated 18 April 1995.

[19] Resolution No. 58/3/96 dated 14 April 1996 and Resolution No. 165/06/2004 dated 6 December 2004.

[20] Central Bank of UAE, Anti-Money laundering legislation,  Link.

[21] DIFC Non-Financial Anti Money Laundering/Anti-Terrorist Financing (AML/CFT) Regulations, Link.

[22] DMCC Anti-Money Laundering and Combating the Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) Policy and Process, Link.

[23] Mazen Boustany and Samar Safar Aly, Guidance for Financial Services Industry in the UAE, April 01, 2020, Link.

[24] The World Bank, Ease of Doing Business Rankings, Link.

[25] 2000 c 8.

[26] Bank of England, What is the Prudential Regulation Authority?, Link.

[27] Financial Conduct Authority, About the FCA, Link.

[28] 2001 No. 544.

[29] 1974 c 39.

[30] 2009 c 1.

[31] Financial Services Compensation Scheme, About us, Link.

[32] Mazen Boustany and Samar Safar Aly, Guidance for Financial Services Industry in the UAE, April 01, 2020, Link.

[33] Baker McKenzie, Global Financial Services Regulatory Guide, Link.

[34] Federal Reserve System, About the Fed, Link.

[35] Office of Comptroller of Currency, Who We Are, Link.

[36] Federal Deposit Insurance Scheme, About Us, Link.

[37] Baker McKenzie, Global Financial Services Regulatory Guide, Link

[38] 12 U.S. Code § 38.

[39] Pub. L. 63-43.

[40] 12 USC § 1751 et al.

[41] Pub. L. 81-797.

[42] 70 Stat. 133.

[43] 92 Stat. 607.

[44] 113 Stat. 1338.

[45] 124 Stat. 1376-2223.

[46] Mark Koba, Dodd-Frank Act: CNBC Explains, Link.

[47] 84 Stat. 1114-2.

[48] 115 Stat. 272.

[49] The World Bank, Ease of Doing Business Rankings, Link.

Learn more about Investment and Banking Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course by Corp Comm legal!

Categories
Blog

Laws relating to Private Equity in the Construction Industry

By: Ananyaa Jha

Introduction

The capital investment in a business plays a major role in determining its long-term sustainability and success and there are various sources available, one of which is private equity, which has gained momentum since the past two decades in India, especially owning to the boom of the IT sector. At present the private equity (PE) firms are showing tremendous growth, the funds are distributed evenly across different sectors to mitigate the risk-factor. PE is a capital form of investment in a company that is not listed or traded publicly.

The paper discusses the law governing private equity in India along with how does a PE investment work. It also throws light upon the increasing demand for last-mile funding in construction industry and how private equity can come to the rescue.

Private Equity & its’ Importance?

The term private equity refers to capital investment in an entity that isn’t publicly traded. It’s an interest or ownership in a company that isn’t publicly listed. Private Equity investment can be made in a public company with the objective of making them private and delisting them from the stock exchange platform. Private Equity investors gain equity in return for the capital they invest in the company. Private Equity investors are generally institutional investors (such as banks, hedge funds, pension funds etc.) or individuals having a high net worth, or private equity firms comprising of accredited investors.[1]

Private Equity is different than venture capital as the latter is a funding provided to start-ups or entities which are in the nascent stages which showcase a lucrative growth in the long run, whereas private equity is more commonly invested in mature businesses that have already been established but are unable to generate profits due to poor performance & lack of efficiency, and are in-turn failing.  Private Equities play an active role in the functioning of an entity in order to improve the performance and help steer the company in the direction of increased revenues so that upon selling the investment and exiting from the entity, a generous amount of profit can be earned.[2]

Learn more about Private Equity Law in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by ANB Legal Advocates and Solicitors!

PE is a crucial form of investment as along with providing the required liquidity in a project, it stimulates entrepreneurship & increases shareholders value, in turn promoting job creation and fuelling economic growth. PE leans towards the riskier side of an investment scale as there is high likelihood of a company failing to perform. It involves a high level of long-term risk in order to yield high returns. Various strategies of PE investment include but is not limited to- growth equity funds, leveraged buyouts, venture capital investments, certain real estate investment amongst others.

Construction Industry & Private Equity

Construction industry and private equity have joined hands for the past many years, coming together to fund significant development projects worldwide. In the absence of PE firms, a lot of real estate development projects wouldn’t see the light of day or wouldn’t have reached the finish line. In this industry, the PE firms make available the required funds to help a project start and finish. These firms have a major role to play in the development of real estate.

Development of the real estate in any country is a costly affair, sometimes requiring the support of foreign investors too. The entire project can cost upwards of 10 to 100 crores. In majority, the development firms fall short of the necessary amount to fund the project in its entirety. This is where PE firms come into the picture. Usually, a banking institution will cover a hefty amount of the costs yet it leaves approximately 20-35% to be funded by the developers, which could still be a large amount, unable to be funded by the developers on their own, they may require additional help funding their project, bringing in private equity.[3]

If a PE firm chooses to invest in a real estate development project, they will have a major role to play in the process of decision-making. Basically, the PE firm/investor are regarded as either a majority or a part-owner of the property in which they are investing, owing to the large scale of investment in the project, they get entitled to a considerable scale of ownership of said project, which entitles them to have substantial influence in all the decisions to be made. They will provide their input throughout the construction process. The construction firm, in all becomes indebted to the PE firm.

Learn more about Private Equity Law in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by ANB Legal Advocates and Solicitors!

The year 2020 has witnessed a drop in PE investments because of the novel coronavirus disease’s outbreak (COVID-19 pandemic). The chance of specific sectors like healthcare, technology, e-commerce among a few others currently bringing about investment opportunities exists[4].

The real estate industry has taken a major hit due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and the end of first quarter (March) has shown the sector to reach an all-time low. Commercial as well as residential sectors have been hit severely.[5] The already ailing residential sector in terms of poor demand is witnessing a hard time to launch any new projects or to even finish the ongoing projects due to shortage of labour and continuous construction stoppage.[6]

The slowdown in the sector will remain even post COVID-19 crisis and as lockdowns relaxation continues nationwide, since the construction sector is faced with a critical working capital crisis which holds utmost importance to restart the business & sustain it successfully. Many have their hopes pinned on intervention by the government to help recover the loss created by the pandemic. However, private equity can prove to be of aid in this current scenario.

The regulatory framework revolving around PE funds in India

In India, commonly the PE funds are established as trusts & in accordance with SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012, are registered as an alternative investment fund (AIF). Although, only a company, trust and limited liability partnership are available to be used as the legal vehicle for the PE funds. Companies Act, 2013 provides for PE funds to be established as companies but this method is not used much due to the lax compliance required in comparison to trust structures and in addition, the unclear precedents for fund-raising. According to the Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) Act, 2008, the alternative investment funds can be instituted as LLPs, however, the LLPs use for PE funds is quite rare.[7] The regulatory framework:

  1. SEBI (AIF) Regulations, 2012

SEBI via notification dated May 21, 2012, repealed & replaced 1996 Venture Capital Funds Regulations of SEBI with the Alternative Investment Funds Regulations of 2012, The AIF Regulations were intended to provide for unregulated funds & extends its principles in this regard along with increasing stability and accountability of the market. There are 3 categories along which these AIFs are spread. Category II categorizes such AIFs which don’t come under the ambit of Category I & III. According to regulations, PE funds get registered as Category II. The purpose of preparing these regulations was to create a standard structure in order to govern private set of funds & investment vehicles to improve the channelizing of the funds.

SEBI has recently issued a circular that introduces various notable changes to the legal framework that currently exists. To strengthen the disclosures required, SEBI directed compulsory Performance Benchmarking along with standardizing PPM, that’s the prime document for disclosing all the relevant information to the potential investors, & Annual Audits for the alternative investment funds. On 1st March, 2020, all these changes have been enforced.

  1. The Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act, 2013 brought with it a required overhaul for companies’ governance in India. The Act of 2013 brought major changes by placing regulatory responsibility, accountability & heavy compliance policies on private companies. Private companies take the ‘private placement’ route to raise capital as they aren’t permitted to offer securities to the general public & raise capital, so they have to take a different approach, wherein the securities are issued to only a selected no. of private individuals. Section 42 of the Act governs the ‘private placement’ process and all such private companies have to comply with the provisions contained in the section. The Section plainly states an invitation or an offer can’t be made to over 200[8] individuals, excluding the securities that are offered under ESOP[9] & the Qualified Institutional Buyers, but such immense rules in respect of PE funds are inapt because regulating the investments that are done through PE funds do not necessitate large compliances because the securities aren’t offered to the public. [10]

Learn more about Private Equity Law in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by ANB Legal Advocates and Solicitors!

The working of PE Investment

Elucidated below is a guideline which the investors/firms need to follow when they invest in private equity of an entity:

  • Raising Capital & Share-Purchase: The Private Equity investment process starts with chalking out an acquisition plan, & ways in which capital for it could be raised, that encompasses decisions based on different kinds of financing used for raising capital, etc, along with conducting due diligence. As soon as the acquisition deal closes, the management duties of the firm that’s been acquired becomes the responsibility of PE investors.
  • The Acquired Company’s Restructuring: The subsequent move is restructuring of the firm required to increase its productivity by managing the company through improving operations & reducing costs. It covers a wide range of crucial decisions about the operations, the expansion, the profitability, the strategy to be adopted, along with the company’s growth model. The involvement level will be directly proportional to the size of their investment.[11]
  • Selling/Exiting the Company: Generally, the end mission of PE firms is putting the company on sale/exiting at a sizeable profit, which usually takes place after around 3 to 7 successful years after initial investment, although the number of years may vary depending on specific strategic circumstances. After the acquired company begins profiting, & continues to show consistent growth, it is the right time to sell it as there exists high probability of the promoters gaining enormous profits from the sale of the entity. The PE investors get their share of the profits and enjoy a good return.

The demand for last-mile funding in Construction Industry

PE firms have been on the look out to take advantage out of the increasing need of last-mile funding by the construction/real-estate developers because of the on-going stagnation in the residential sector which has worsened due to the liquidity crisis that is existent in the country. Many of the PE investors are keeping an eye for offering capital out of existing funds for construction projects which are in the final or late stage & also establishing platforms in order to finance such real estate projects. [12]

After Real Estate (Regulations & Development) Act (RERA) was implemented in 2017, the developers since then have focused on completing the construction projects & so the demand for funding capital in the late-stages has soared. The banks unwillingness to refinance loan in addition to the liquidity crisis in the financial market has elevated the demand for PE funds because a substantial number of late-stage projects are unable to finish due to lack of capital.

Given the scenario, influx of last-mile capital funding coming in to complete projects is very positively transformative for all the concerned stakeholders. The benefit of last-mile funding is that comparatively it’s a less risky approach as these projects have the necessary approvals, the construction has begun & to some extent have started bringing about sales, so all of this helps to mitigate the risk involved, which provides better chances of reward & hence, investors interests piques.

The PE firms’ interest in the real estate sector is growing at the same time when the government is taking initiative to revive the sector. The government in 2019 announced the establishment of a Rs 25,000 crore AIF in respect of last-mile funding to get the stalled residential projects back on track, because sales have been on the declining scale since 2014, except a marginal rise in the year 2016, but the demonetisation decision by the government & goods and services tax (GST) implementation worsened the situation in 2017 & since the recovery in the sector is moving very slowly.

Conclusion

Private Equity and the construction sector haven’t always connected as the PE investors have by & large steered clear of the construction industry owing to a great deal of inherent risks, like the business having a cyclic nature, professional management, succession planning along with the unrealised expectations in respect of financial requirements of the construction business, i.e., bonding, & the owners of construction companies have been apprehensive of outside investors. However, that perception is changing as PE investors will bring not just financial aid but act as a strategic partner, unlike the other sources of capital & work with the business & make a sustainable model by keeping a long-term vision, thereby maximizing value. The PE firms will bring in deep understanding of the construction industry & help the companies grow by investing not just capital but an array of other valuable requirements for the company to grow.[13]

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/financial-careers/09/private-equity.asp, (Last Visited at 9:00 AM on 6th November, 2020).

[2] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/020415/what-difference-between-private-equity-and-venture-capital.asp#:~:text=Private%20equity%20is%20capital%20invested,potential%20for%20long%2Dterm%20growth., (Last Visited at 10:00 AM on 6th November, 2020).

[3] https://workwithfocus.com/news/private-equitys-role-in-real-estate-development-construction/, Last Visited at 5 PM on 6th November, 2020.

[4] Rukmini Rao, “Coronavirus: E-commerce, SaaS and healthcare to attract more PE funding, says report”, Business Today, May 14, 2020, available at https://www.businesstoday.in/current/corporate/coronavirus-e-commerce-saas-and-healthcare-to-attract-more-pe-funding-says-report/story/403823.html (last visited at 2 PM on 6th November, 2002).

[5] Knight Frank India Survey.

[6] Kailash Babar, “Covid-19 impact: Real estate sentiments hit lowest level”, The Economic Times, April 16, 2020, available at https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/wealth/real-estate/covid-19-impact-real-estate-sentiments-hit-lowest-level/articleshow/75175857.cms?from=mdr (last visited at 7 PM on 6th November, 2020).

[7] Pratish Kumar, Sumitava Basu and Divya Dhage, “Private Equity in India: market and regulatory overview”, available at https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/8-504-2425?transitionType=Default&contextData=(sc.Default)&firstPage=true, (last visited at 11:00 AM on 6th November, 2020).

[8]  Rule 14 of the Companies (Prospectus and Allotment of Securities) Rules, 2014.

[9] Employee Stock Option Plan

[10] B&B Associates, “Private Equity in India: Evolution and Legal Overview”, July 31, 2020, available at: https://bnblegal.com/article/private-equity-in-india-evolution-and-legal-overview/, (last visited at 9:00 PM on 8th November, 2020).

[11] https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/careers/companies/equity-firm/, last visited at 11:00 AM on 8th November, 2020.

[12] Bidya Sapam, “Private equity firms sense big opportunity in last-mile real estate funding”, December 3, 2019, available at: https://www.livemint.com/industry/infrastructure/private-equity-firms-sense-big-opportunity-in-last-mile-real-estate-funding-11575311313757.html, (Last Visited at 10 AM on 9th November, 2020).

[13] https://www.cohnreznick.com/insights/private-equity-builds-bridges-construction-industry#:~:text=Private%20equity%20brings%20a%20lot,a%20company%20needs%20to%20grow., last visited at 11:30 AM on 10th November, 2020.

Learn more about Private Equity Law in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by ANB Legal Advocates and Solicitors!

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Laws Relating To Criminal Procedure In India, USA And UAE

By: Divyashree Dhumal

The Criminal Justice System is designed to delivers justice for all. Which also means protecting the innocent, convicting criminal and providing fair trails. The Code of Criminal Procedure is provided with the rules and regulations that has to be followed by the Court and Police. The Code of Criminal Procedure does not define what are violations of laws but rather set out procedure on how a criminal case should be handled. The Code of Criminal Procedure is important for the Defendant.  The Code of Criminal Procedure guarantee’s constitutional due process to those individuals charged with crime.

It is an objective of the Code to provide an opportunity of fair trail to the accused person and to make sure that the right of the accused is not compromised. The code makes sure that there is no delay made in the investigation and ensures fair trial. It also ensures the attendance of any person who is related to with the case through the means of warrants, summons, proclamation and attachments of the property. The Code provides a detailed scheme for the working of various functionaries of the state to help and administration of the justice.

Learn more about Advanced Certificate on Civil Procedural Laws in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by Legaleye Advocates and Legal Consultants!

The Code of Criminal Procedure in India.[1]

Earlier there was no constant procedure for the Criminal Justice system in India. In 1861, the Code of Criminal Procedure was passed by the British Government. It was first created in the year 1882 and then amended in the year 1898.

In (iqbal v state of maharashtra, 1975) the Supreme Court said, “It is the procedure that spells much difference between the rule of law and the rule of the whim and caprice.”

The Code of the criminal procedure is called a Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). It is Substantive criminal law in India. The act contains 484 sections further divided into 37 chapters, 2 schedules, and 56 forms. It provides detailed information about the investigation of crime, apprehension of a suspected person, evidence collection, determination of the guilt, and determination of punishment to the offenders. The Code describes all the offenses that are present in the Indian Penal Code on how should they be dealt with.

The CrPC provides uniform sets of criminal courts throughout the territory of India by conferring jurisdictions, powers, and functions. The Code separates the Judiciary from the Executive, which enables the state to work differently without the interference of any other organ of the state. The Judicial Magistrate works under the High Court of their respective States. The Judicial Hierarchy is represented by the Chief Judicial Magistrate and first- and second-class Judicial Magistrate, District Magistrate and subordinate magistrate. Earlier jury system was followed now the jury system has been abolished.

Under the Code of Procedure, every person is entitled to Fair trail and hearing from an independent and impartial tribunal. The Accused is considered to be innocent until proven guilty. The Accused has the right to be represented by a counsel. In case, The Accused is poor and in no condition to appoint a counsel then the court provides free legal aid. Some Special provision are provided under section 313,315 and 164(2), etc. made for protecting the rights of the Accused. Special provision is made for Protection of the accused person. Supreme court of India has also given guidelines with respect of right of the accused person (D.K. Basu vs State of West Bengal , AIR 1997).

Learn more about Advanced Certificate on Civil Procedural Laws in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by Legaleye Advocates and Legal Consultants!

The Procedure of the Summary cases is same as the Summons cases except where it is provided. In summons cases the offences are punishable with imprisonment up to two years. Additional revisional jurisdiction powers are also given to the session’s courts by the High Court. The revision power given to the Superior Courts cannot be exercised by the Interlocutory orders. An appeal by the state in case of acquittal can be only filed only after obtaining leave from the High court. The Court has the power punish the blatant matters in case of perjury on the spot. Public Prosecutors and assistant public prosecutors are systematized and qualification is prescribed for the same. If a case is related to the central government which has to be removed then the consent of the government has to be taken.

Code of Criminal Procedure in USA[2]

There is federative structure in the United States, the federal government and each state has their own criminal justice processes, federal criminal procedure law and 50 different state jurisdictions. The pre-trial (investigatory) process and the trial (adjudicatory) process are the two parts of criminal law procedure.

In the first century Supreme Court of United states had no constitutional criminal procedure decisions. There were two reason for this and professor Akhil Amar pointed out two reason for that: first in (Barron v. Baltimore , 1833) the court decision meant that then federal constitution did not apply in state proceedings until the incorporation of the bill of rights after the fourteenth Amendment. Second, general appellate jurisdiction over federal criminal cases until 1891 was lacked by the court. The Criminal Procedure of USA has been derived from several source of law. The criminal procedure is different from civil procedures.

Under 3 article, 2 section, clause 3 provide that in trail of crimes except in impeachment case, such trail shall be held in the states where the said crime has been committed and if not committed in that state then at a place or places as the congress by law suggests and also there shall be jury for these cases. Fifth amendment is a relevant part of the United States Constitution, which says that no person shall be answerable for a capital, or infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of grand jury, except in cases of land or naval forces, or Militia,  when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.

Sixth amendment provides rights for the accused person such as in a criminal prosecution the accused person has right to speedy and public trail, with an impartial jury of the State and District where the crime has been committed. Eighth amendment provides that excessive bail shall not be required. Fourteenth amendment provides that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law nor deny any person within the jurisdiction for equal protection of the law. Burden of proof always lies on the prosecution in a criminal trial which means that the Prosecution has to prove beyond the reasonable doubt that the defendant is liable. As there is no burden on the defendant. The Defendant has to only prove that it reasonably possible that the defendant did not commit the crime. Once both the sides have presented their cases then the case goes to the jury. The jury is made aware of all the legal rules which may affect the decision. the jury then deliberate in the jury room about whether the defendant is Guilty or not of the particular crime.

Learn more about Advanced Certificate on Civil Procedural Laws in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by Legaleye Advocates and Legal Consultants!

At that point the jury is not allowed to discuss about it to anyone other than the other jury members or even read about the cases. Once the jury has decided it is called as verdict. In case the defendant is found guilty the sentence of the defendant is done by the Judge. After the sentence, the case enters the post-conviction stage and the defendant has the right to appeal to the Higher Court. American appellate does not retry the cases. In USA Plea bargaining takes place even in most serious crime such as homicide. Plea bargaining becomes impossible when the defendant is charged or indicted for the crime. After the defendant has plead guilty, the court recalls its rights. The parties participate in a discussion in which they try to agree on a particular sentence range and once they have reached to an agreement the case is disclosed in an open court. the court has the authority whether to accept the plea or not.

Criminal Procedure in UAE

The Initial step in a Criminal action for the victim is to file a complaint against the offender to the police. The complaint should set out the details of the incident that had occurred and the series of events pertaining to the criminal offences. The complaint can be in formal writing or by the way of oral statement before the police which is recorded in Arabic and then signed by the complainant. The complainant has to file the complaint before police station which has the jurisdiction. The complainant has the authority to call a witness who can testify against the offender which will be in his favour. Following the complaint, the police will have to get in contact with the accused and take his/her statement. During this whole process the accused can bring in potential witnesses who can testify for the accused.

The police have to report the case to the relevant department within the police station that are responsible for opining and reviewing the complaint. Once the police have finalized their task after taking the statements of all the parties, the complaint is given to the police prosecutor, a judicial authority empowered to refers cases to the Court. The Criminal trial in Arabic, and all statements are taken in or translated into Arabic. The Court provides the accused with sworn translator. Cases are heard before judges only, a closed setting. Only the legal counsel, the defence counsel and the parties to the case, along with the witnesses that may be haven been called are allowed in the chambers. In case if a minor is involved then parents and legal guardians can attend. There are no jury trails. The duration of a trail may vary and it depends on the emirate in which you are tried. There is no limit to the duration of trail. The punishment under U.A.E penal code are divided into two categories, sharia- based and Chastisement.

Conclusion

There is not much difference in the criminal procedure around the world and how they are enforced and applied. The Criminal trail works in the same way. But the criminal procedure in USA and India are much detailed and elaborated then UAE Criminal Procedure. The procedure of the investigation by police are also the same.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_constitutional_criminal_procedure

Learn more about Advanced Certificate on Civil Procedural Laws in India with Enhelion’s Online Law firm certified course certified by Legaleye Advocates and Legal Consultants!

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Marketing Strategies of Luxury Brand

By: Bushra Sarwar

What is a luxury brand?

The brand is the identity of a product which get associated with the customer. Branding is like the positioning of the product in the mind of the consumer. As per marketing management professor, Kotler, brands are designed by companies in such a way so that consumer can relate it or get associated with it.

As per the Economic theory, luxury brands are those brands whose demands increase with the rise in income of the consumer. Luxury brands are in contrast to the necessity of goods. So, the need of luxury brand is proportionally related to payment of the consumer. They are mostly status symbol products and catered to classy people. Luxury brands are targeted to high-class income group people.

Sometimes, luxury brands are equal to superior products. The essence of luxury goods is that they have high demand elasticity of sales, which suggests that they can profusely partake in the buying of luxury goods as individuals become bounteous & wealthier. However, this also means that if there is a reduction in consumer income, then demand will also decrease.

First and foremost, a brand-driven industry is the luxury industry. People purchase luxury products and services because they trust the brand and love it. Premium products and services are guided by their brand perception and success rather than any other group.

Learn more about Marketing Management Foundations with Enhelion’s Online course certified by Sahil Malhotra!

How companies build luxury brands:

How do businesses build profitable brands? How do they make those products resonate through time and space with customers? What are the main success factors that cause the global brand environment to be dominated by some brands? These questions come into the mind of the CEO of the company and brand manager all around the world.  Develop a brand is not a one day or one-time affair. It is a long-term process to develop the image of a product in the mind of consumers. The company needs specific marketing and branding plan to increase brand outreach.

Source: Author’s Creation

Figure 1 Process of building Luxury Brands

Figure 1 presents the process of creating luxury brands. Identification of niche segment is the most critical steps in the process of building brands. For different products, the company should adopt different differentiation strategies. Develop the symbol for creating value in the brands. The brand creates exclusivity feature to make a difference among other brands. These all part together position the image of the brand in the mind of the customer. The above component will help brand managers to create luxury brands.

List of top 10 popular luxury brands

Source: branddirectory.com

What are marketing strategies?

The long-term preparation of corporate targets that the organisation aims to accomplish is a Marketing Strategy/Technique. It is necessary to choose specific measures to consolidate the credibility of goods and services or increase market sales to achieve these objectives. To identify the target market and to be able to keep customers loyal to the organisation to improve the positioning of the company, it is necessary to use opportunities.

To achieve positioning among customers and satisfy consumer and organisational relationship loyalty, it is essential to identify how do you want to place or position the product/service in the market. It is the method of creating sales opportunities, also of communicating and setting the product or service, and of translating the organisational lines that allow the correct channels to reach a target market.

Why does Company need marketing strategies?

Figure 3 Why company needs marketing strategies?

Source: Author’ created

Learn more about Marketing Management Foundations with Enhelion’s Online course certified by Sahil Malhotra!

Marketing strategies adopted by luxury brands:

As per 2014 Mckinsey report, digital platform influences the 45% sale of luxury products. Luxury brands prefer to do advertising through print and electronic media. Nowadays, shoppers spent most of its time on online shopping, so luxury brands are coming on a digital platform to promote their products. Taylor (2020) suggested digital marketing strategies for luxury brands:

Analysis of marketing strategies

Michael porter defined four kind of generic strategies to create competitive advantage.

  • Cost leadership
  • Cost focus
  • Differentiation Leadership
  • Differentiation Focus

The Cost Leadership Approach focuses on minimising the cost of providing a customer’s goods or services, to become cost-efficient and add value to your shareholder’s wealth.

Under differentiation strategy, instead of focusing on the most part, brands differentiated their products from competitors. Under which business houses differentiate their products in terms of design, comfort, quality, and value-added features. As per Oh and Kim (2011), most brands prefer to use differentiation marketing strategy to create a difference in the market. Oh, et al., (2011) conducted this study in Asian countries (Japan, China and South Korea) and chose Louise Vuitton brand to study marketing strategies. The author found three critical factors which create Louise Vuitton as a brand: innovation, differentiation and customer-centric advertising.

Cost focus strategy focuses on cost leadership to focus on a niche market. Cost leadership strategy does not work on luxury products. Any strategy based on low costing would not work in fashion brands. Differentiation focus is the part of the differentiation strategy, which is used by the luxury brands.

PEST and SWOT Analysis:

  • PEST stands for political, economical, social and technological factor analysis.
  • SWOT stands for strength, weakness, opportunity and threat analysis.

SWOT & PEST tests are two approaches through which businesses plan ahead by carrying out research. Such variables are primary determinants of strategic planning. Businesses may fail to achieve desired objectives without SWOT and PEST analysis.

Learn more about Marketing Management Foundations with Enhelion’s Online course certified by Sahil Malhotra!

Marketing strategies of famous brands:

Apple’s Brand:

Apple follows a straightforward brand strategy.  As their tagline says: Think different, Apple think differently at every stage of the product (product preparation to launching). Apple does not merely sell a phone or tablet; they simply sell a lifestyle to its luxury customers. Apple’s brand marketing makes people realize that they need an apple product to enrich their life with quality products and profitable experience.

Nike’s Brand:

Nike creates a strategy by knitting the story of a brand. Nike takes this opportunity to make a possible story around its every product to start the ideas, which fascinate the customers.

Adding a storytelling element to your brand or presenting the meaning of your business storey to your customers adds a human element to your organisation and can be a perfect marketing strategy for you.

McDonald Brand:

McDonald is not a new name in the market; it is recognized worldwide. Marketing strategy of McDonald is to maintain consistency.

How did McDonald’s build a name so distinguishable? Well, for over 60 years, they have kept their brand name and product consistent while making thoughtful and on-brand enhancements. Their logo has remained nearly identical, and their marketing taglines have relentlessly endorsed the same message: we make you happy.

Conclusion:

This write-up talks about the analysis of the marketing strategies of luxury brands. The article starts with the introduction of luxury brands and how companies are creating luxury brands by adopting differentiation strategies and top 10 brands based on brand value globally. It also provides an understanding of marketing strategies and why luxury brands needed marketing strategies and what marketing strategies followed by brands.

This article also analysed the Michael porter competitive advantage strategies and found the luxurious brands follow differentiation strategy. PEST and SWOT analysis are the two essential techniques followed by companies to achieve desired objectives. Finally write up concluded by comparing the marketing strategies followed by famous brands: Apple, Nike and McDonalds.

 

Learn more about Marketing Management Foundations with Enhelion’s Online course certified by Sahil Malhotra!

 

 

References:

Top 50 luxury brands 2020. Retrieved by https://brandirectory.com/rankings/luxury-and-premium/table

https://www.toolshero.com/marketing/marketing-strategy/

How to build luxury brands. https://martinroll.com/resources/articles/strategy/five-steps-to-build-a-luxury-brand/

Oh, S., & Kim, J. (2011). Analysis of the Marketing Strategy of a Luxury Brand and its Success in Selected Asian Countries. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences, 6(1).

Taylor, M. (2020). 10 Marketing Strategies For Luxury Brands That Deliver Results. Retrieved from https://www.ventureharbour.com/luxury-brand-digital-marketing/

 

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Corporate Laws in USA, UK and UAE

By: Tanvi Rai

Introduction

“A modern economy is marked by the feasibility of endogenous change: Modernization brings myriad arrangements from expanded property rights to company law and financial institutions.”

– Edmund Phelps

Corporate law, which is also commonly known as enterprise, business, commercial or company law is a sphere of law which deals with managing and governing rights, duties, relationships and conduct of various companies, organisations, businesses and even persons. It is directly related to the life cycle of a company/corporation/business hence it involves the company’s formation, funding, governance, death and many more related aspects.

An additional aspect of Corporate Governance is represented by capital markets, culture of the business, share ownership, and many more aspects, legal rules, characteristics, problems differ from one jurisdiction to another, yet are present in across the world. Corporate law essentially regulates and controls relations amongst companies, its investors, shareholders, board of directors, employees, creditors, other stakeholders like the government, consumers, the society at large and environment along with their interaction with one another. Commercial law is umbrella term which includes company and business laws and all activities related to them. This also includes financial and corporate governance laws.

Learn more about Corporate Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Brief Historical Background of Company Law

The modern company law began in the year 1844 in England, United Kingdoms, with passing of the Joint Stock Companies Act. For the very first time a corporation/company could have been incorporated by registration. Before this act, a company could only be incorporated by obtaining either by sanction of a special Act of the Parliament of England or by obtaining a Royal Charter. There was also an important creation made in the process, which was re creation of office of the Registrar of the Joint Stock Companies. In the year 1855, the English Parliament passed another act namely the limited Liability Act which provided for the limited liability to the members of a registered company. Further, in 1856, a new and comprehensive act came into force which superseded the 1854 act and marked the starting of new company law in England creating articles and memorandum of association.

In North America, this charter and new law had two purposes, one was the colonizing rub-off, and another was a trading purpose. The Hudson’s Bay company was almost completely dedicated to only trading activities but most companies like Plymouth, London Company, Massachusetts Bay Company were wholly engaged in settlement of colonists. In other parts, the chartered English Companies continued to be formed for the expansion of new trade.

Analysis of Corporate Laws in USA, UK and UAE

Corporate Law in United States of America

The United States of America is the world’s largest economy having corporate laws at federal, state and local levels and has been flooded with business prospects. This corporate law at the federal level creates minimum requirements for business in company shares and governance rights. Being capitalistic democracy, the country and its corporate laws allow the companies to get incorporated in the state of their choice and convenience, regardless of the place of their headquarters. This and other standards have been enlisted in the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities and exchange Act of 1934. Over the last century, Delaware General Corporation Law is the most preferred State Law for incorporation of major Corporations and companies. This is specifically for the of lower corporate taxes, lesser shareholder rights against the board of directors of the company and that Delaware has a specialised court and legal profession. Nevada has replication the same. Out of the fifty states, twenty-four of them abide by the Model Business Corporation Act, whereas the states of New York and California are essential due to their massive size.

Incorporation, Charter Competition and Corporate Personality

The articles of incorporation are the foundation of the Company, they not just laid about the basics but also determine the state of incorporation of the company and accordingly levels of corporate taxes, various qualities of shareholder and stakeholder rights, the duties of directors and other things are determined. A business which has been rightly and legally incorporated acquires the status of a separate legal entity which is different from that of its investors. The company can both sue and be sued in its own name.

Learn more about Corporate Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Corporate Governance

In principle, a corporation’s constitution can be designed in any way so long as it complies with the compulsory rules set down by the state or federal legislature. Most state laws, and the federal government, give a broad freedom to corporations to design the relative rights of directors, shareholders, employees and other stakeholders in the articles of incorporation and the by-laws.

Duties of the Director

Decisions of a company are majorly entrusted on the directors; these can retrain as well as empower the directors in whose favour they exercise their discretion. The directors should promote shareholder value, which exercising their own business judgement to balance all the claims against various stakeholders, employees, and shareholders. Another duty of the directors are their fiduciary duties which expects them to avoid any conflict of interest between their own pursuit of profit and the interests of the corporation. Another requirement in most of the states is a basic duty of care in performance, this standard is determined from the fact that any prudent man could follow in any contract of services. But the state of Delaware has discarded these duties and allows liability waivers. Duty of care, which is primarily rested upon the shoulders of the board of directors includes standard of diligence and to act with reason and care.

Derivative Suits

The Board of Director owe their duties and responsibilities to the company as whole and not to each and every shareholder and stakeholders individually therefore the right to sue for breach of duty by the Board of directors as a whole or a single director rests by default with the company itself. Hence, this creates a problem where action is brought against a single director when the company has been taken over and the board is non- friendly or has been replaced after the company suffering bankruptcy. There are a few solutions to the aforementioned problem, first being that jurisdictions outside of US allow specific share to shareholders to claim is right. Second is by giving standing to sue to non-shareholder groups and last and the main alternative is with an independent shareholder to derive a claim on company’s behalf to sue for breach of duty. This is decided by the courts on the merits of the case.

Corporate Law in United Kingdom

The Department of Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform which is BERR and was formerly the Department of Trade and Industry the DTI is responsible for corporate law and Governance Directorate. UK’s interest in the development of EU company law is represented by this directorate. Matters relating to various aspects of corporate governance are dealt with in codes of best practice.

Formation of the Company

An assortment of organizations might be consolidated under the Companies Act 2006. Individuals keen on beginning the undertaking – the forthcoming chiefs, representatives and investors – may pick, initially, a limitless or a restricted organization. “Limitless” will mean the incorporators will be obligated for all misfortunes and obligations under the overall standards of private law. The choice of a restricted organization prompts a subsequent option.

Rules of Attribution

While a limited organization is considered to be a legitimate individual separate from its investors and representatives, truly, an organization can just act through its workers, from the directorate down. So there should be standards to credit rights and obligations to an organization from its actors. This typically matters in light of the fact that an oppressed outsider will need to sue whoever has cash to pay for penetrate of a commitment, and organizations as opposed to their representatives frequently have more cash.

Directors’ Duties

Directors designated to the board structure the focal expert in UK organizations. In doing their capacities, directors (regardless of whether officially designated, accepted, or “shadow directors”) owe a progression of obligations to the company. There are by and by seven key obligations systematized under the Companies Act 2006 segments 171 to 177, which mirror the precedent-based law and fair standards. These may not be restricted, deferred or contracted out of, however organizations may purchase protection to take care of directors for costs in case of breach. The solutions for penetrates of obligation were not arranged, yet keep precedent-based law and value, and incorporate remuneration for misfortunes, compensation of ill-conceived gains and explicit execution or directives.

Corporate Governance

It communicated that different rules, recommendations and rules structure the rule of corporate organization inside the UK, for instance, exclusively based law rules, for instance, trustee commitments of bosses, secured reports of an association including notice and articles of alliance, form expressly Organizations Act 1985, the presenting rules applying on all associations recorded on the Point Rules or Authority Rundown, the Consolidated Code on

Corporate Administration; be that as it may, the Code’s courses of action are not central, yet it is compulsory for the recorded associations to give their yearly report a declaration showing consistence with the Code and give reasons if not concurring. Keasey, Thompson and Wright (2005) found that the Code is joined by the Smith Direction insinuating audit sheets and evaluators; the Turnbull Direction related to

Code’s internal control need and the Higgs Audit and proposed proposition of good practices. Moreover, non-authentic standards appropriated by bodies addressing institutional monetary trained professionals, for instance, ABI PIRC (the Benefits and Venture Exploration Experts and NAPF are fundamental. All the recorded associations will without a doubt adhere to these standards. Moreover, in case of public associations’ takeovers, Mergers and the rules of the Takeover close by the City Code on Takeovers are important. Additionally, Code of Market Direct of Budgetary Administrations Authority is huge as it relates to the information introduction, which is significantly sensitive and mystery and if it isn’t followed, it might incite make a sham market.

Learn more about Corporate Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Corporate Law in United Arab Emirates (UAE)

The corporate law of UAE regulates all the aspects of a company and its management right from governance to finance of the company. Each emirate has its own corporate code.

Types of Business License

There are primarily four types of business licenses provided in UAE, which are professional, commercial, industrial and tourism. Services offered by the various professionals like doctors and others, artisans and craftsmen get a professional license. Trading and commercial activities come under the ambit of commercial licenses, given that these activities are undertaking with the intensions of making profits. Industrial and manufacturing activities are carried out under the industrial license. Lastly, all activities related to tourism like hospitality and travel are covered under tourism license.

Jurisdiction of the company

There are only three jurisdictions that are followed in UAE for formation of a company, there are Mainland, Free Zone and Offshore and all company are divided into these three jurisdictions. These jurisdictions are separate licensing authorities, the mainland is licensed by Department of Economic Development of the respective emirates, which the Free Zone will be licensed by the relevant free zone authority and so will the offshore authority. In the cases of commercial as well as industrial licenses, UAE National holds/owns 51% shares and 49% is held by the expat partner. While in professional license, 100% shares are owned by expat partner but UAE national is appointed as a Local Service Agent.

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

It is the most common form of registered organisation and is recommended where the purpose of the entity is to make sales within the region. An entity with a 100% foreign ownership is not allowed in UAE.  Under the Commercial Companies Law (CCL) of the UAE the foreign investors are allowed to own 49% of equity shares in national companies and 51% at all times by one or more UAE nationals.

LLC under article 218 of CCL can be formed by minimum of 1 and maximum of 50 shareholders who are limited to the liability of their share capital in the company. In the latest amendments to article 217 of CCL minimum share capital requirement is removed allowing founders of a limited liability company the freedom to determine the company’s share capital. MoA or management contract appoints managers and a LLC must appoint one manager and maximum of five managers for business for a fixed or unlimited term. They have fill managerial and administration power, but the LLC is not allowed to practice its activities without Trade License and Commercial Registration Certificate.

Branch/Representative Office

A branch or representative office has the identical legal personality as its parent company as well as operates business under the name of its parent company. The branch or representative office carries out similar activities to that of the parent company. However they are not permitted to carry on business of importing products of the parent company, as this function can only be carried on by local trade agents. In a few instances the representative office of a foreign company are required to obtain an additional license from UAE ministry of Economy. A UAE national must be appointed as a ‘service agent’ for the branch or representative office.

Civil Company

This is a company for the professional like doctors, lawyers, engineers and accountants in UAE. Except the engineering civil company all others are a 100% owned by professional partners. However, a UAE National Local Services Agent is a mandatory. A foreign company can be a partner in a civil company, as long as the foreign company is in the same field as the civil company.

Learn more about Corporate Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Comparative Analysis and Conclusion

There is a vast and major difference among laws in US, UK and UAE. The first and the foremost difference is that of Language. While in USA and UK the entire corporate law is in English (which may differ from each other, American English in the states and British English in UK), the law and agreements are primarily in Arabic, and if written in English, have to be deciphered in Arabic. Arabic is preferred over English in UAE.

In the USA, undertakings are at various levels, i.e., government law, state law, and the close by law/local laws. Of course, in the UAE, an individual body picks the rules, and all the organizations require to expect quick to remember. In the USA, cover rules are given to be clung to and further the state applies the relatable standards close by the associations which breaker rules into their by-laws. With the ultimate objective of expense assortment, each level powers its own evaluation which the organization needs to pay. State laws are particular in every one of the 50 states. This grows the multifaceted idea of the pattern of business. The association is restricted by first the public authority rules, by then the state rules, ultimately the local standards. UAE has a uniform system. The organization close by explicit associations picks the rules for all the associations and there is no centre level. Both for the territory associations the ones in smoothed out business zones, there is only one level at which the rules are set down similarly as the obligation procedure is taken.

In UAE, the business and the piece of the business are treated as free substances and the pay made from the branch is considered as the pay of the branch itself, however, in the USA, the branch is treated as a bit of the business and not a unit of the business. Hereafter, the evaluation to be charged on that particular branch is charged on that of the whole business.

The fundamental principles of the UAE give confined commitment to the financial specialists of the association as the business and the speculators are seen as free substances. USA gives a decision to the owners of the association to either get troubled freely on the business and the speculator’s compensation comparably as UAE or the other option is get the business pay in like manner troubled as the owner’s own personal compensation. Regardless, for the resulting decision, certain conditions are to meet.

Definitively, the relationship of corporate organization practices and laws of the UK and the U.S. are similar or there is an indistinguishable standard. Regardless, for associations and their in-house managing, the changing embodiment of the definitive scene of the two countries propels various troubles. Believe it or not, after the deplorable budgetary crisis of 2008 and 2009, the laws demand totally recorded associations to hold quick to code of ethics and related laws and rules. Considering, it has been dependable with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and 2004 Act; nevertheless, for non-U.S. firms, SEC has been extraordinarily obliging giving them an open entryway through avoidances to develop their associations as they may go up against conflicting challenges considering neighbourhood laws. In the U.S., SOX expect a critical part for effective corporate organization while in the UK, Demonstration 2004, Smith Direction and various laws coordinate to clear money related itemizing.

Learn more about Corporate Laws with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Categories
Blog

Role of Consumer Protection Law in Medical Negligence cases

By: Sreyasi Sarma

Abstract

Medical profession is a noble profession. The connection between the patient and the specialist depends on shared trust and confidence. It is a helpful weapon of shopper to guarantee responsibility of specialist organizations. The patients have begun utilizing this Act, when they are abused by clinical carelessness of the medical services. Each specialist independent of the spot of his administration has an expert commitment to broaden his administration for ensuring life. Inadequacy might be consequence of powerlessness and absence of competency while carelessness would be brought about via lack of regard. In all instances of carelessness, there will be lack yet in all instances of inadequacy, carelessness won’t be available. The Indian legal executive has excellent help in securing and protecting the privileges of the customers just as sharpening the general public concerning the privileges of the customers. The analyst through some case laws endeavour to zero in upon the legal activism on clinical carelessness risk under the Consumer Protection Act.

Introduction:

Recently, Indian culture is encountering a developing mindfulness with respect to patient’s privileges. This pattern is unmistakably detectable from the ongoing spray in suit concerning clinical expert or foundation obligation, guaranteeing redressal for the enduring caused because of clinical carelessness, vitiated assent, and penetrate of privacy emerging out of the specialist persistent relationship. The patient-focused activity of rights assurance is needed to be acknowledged in the monetary setting of the fast decay of State spending and gigantic private interest in the circle of the medical services framework and the Indian Supreme Court’s meticulous endeavours to Constitutionalize a privilege to wellbeing as a principal right. Starting at now, the arbitrating cycle concerning clinical expert obligation, be it in a purchaser discussion or a normal common or criminal court, considers precedent-based law standards identifying with carelessness, vitiated assent, and penetrate of classification. In any case, it is similarly basic to take note of that the assurance of patient’s privilege will not be at the expense of expert honesty and self-rule. There is certainly a requirement for finding some kind of harmony. Something else, the outcomes would be illogical.

With regards to acquiring measures, there is a meriting need for a two dimensional methodology. On one hand, the attractive heading focuses towards recognizable proof of least sensible principles considering the social, conservative, and social setting that would encourage the adjudicators to choose issues of expert risk on a goal premise. Then again, such distinguishing proof empowers the clinical experts to disguise such norms in their everyday release of expert obligations, which would ideally forestall to an enormous degree the situation of assurance of patient’s privileges in a litigative atmosphere. Over the long haul, the present antagonistic arrangement of specialist and the patient would go through a change to the benefit of the patient, specialist, and society on the loose.

In the law of carelessness, experts, for example, attorneys, specialists, engineers and others are remembered for the classification of people purporting some extraordinary ability or gifted people by and large. Any errand which is needed to be performed with an extraordinary ability would commonly be conceded or attempted to be performed just if the individual has the essential expertise for playing out that task. Any sensible man going into a calling which requires a specific degree of figuring out how to be known as an expert of that branch, impliedly guarantees the individual managing him that the aptitude which he purports will be practised with a sensible level of care and alert. On a similar relationship, this guarantees the patients that a specialist has the imperative expertise in the clinical calling which he is rehearsing and keeping in mind that endeavour the presentation of the errand depended to him he would practice his ability with sensible skill. Decided by this norm, a proficient including clinical expert might be held obligated for carelessness on one of two discoveries: possibly he was not had of the essential expertise which he proclaimed to have had, or, he didn’t work out, with sensible ability in the given case, the aptitude which he had.

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

The norm to be applied for judging, if the individual charged has been careless, would be that of a customary equipped individual practising common ability in that calling. It isn’t vital for each expert to have the most elevated level of aptitude in that branch which he rehearses. Where a calling grasps a scope of perspectives with respect to what is an adequate norm of direct, the ability of the expert is to be decided by the most minimal standard that would be viewed as worthy. The test is the norm of the customary gifted man practising and maintaining to have that extraordinary ability. A man need not have the most noteworthy master ability; it is entrenched law that it is adequate in the event that he practices the normal expertise of a common skilled man practicing that specific workmanship.

Hence, an expert man should order the corpus of information which structures part of the expert hardware of the common individual from his calling. He ought not linger behind other common steady and clever individuals from his calling in the information on new advances, disclosures and improvements in his field. He ought to have such mindfulness as a normally able professional would have of the insufficiencies in his insight and the impediments on his ability. He should be aware of the dangers and dangers in any expert assignment, he attempts to the degree that other conventionally skillful individuals from the calling would be ready. He should bring to any expert undertaking he attempts no less mastery, ability and care than other usually skilled individuals from his calling would bring yet require bring no more.

To build up risk on that premise it must be appeared

(1) that there is a typical and ordinary practice;

(2) that the respondent has not embraced it; and

(3) that the course indeed embraced is one no expert man of conventional aptitude would have taken had he been acting with normal consideration.

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

A clinical specialist can’t be held at risk essentially on the grounds that things turned out badly from incident or misfortune or through a blunder of judgment in picking one sensible course of treatment in the inclination of another. A clinical expert would be obligated just where his lead fell beneath that of the norms of a sensibly equipped.

Legal INTERPRETATION OF MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE LIABILITY

Overall, the accompanying lawful issues have been tended to and reacted to by various discussions and Courts in India.

Charge of Medical Negligence against Professional Doctors

From the hour of Lord Denning up to this point it has been held in a few decisions that a charge of expert carelessness against the clinical expert remained on an alternate balance from a charge of carelessness against the driver of an engine vehicle. The weight of verification is correspondingly more prominent on the individual who charges carelessness against a specialist. With the best ability on the planet, things here and there turned out badly in clinical treatment or careful activity. A specialist was not to be held careless essentially on the grounds that something turned out badly. The National Commission, just as the Apex Court in a catena of choices, has held that the specialist isn’t subject for carelessness in view of another person of better aptitude or information would have endorsed an alternate treatment or worked in an alternate manner. He isn’t liable of carelessness on the off chance that he has acted as per the training acknowledged as legitimate by a sensible group of clinical experts. The Hon’ble Supreme Court on account of Dr Laxman Balkrishna versus Dr Trimbak, AIR 1969 SC 128, has held the above view that is as yet viewed as a milestone judgment for choosing an instance of carelessness. On account of Indian Medical Association versus Santha, the Apex Court has concluded that the expertise of a clinical professional varies from specialist to specialist and it is officeholder upon the Complainant to demonstrate that a specialist was careless in the line of treatment that brought about the life of the patient. Along these lines, a Judge can see a specialist as blameworthy just when it is demonstrated that he has missed the mark concerning the norm of sensible clinical consideration. The standard of Res-Ipsa-Loquitur has not been commonly trailed by the Consumer Courts in India including the National Commission or even by the Apex Court in choosing the case under this Act. In a catena of choices, it has been held that it is for the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness or insufficiency in assistance by illustrating master proof or sentiment and this reality is to be demonstrated past all sensible questions. The simple charge of carelessness will be of no assistance to the Complainant.[1]

What Constitutes Medical Negligence?

Disappointment of an activity and results are not carelessness. The term carelessness is characterized as the nonattendance or absence of care that a sensible individual ought to have taken in the conditions of the case. In the claim of carelessness for a situation of wrist drop, the accompanying perceptions were made. Nothing has been referenced in the protest or in the grounds of allure about the sort of care wanted from the specialist wherein he fizzled. It isn’t said anyplace what kind of carelessness was finished over the span of the activity. Nerves might be chopped down at the hour of activity and simple cutting of a nerve doesn’t add up to carelessness. It isn’t said that it has been intentionally done. Actually, it is additionally not said that the nerves were cut in the activity and it was not cut at the hour of the mishap. No master proof at all has been created. Just the report of the Chief Medical Officer of Haridwar has been delivered wherein it said that the patient is an instance of post-horrible wrist drop. It isn’t said that it is because of any activity or the carelessness of the specialist. The simple claim won’t present out a defence of carelessness except if it is demonstrated by solid proof and is upheld by master proof. The facts demonstrate that the activity has been performed. It is likewise evident that the Complainant has numerous costs yet except if the carelessness of the specialist is demonstrated, she isn’t qualified for any compensation.[2]

What is the Standard of Care?

It is currently a settled standard of law that a clinical expert will bring to his assignment a sensible level of expertise and information and must exercise a sensible level of care. Neither the most noteworthy nor the least level of care and fitness decided in the light of conditions for each situation is the thing that the law requires. Decided from this measuring stick, post-employable contamination or shortening of the leg was not because of any carelessness or insufficiency in help with respect to the contrary party Appellant. Inadequacy in help subsequently can’t be attached on the inverse party.[3]

For a situation that prompted visual impedance as a result, the accompanying perceptions were made. The writing concerning largo unmistakably referenced that the symptom of this medication whenever taken for a more extended length can influence visual perception however this isn’t a reality for this situation. Plus, there is no master proof on record to show that the utilization of this medication made harm the patient’s visual perception. In any event, for the wellbeing of argument, on the off chance that it is acknowledged that this medication made harm the patient’s vision, if the Respondent-specialist is one who has encouraged his patient to utilize this medication after an assessment in which he discovered the patient to be experiencing jungle fever, all things considered too the specialist Respondent can’t be held liable of carelessness or insufficient in his administration. In any case, as expressed above, for this situation, the medication has been utilized by the patient in low portions for a couple of days and there is no master proof to show that the utilization of medication has influenced his vision. Thusly, the Complainant-Appellant has neglected to demonstrate that the Respondent was careless and insufficient in his obligation as a doctor.[4]

Verification of Medical Negligence

It has been held in various decisions by the National Commission and by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that a charge of expert carelessness against a specialist remained on an alternate balance from a charge of carelessness against a driver of a vehicle. The weight of evidence is correspondingly more noteworthy on the individual who affirms carelessness against a specialist. Even with a specialist with the best aptitudes, things now and then turn out badly during clinical treatment or in a medical procedure. A specialist isn’t to be held careless essentially in light of the fact that something turned out badly. The Complainant’s vision was not re-established after the activity was led by the Appellant yet on this ground alone a specialist cannot be held careless in light of the fact that even in the wake of receiving every vital insurance and care the aftereffect of the activity may not be agreeable since it relies upon different variables. The dispute of the Appellant was that the patient was experiencing diabetes and circulatory strain and in numerous such cases, visual perception isn’t re-established after the activity anyway cautiously it is finished. For this situation, there isn’t anything on record to show that something turned out badly because of a demonstration of the Appellant-specialist. There is no proof to arrive at the resolution that the Appellant fell beneath the norm of a sensibly equipped expert in their field, to such an extent that their leaders may be meriting reproach. The Appellant can’t be subject for carelessness since another person of better ability or information would have endorsed an alternate technique for activity in an alternate manner. The proof proposes that the Appellant has played out the activity and acted as per the training routinely acknowledged and received by him in this clinic and a few patients are consistently treated for their eye issues. The Hon’ble Supreme Court on account of Dr Laxman Balkrishna versus Dr Triambak, AIR 1969 Supreme Court page 128 has held the above view and this view has been additionally affirmed on account of the Indian Medical Association versus Santha. The Apex Court and the National Commission has held that the aptitude of a clinical expert contrasts from specialist to specialist and it is an occupant upon the Complainant to demonstrate that the Appellant was careless in the line of treatment that brought about the deficiency of visual perception. A Judge can see a specialist as blameworthy just when it is demonstrated that he has missed the mark regarding a norm of sensible clinical consideration. The reality and conditions of the case before us show that the Appellant has taken care of the patient with due consideration, expertise, and determination. Basically, in light of the fact that the patient’s vision was not re-established acceptably, this record alone isn’t just for holding the specialist blameworthy of carelessness and inadequate in his obligation. It is settled law that it is for the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness or inadequacy in help by illustrating master proof or sentiment and this reality is to be demonstrated past all sensible uncertainty. A simple claim of carelessness will be of no assistance to the Complainant. [5]

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

The accompanying instances of supposed clinical carelessness give an understanding into how a ultimate choice is reached by the legal bodies. “All clinical carelessness cases concern different inquiries of reality, when we state the weight of demonstrating carelessness lies on the Complainant, it implies he has the undertaking of persuading the court that his adaptation of the realities is the right one”. No master feeling has been delivered by the Complainant to repudiate the report of the Board of Doctors. The allure of the Complainant was excused with costs as “No master feeling has been created by him.”[8] For a situation of an inappropriate association of the patella, no master has been delivered by the Complainant to demonstrate the carelessness of the contrary party. Accordingly, it can’t be said with a precision that therapy of the Complainant by the contrary party was against the standards recommended under the clinical statute or that the contrary party in any capacity was careless or inadequate in the presentation of his duties. [6]

“Charge of clinical carelessness is a major issue and it is for the individual who sets up the case to demonstrate carelessness dependent on the material on a record or via proof”. The objection of clinical carelessness was excused in light of the fact that the candidate neglected to build up and demonstrate any case of clinical negligence.[7] “Just on the grounds that the activity didn’t succeed, the specialist can’t be supposed to be careless” and the allure of the specialist was allowed.[8] “A simple claim won’t present a defence of carelessness except if it is demonstrated by solid proof and is upheld by master proof” and the allure was dismissed. “The commission can’t establish itself into a specialist body and repudiate the assertion of the specialist except if there is something opposite on the record via a specialist assessment or there is any clinical composition on which dependence could be based” and the Revision appeal of the specialist was allowed. For another situation, an X-beam report showed a little mistiness that like a hazy shadow that gets obvious for some causes other than math. It couldn’t be accepted that actually, stone existed in the correct kidney that had not been worked upon. Considering the present situation, we don’t feel that any instance of carelessness has been made by the Complainant. This request is, subsequently, allowed.[9]

RECENT SUPREME COURT DECISION AND CONCLUSION

Before the instance of Jacob Mathew versus the State of Punjab, the Supreme Court of India conveyed two distinct assessments on specialists’ obligation. In Mohanan versus Prabha G Nair and another, it decided that a specialist’s carelessness could be found out simply by filtering the material and master proof that may be introduced during a preliminary. In Suresh Gupta’s case in August 2004 the norm of carelessness that must be demonstrated to fix a specialist’s or specialist’s criminal risk was set at “net carelessness” or “wildness.”

In Suresh Gupta’s case, the Supreme Court recognized a mistake of judgment and at fault carelessness. It held that criminal indictment of specialists without sufficient clinical sentiment highlighting their blame would do an extraordinary damage to the network. A specialist can’t be gone after for at fault or criminal carelessness in all instances of clinical setbacks or incidents.

A specialist might be at risk in a common case for carelessness however simple remissness or need of due consideration and aptitude can’t be portrayed as so wild or terribly careless as to make her/him criminally obligated. The courts held that this qualification was important so the perils of clinical experts being presented to common risk may not absurdly stretch out to criminal obligation and open them to the danger of detainment for supposed criminal carelessness. Consequently, the grievance against the specialist must show carelessness or imprudence of such an extent as to demonstrate a psychological express that can be portrayed as absolutely indifferent towards the patient. Such gross carelessness alone is culpable.

On September 9, 2004, Justices Arijit Pasayat and CK Thakker alluded the subject of clinical carelessness to a bigger Bench of the Supreme Court. They saw that words, for example, “net”, “wild”, “capability”, and “apathy” didn’t happen anyplace in the meaning of “carelessness” under Section 304A of the Indian Penal Code and subsequently they couldn’t concur with the judgment conveyed on account of Dr Suresh Gupta.

The issue was chosen in the Supreme Court on account of Jacob Mathew versus the State of Punjab. The court guided the focal government to outline rules to spare specialists from pointless provocation and unjustifiable weight in playing out their obligations. It decided that until the public authority outlined such rules, the accompanying rules would win:

A private grievance of carelessness or carelessness against a specialist may not be engaged without by all appearances proof as a sound assessment of another skilled specialist supporting the charge. What’s more, the exploring official should offer a free input, ideally of an administration specialist. At long last, a specialist might be captured just if the examining official accepts that she/he would not be accessible for indictment except if captured.

[1] Smt. Savitri Singh v. Dr. Ranbir PD. Singh and others. 2004;(1) CPJ 25 (Bihar)

[2] Smt. Vimlesh Dixit v. Dr. R.K. Singhal. 2004;(I) CPJ 123

[3] Dr. Kamta Prasad Singh v. Nagina Prasad. 2000;(III) CPJ 283 (WB)

[4] Ajay Kumar v. Dr. Devendra Nath. 2004;(II) CPJ 482.

[5] Dr. Akhil Kumar Jain v. Lallan Prasad. 2004;(II) CPJ 504.

[6] Amar Singh v. Frances Newton Hospital and Anr. 2001;(I) CPJ 8.

[7] Mam Chand v. Dr. GS Mangat of Mangat Hospital. 2004;(I) CPJ 79

[8] Dr. (Smt) Kumud Garg v. Raja Bhatia. 2004;(I) CPJ 369.

[9] Dr. Harkanwaljit Singh Saini v. Gurbax Singh and Anr. 2003;(I) CPJ 153

 

Learn more about Medical Negligence with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Sukrith Legal!

Categories
Blog

Analysis of Trademark Laws in USA, UK, and UAE

Trademarks are, generally, words, names, symbols, devices, designs, or other distinctive signs or stamps which serve to recognize the wellspring of merchandise or benefits and recognize them from those sold by others.[1] Trademarks are usually of names, logos, symbols, devices, etc., representing an individual entity. For instance, the ‘M’ for McDonald’s has a ‘™’ to it specifying the distinction of its source.

Trademarks are essential as they show how viable the product is. They have been used by companies that have a brand value attached to them. It offers quality and ensures the customers’ product safety is received; this also saves the company from fraudulent misuse of their brand name or logo.

Trademarks promote enterprise, both locally and globally, by providing owners of trademarks with recognition and profit. Trademark protection also hinders unfair competitors’ efforts, such as counterfeiters, to use similar distinctive signs to market their products and services. Trademark law allows people with skill and enterprise to produce and market goods and services more profitably, thereby facilitating domestic and international trade. Moreover, trademarks can protect consumers from unwittingly paying a premium for inferior products.[2]

Learn more about Intellectual Property with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

Brands play a significant role in the socio-economical out a way for the people. The quality of a product is essential in the growth of a brand and the shareholders. To facilitate the whole system of intellectual property, independent trademark laws have been brought out in countries for the ease of business and to protect the companies against fraud.

Rochelle Dreyfuss observes that, in recent years, trademarks have begun to serve an additional purpose, of “becoming products in their own right, valued as indicators of the status, preferences, and aspirations of those who use them.[3] As putting the concept in simple terms by Robert N Klieger, the Trademark makes tomorrow’s business something more than an accident.[4]

US Laws

The US trademark framework accommodates both government and state assurance of brand names. Regardless of whether under government or state law, enlistment is anything but essential for enforceable rights. The principal statute dealing with Trademark and unfair competition law in the United States is the Lanham Act, 15 USC Section 1051 et seq. The Act had been altered on various occasions since its effective date more than 70 years ago. The amendments have, among other things, made dilution of famous trademarks a federal offense; provided statutory damages as a remedy against sellers of goods bearing counterfeit marks; permitted the filing of applications for registration based on an intent to use, and created a private cause of action against cybersquatting.[5]

The Lanham Act governs the enforcement of trademarks, service marks, and unfair competition. It provides authority from the USPTO, which is the US Patent and Trademark Office, to register marks used in interstate or foreign commerce.[6] As a general rule, registration is not expected to get brand name rights or authorize a brand name. Instead, the first body to use a distinctive mark, in the beginning, to utilize a particular mark in business may guarantee rights to that Trademark for the merchandise or organizations with which the imprint is utilized. The proprietor of an unregistered trademark may not use the ‘®’ mark, as it may be used only proceeding or in connection with a registered mark; however, the holder of an unregistered mark might use the ‘™’ symbol to put others on the announcement that it claims rights to a mark.[7]

Learn more about Intellectual Property with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

As the US Supreme Court has suggested that a trademark is an elaborative form to display the quality of production and to maintain the benefits of a good reputation.[8] Therefore, in the US system, the goodwill is considered over the registration and substantive clauses. The Supreme Court, while quoting the  same stated, “In truth, a trademark confers no monopoly whatever in a correct sense, but is merely a convenient means for facilitating the protection of one’s goodwill in trade by placing a distinguishing mark or symbol-a commercial signature-upon the produce or the package in which it is sold.”[9] Trademark rights can be lost through indecorous licensing, assignment, genericity, or abandonment. If the use of a trademark is licensed without adequate quality control or supervision by the trademark owner, the Trademark will be cancelled. [10]

The language of the statue is somehow or another predictable, with this limited the vision of the extent of Federal protection. Under the Act, a firm initially should select an imprint that is equipped for recognizing its merchandise. Under state law, a trademark need not be famous in order to give rise to a weakening claim. Instead, dilution is available if-

(1) the mark has “selling power” or, in other words, a distinctive quality; and

(2) the two marks are substantially similar. [11]

The steady development in the subject matter and scope of trademark law has not gone disregarded, and legal scholars have long called warnings about the dangers of overly well-developed trademark rights.[12] The laws are based on the gravity of good-faith and the vitality of the owner. If any hindrance is found from the plaintiff, the court decides based on natural justice.

UK Laws

The United Kingdom has a history of trademarks and indictive marks on its products from the 16th Century before the rule of King James I. All these rules were merely in good conscience, and finally, the these were complied with and codified in the Trade Marks Registration Act 1875. These gave the traders a sense of ethics and gave powerful rights to their proprietors and are very important and valuable assets.

Trademark registration is a fairly more organized sector in the United Kingdom as compared to the United States. For the application of a registered trademark, a body has to do the following-

  1. They can register a trademark by applying to the United Kingdom Intellectual Property Office (abbreviated to the UKIPO).[13]
  2. The second option is to file an application with the EU Intellectual Property Office (abbreviated to the EUIPO). The main profit of applying for an EU trademark is it covers all EU member states (including the UK), so you save the money and time of having to make distinct applications in multiple national intellectual property offices.[14]
  3. Lastly, an application can be made using the Madrid Protocol. This allows a home trademark recording or application to form the basis of an application for a so-called international registration. This claim is filed with the International Bureau of the World Intellectual Property Office (or WIPO).[15]

It is to be standard that the trademark laws of the United Kingdom include England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Irelands, and the Isle of Man, and the people of these can only apply for Trademark by the following process. Due to the high level of harmonization in trademark law within the European Union and its member states, Brexit will have a substantial effect on trademark protection in the United Kingdom. First, Brexit would mean that EU trademark protection would no longer extend to the United Kingdom. Not even an often-mooted membership of the EEA as a form of soft Brexit would enable the unitary right to extend to the United Kingdom.[16]

Implementation of trademark rights in the United Kingdom is predominately a civil matter. Both recorded Trademark and passing-off entitlements can be outlooked in the High Court (Chancery Division), as well as in the IP Enterprise Court. Judges in these courts tend to be IP experts. Claims at the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court can be multi-track or small entitlements track; the track chosen has inferences for the remedies available to the proprietors. The ensuing part features an unusually large number of cases this year in relation to “exhaustion of rights” which provide an important role in ensuring free movement of goods within the single market of the claimant.[17]

The administrator of a mark cannot exercise total control over every use of the Trademark; he will, however, be able to an agreement with it like most other property rights by, for example, by assigning, licensing, and mortgaging it. [18]This view surfaced in Arsenal v Reed[19] where it was held that the primary function of a trademark is the origin function.

EU trademark law contains a variety of specific defenses and other limitations on the exclusive rights conferred upon Trademark the EU. Set out under Article 15 of the 2017 EUTM Regulation and Article 7 of the 2008 TM Directive, “exhaustion” acts as a limitation of the exclusive rights provided to EU trademark owners.[20]

UAE Laws

The trademarks in UAE is similar to that seen under the general concept that trademarks are names, words, signatures, letters, figures, illustrations, logos, titles, hallmarks, seals, pictures, patterns, declarations, packets, or any other symbols or group of marks if they were used or proposed to be used either to extricate goods, products or services from whatever sources, or to show that certain services, belongings or products belong to the owner of the Trademark, because of their delivery, manufacturing, selection or trading. The voice accompanying a trademark is considered a part of it. [21]It is governed by the Federal Law No. 37 of 1992 on Trademarks.

The enlisted brand name will be under legitimate assurance in UAE for a long time since the date of authentic TM enrolment. To keep the brand name in power following ten years – the proprietor should pay extra authority fess to the UAE Ministry of Economy for additional augmentation. The amount of expansions for brand name endorsements isn’t restricted.

The UAE Trademark Law contains no direct causes of action for what is frequently referred to as ‘trademark infringement’ in other jurisdictions. Rather, Articles 37 and 38 set out criminal offences focused on fabricating and emulating trademarks. The phrasing of the offenses can make it problematic to bring actions against anything other than the direct counterfeit.[22]

Learn more about Intellectual Property with Enhelion’s Online Law course certified by Scriboard Advocates and Legal Consultants! 

The lawsuit before the courts includes very little oral advocacy. Instead, written pleadings are exchanged during each hearing. There are usually several rounds of pleadings before the court adjourns to issue its decision. Cases are heard by the bench; there are no jury trials.[23] The work of witnesses to provide oral evidence – particularly in civil cases – is possible but very rare. Authorities may be appointed by the court to provide an opinion on technical or complex matters.[24] The UAE is expected to implement the GCC Trade Mark Law in the coming months. The government has also announced the setting up of specialized IP Courts, which are expected to be in operation soon.[25]

The Trademark Law likewise gives criminal solutions for the encroachment of brand names as fines and additionally detainment. You can likewise make a move against brand name encroachments through Dubai Customs, which has the order to quit encroaching items prior to entering the nation, in this way making your brand name assurance more productive and secure.

Therefore, it is seen that trademarks all over the world are similar and follow the common strategies laid down by the World Trade Organisation. A trademark is the most valuable asset of a business to upkeep its prestige; therefore, it is more important to register the business trademark and to keep an updated. Usually, a trademark is registered for ten years, depending on the laws of each country. It is important to maintain trademarks by brands, especially well-developed brands. Any counterfeit in the following should be brought into action in the courts as many countries have

[1] Brian Farkas, Which Protection Do I Need: Patent, Copyright, or Trademark? NOLO, https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/which-protection-do-i-need-patent-copyright-or-trademark.html

[2] Michael Cosgrove et al, Case Study:  Trademark Infringement Issues,7 JOURNAL OF BUSINESS CASE STUDIES,19, 19-26 (2011)

[3]Jeanne C. Fromer, The Role of Creativity in Trademark Law, 86 THE NOTRE DAME LAW REVIEW,1885, 1892-93,(2011)

[4] Ibid.

[5] Roberta Jacobs & Lesley McCall Grossberg,United States, THE LAW REVIEWS,(Oct 2019), https://thelawreviews.co.uk/edition/the-trademarks-law-review-edition-3/1209926/united-states

[6] Jessica Hiney &Lisa M Mottes, Trademark procedures and strategies: United States, WTR, (29 Mar 2017), https://www.worldtrademarkreview.com/portfolio-management/trademark-procedures-and-strategies-united-states

[7] Ibid.

[8] Park ‘N Fly, Inc. v. Dollar Park ‘N Fly, Inc., 469 U.S. 189, 198 (1985)

[9] United Drug Co. v. Theodore Rectanus Co, 248 U.S. 90 (1918).

[10] TradeMark Law, HG.ORG, https://www.hg.org/trademark-law.html

[11] Mead Data Central, Inc. v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc., 875 F.2d 1026 (2d Cir. 1989).

[12] Ralph S. Brown, Jr., Advertising and the Public Interest: Legal Protection of Trade Symbols, 57 Yale L.J. 1165, 1177-80 (1948)

[13] Charlie Bond, UK: The Basics of Trade Mark Law, MONDAQ, (Nov 20,2017), https://www.mondaq.com/uk/trademark/648042/the-basics-of-trade-mark-law

[14] Ibid

[15] Ibid

[16] Marc Mimler, The Effect of Brexit on Trademarks, Designs and Other “Europeanized” Areas of Intellectual Property Law in the United Kingdom, British Institute of Comparative and Operative Law, (Dec 2017), http://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/31199/1/Brexit%20Paper%20no.7.pdf

[17] https://www.worldtrademarkreview.com/portfolio-management/trademark-procedures-and-strategies-united-kingdom

[18] All Answers Ltd. November 2018. Trademark Systems in the UK. [online]. Available from: https://www.lawteacher.net/free-law-essays/business-law/trademark-systems-in-the-uk-business-law-essay.php?vref=1

[19][2003] EWCA Civ 696

[20] Trademark Infringement, 109 TRADEMARK REP. 532 (2019).

[21] Intellectual Property, Information & services, https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/business/intellectual-property

[22]  David Harper,UAE – Trademark Litigation 2017 (A global guide), CWB LEGAL, (Oct 21,2016), http://www.cwblegal.com/trademark-litigation-2017-global-guide-uae/

[23] Ibid.

[24] Ibid.

[25] Maria Farrukh Irfan Khan, Trade mark litigation in the United Arab Emirates: overview, UNITED TRADE MARK & PATENT SERVICES,(Sept 01, 2018), https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/w-011-8550?transitionType=Default&contextData=(sc.Default)&firstPage=true#co_anchor_a192792

 

Categories
Blog

What is the difference between IPC and CrPC?

What is the difference between IPC[1] and CrPC[2]?

According to the National Crime Records Bureau, in 2018, India registered more than 50 lakh criminal cases. It is vital for the citizens of any country to know the laws and understand the differences between their applications. The maxim: Ignorantia Juris Non-excusat (Ignorance of the law is not an excuse) is embedded in the Indian Penal Code. Ignorance of Law or lack of knowledge does not stand as a defence in the court of law. India, as a country has more than 1200 laws in existence. However, crimes in India are regulated by:

  1. Indian Penal Code, 1862
  2. Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
  3. Indian Evidence Act, 1872

 

The criminal justice system in India is divided into two parts:

  1. First Part: Substantive Criminal Laws

These laws provide for the punishments for the offenders by the extent of the crime committed.

 

  1. Second Part: Procedural Law

This law provides a process for establishing the offenders’ guilt and imposing the punishment prescribed under the substantive criminal laws.

  • The Indian Penal Code, 1862

The Code is the country’s primary criminal Code and was drafted during the British Raj in the year 1850 and was presented to the then Legislative Council in the year 1856. It came into force on 01st January 1862.

The Code covers various offences (divided into multiple categories) and the related punishments for the said crimes. For instance, Crimes against the body (Murder, kidnapping, Culpable homicide, etc.), Crimes against property (theft, dacoity, etc.), Economic crimes (Cheating and Counterfeiting) and various other crimes.

  • Criminal Procedure Code, 1973

The Code is the procedural law which provides a detailed procedure for punishments under the penal laws. It thereby enforces and administers the Indian Penal Code and various other substantive criminal laws. The Parliament enacted the Code on 25th January 1974 to consolidate and amend the law relating to Criminal Procedure.

The Criminal Procedure Code is read along with the Indian Penal Code, 1862 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. There often exists a state of perplexity concerning the difference between the Indian Penal Code, 1862 and the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973. Let us now look at the differences between the two legislations.

 

Difference between the Indian Penal Code, 1862 and Criminal Procedure Code, 1973

  1. The Indian Penal Code is a substantive law[3], whereas the Criminal Procedure Code is procedural law.[4]
  2. The Indian Penal Code states various crimes and classifies them into multiple categories. The Code also prescribes the penalties and the punishment for the respective offences. On the other hand, the Criminal Procedure Code defines the procedure that the police take to investigate any violation after having committed any crime mentioned under the penal laws.
  3. The Indian Penal Code aims to provide a primary penal code in the country for giving punishment to the wrongdoers. On the other hand, the Criminal Procedure Code’s main motive is to provide for binding procedures that must be enacted during the administration of a criminal trial.
  4. The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 provides for the courts and Magistrate’s powers, while the Indian Penal Code does not.

Let us now take an example to understand the difference between the legislations better.

Izzie to kill Mathew enters his house and murders him by hitting him with a hammer and slitting his throat. Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 defines ‘Murder.’ And Section 302 of the Code prescribes the punishment for the said crime. The section specifies that any person who commits the act will be punished with death or life imprisonment.

How will Izzie be punished for the crime committed?

Murder is a non-bailable and cognizable offence. The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 thus specifies a procedure to be followed to determine the offender’s guilt, whether or not bail will be granted, evidence to be taken into account, trial, investigation and impose the individual penalty.

CONCLUSION

The three primary legislation governing criminal law in India: Indian Penal Code, Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Evidence Act continue to play an essential role in the courts of law for the effective execution and justice administration. Due to the rise in crimes and criminals, it becomes vital for all citizens to learn the country’s primary criminal laws’ fundamental differences.

[1]The full form of IPC is Indian Penal Code

[2] The full form of CrPC is Criminal Procedure Code

[3] Substantive laws refer to those laws that define individuals’ rights and duties and the respective punishment and organizations.

[4] Procedural Laws include those rules that govern the process of determining individuals and organizations’ duties and rights.

 

 

Categories
Blog

Star India Private Limited v. Leo Burnett

– By Apoorva Mishra

The plaintiffs entered into an Agreement dated 9th April, 2000 with Balaji Telefilms Pvt. Ltd., in order to create, compose and produce 262 episodes of a television serial entitled “KYUNKI SAAS BHI KABHI BAHU THI”.  Since then Balaji has produced episodes of the serial and their services were engaged by way of contract of service and as such the plaintiffs are the first copyright owners under Section 17 of the Copyright Act. Balaji has devised the original artistic work depicting inter alia the logo and the title in a peculiar stylized font and containing as its essential features the words “KYUN KI SAAS BHI KABHI BAHU THI” and as per the agreement plaintiffs have become the owner of the said artistic work. The serial had acquired immense goodwill and reputation so much so that the public associate the said serial with plaintiffs and plaintiffs alone. Plaintiffs started endorsing the serial and the characters in form of products and services for a fee. In February 2002, the defendants came up with the commercial for a consumer product “TIDE DETERGENT” telecasting it with a title, “KYONKI BAHU BHI KABHI SAAS BANEGI” and characters of a grandmother, mother-in-law and daughter-in-law, similar to the characters of J.D., Savita, Tulsi as in the serial of the plaintiff. The plaintiffs contended that there has been an infringement of copyright because an average viewer will have an impression that the plaintiffs are endorsing the defendant’s product and there is a connection between plaintiffs in the said serial and the defendants and their product. It is contended that the defendants are not entitled to do so without obtaining the prior consent and/or the permission from the plaintiffs and they have misrepresented the public at large and on account of this plaintiffs have suffered loss due to continuous act of infringement of copyright and passing off of the copy to the defendants.  The matter was brought before the Hon’ble Bombay High Court raising several issues:

First, Have the defendants by making the commercial film, violated and/or infringed the plaintiffs’ copyright in the T.V. serial “KYUN KI SAAS BHI KABHI BAHU THI”?

The court ruled that anything which is not a substantial copy of the film shall not be held liable for copyright infringement. Therefore, defendants by making the commercial film have not violated and/or infringed the plaintiffs’ copyright.

The court has rightly dealt with the above issue, for the second film to infringe the copyright of the first film it has to be the exact copy of that film which is not the case here. The plaintiff’s film is a work of 262 episodes whereas defendant’s advertisement is a work of 30 seconds in which only for 8 to 10 seconds the characters appear as a prelude to the tide detergent. The major and substantial part consists of tide detergent. Nothing is common between the two scripts. The defendants have put in their own independent skill and labour in making of the advertisement whole sole purpose is to promote the Tide detergent. The models are same in both the film. These models are professional and free to contract. There cannot be, therefore, any act which would amount to infringement by using the same models. Even if the idea is borrowed there, can be no copyright in the idea.

Second, Have the plaintiffs’ proved the defendants have infringed the plaintiffs’ artistic work?

The court denying the contentions of the plaintiffs coined the term Originality. Originality merely means effort expanded or that it involves skill, labour and judgment in its creation. Under Section 17 of the Copyright Act, the Author of a work is the owner of the copyright therein. The defendants have contended that the logo consisting of the two hands is a symbol in common use and in the public domain and open to anyone to use. The holding hands well known form of representing the handing over of something from one to another and are a commonly used symbol and they denied on the fact that the plaintiffs have put any skill, labour or some sort of judgement in its creation but has merely taken the lettering style from a source easily available in public domain. Hence, there is no originality, therefore no copyright.

Third, Have the plaintiff’s proved that the defendants are guilty of passing off their reputation and goodwill in the T.V. serial?

The court held that the defendants are not guilty of passing off as they do not satisfy the essentials of passing off per se. Plaintiffs’ serial is shown on Star Plus Channel which is not owned by the plaintiffs. Goodwill does not accrue to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs have no goodwill or reputation. It is the case of the plaintiffs that their serial/film is associated exclusively with the Star Plus Channel by the public and public is well aware that it can be seen only on Star Plus. Also, the T.V. commercial will not cause any harm to the plaintiffs’ serial or their reputation because the field which the plaintiffs’ serial occupies as a film/soap opera is different from the field of defendants’ commercial that of an advertisement of detergent Tide. Even the activity area is also not in common, therefore there is no misrepresentation.

On the facts of this case, there is no fictional character involved like ‘Superman’, ‘Shaktiman’ Teletubbies’. In the serial there are ordinary people in common life who plays the role of some character or the other. At least from the material on record there is nothing special in any, of the characters of which it can be said that they have gained any public recognition for itself with an independent life outside the serial. This, the plaintiffs have failed to establish. It is also not a case of one film against another film and further the defendants are not merchandising any character from the serial by means of their T.V. commercial. There should be in actual character merchandising and not mere potential of character merchandising.

The court, after analysis the entire case, rightly pronounced the judgement in favour the defendants. The defendants are just promoting their consumer product “Tide” via a T.V. commercial which in no way is connected. The field of activity of the plaintiff and defendant are totally different. No likelihood of damage has been caused to the plaintiff. The characters of which the plaintiff claims to be copied are simple general roles of our Indian society and the defendants are simply targeting the audiences of India who will relate easily to these household roles and nothing special that the plaintiffs have done with these characters for which they claim a copyright on them. This isn’t a case of misrepresentation or fraud and no real damage has been caused. No prudent person will confuse the advertisement with plaintiffs’ serial. Moreover, for character merchandising the plaintiffs should prove that the public would look at the character and consider it to represent the plaintiffs or to consider the product in relation in which it is used as has been made with the plaintiffs’ approval. But the plaintiffs have failed to establish this. In my opinion, the defendants have rightly pleaded that they are a major consumer goods Company, well known in their own right and their products including Tide have their own reputation amongst the public; Tide will be associated with the defendants and not with the plaintiffs.

To learn more about Cyber Law in India, stay connected to our blog or head on to our Law Firm Certified Courses and learn from leading law firms in India. [Click Here]

Categories
Blog

Compulsory Licensing of Patents

– By Apoorva Mishra

Compulsory licensing is an involuntary licensing where the licensor is unwilling to grant the license to the willing licensee, but this entire agreement of compulsory licensing is enforced by the state, by which the licensor has to transfer the rightful authorization of the patent to the licensee, against all his wishes. Government is basically the protector and acts as a guardian for the public at large. Therefore, for the benefit of nation, it has the right to grant the patent and next moment take away the patent and patentee’s monopoly over it. The requirements of the society at large supersedes against the rights of the patent holder to answer the pressing public requirements. Following situations may attract compulsory licensing where IP holder:

  • Charges unfair and discriminatory prices; or
  • Limits production of goods and services; or
  • Restricts technical or scientific development of goods and services; or
  • Desecrates consumer welfare.

Internationally, compulsory licensing has been supported saying that it helps in catering to the needs of the public at large and development of developing and underdeveloped countries. Compulsory Licensing has been mandated by several agreements like WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization), Paris Convention for the promotion of industrial property. TRIPS has envisaged several conditions for issuance of compulsory licensing:

  1. The person or company should apply for licensing after 3 years to the grant of patent.
  2. Before applying for compulsory licensing, the person or company should make an attempt for voluntary licensing.
  3. The person or company then should apply to the board for compulsory licensing if the proposed user has made efforts to obtain authorization from the right holder on reasonable commercial terms and conditions and that such efforts have not been successful within a reasonable period of time.

In India, we have seen a growth of many foreign companies reason being they hold knowledge and they rule the terms.  Therefore, there exists a chance that these companies can abuse their positions. Compulsory licensing of IPRs in cases of such abuses would be an apt remedy that will deter these companies from abusing their dominant positions. Keeping in mind Indian conditions compulsory licensing will spur growth and development in Indian industrial sectors. Keeping in mind the size of Indian market the incentive for innovation will not erode to the extent that might deter companies from entering in to innovative endeavours as courts have granted reasonable royalties in cases where compulsory licensing has been awarded. Compulsory licensing will make the products more accessible to public and it will be beneficial for public welfare.

The developing and the under developed countries are not much concerned about protection of patent laws as much as developed countries are because they don’t have resources to spend on development of costly mechanism to ensure protection of patents.

There are few reasons behind this:

  • by allowing piracy, developing and underdeveloped countries can ensure availability of needed goods and services to their citizens at affordable prices
  • The local industries which produce counterfeit goods employee thousands of workers and therefore reduce unemployment.
  • In order to advance in science and technology, they need maximum access to intellectual property of advanced nations.

More than 80% patents in developing and underdeveloped countries are owned by citizens of technologically advanced countries. Consequently, their governments are not willing to spend huge amounts in developing effective administrative mechanism to enforce IPRs of citizens of advanced states.

The Government will, however, pay royalty to the patent holder for using his patent without his permission, but this will in turn discourage the patent holder from making any further inventions or innovations. The discouraged Research & Development shall lead to deteriorating economic growth. The developing or under-developed countries shall refrain from investing in R & D, indirectly affecting the economy, and will settle for generic goods. This might increase the risk of goods turning into inferior quality. Ultimately, as a result of weak intellectual property regime, a country becomes less competitive, and brain drain is an obvious result.

Compulsory licensing becomes inevitable to deal with the situations of “patent suppression”. By incorporating an effective mechanism of compulsory licensing, governments of developing countries may pressurize the patent holders to work the patent to maximum national advantage. The threat of non-voluntary licensing may be helpful in negotiating a reasonable price of the needed drug acceptable to both the patent owner and the government. Compulsory licensing might be necessary in situations where its refusal may prevent utilization of another important invention which can be significant for technological advancement or economic growth.

Compulsory licensing ensures that a good number of producers or manufacturers are there to cater to the needs of society; it spurs competition and consumer welfare. Those who argue against it saying that it leads to erosion in incentive for innovation forget that a right is always accompanied by a corresponding duty, and failure to perform that duty might have its implications in law.

The abuse of patents is a very likely to occur where the patentee has its rights protected under Patent laws. The patent holder has monopoly rights but they are more likely to abuse. The patent holders are often tempted to indulge in to anti-competitive practices and they try to extend their monopoly into areas where they do not have rights protected by IPRs. Software companies like Microsoft, several pharmaceutical companies, as discussed above, are protected under the patent laws and most of the time they are the sole manufacturer. So this gives them an opportunity where they can dictate their terms over the entire market which might lead to exploitation of others right in the market. In such a scenario, compulsory licensing comes into play, which acts as a remedy to abuse of patents, where government intervention leads to increase in the versatility of the market leading to a monopolistic market rather than a monopoly, the consumers have a choice and the product will be easily available, where the opponents have argued that compulsory licensing will lead to discouragement for innovations, but this also true that this will lead to a heated competition, which will in return lead to a peer pressure over the patent holder to work more over his product, get distributers, improve his research and product and make it available to the public at large. This will lead to an increase in the economy. There are reasonable apprehensions that FDI may dry up if compulsory licensing is granted as a remedy, to that essential facility doctrine must be adopted, so that only what is essential and necessary should prevail.

To learn more about Cyber Law in India, stay connected to our blog or head on to our Law Firm Certified Courses and learn from leading law firms in India. [Click Here]